Andrew Hill



by Kage USER (30 Reviews)
August 25th, 2008 | 9 replies

Release Date: 1966 | Tracklist

Review Summary: All the pieces come together for Andrew Hill's masterwork.

The 1960s jazz scene was all about expanding the possibilities, opening new alleyways for jazz to explore. At times it seemed to be a race to the edge, with the mania bleeding over into Europe where it merged with that scene’s sensibilities, as musicians like Peter Brotzmann sought to stretch jazz’s capabilities to the extreme limits of freedom. However, Hill’s vision is not dedicated to seeing how far out there jazz can go, but instead expanding jazz by exploring its roots as deeply as possible.

On that note, we arrive here, at Andrew Hill’s masterwork, Compulsion!!!!!. Hill is most known for working with Eric Dolphy on Hill’s own Point of Departure, as well as being an instrumental force on records with Bobby Hutcherson and others. Point of Departure is a wild post-bop romp that displays the minimalist excellence of Hill’s composition style, as well as his relentlessly subtle dedication to untying jazz’s roots from the bottom up without anyone noticing it’s happening. It is with Compulsion, however, that Hill’s passion is truly lit aflame, igniting the rest of this unconventional lineup into expressive performances and channeling this energy into a unified, coherent record.

Compulsion is driven by a fervor for primal African rhythms, making it a particularly percussive affair. On this record, Hill dives into his past heritage in order to pave the way for the future; he doesn’t simply fuse tradition with modernism, he investigates their inherent, tangled connection. Joe Chambers is the drummer, augmented here by two extra percussionists playing, amongst others, African drums and congas. Hill gets in on the act, treating his piano as a percussion instrument and allowing his chording to flow freely and often chaotically. This whirlwind spirit pushes Chambers, and the duo’s trippy rhythmic interplay, dancing amongst the polyrhythmic complexity of the traditional African percussive team, gives the record a completely unique bed of sound. This theme ties the pieces together and gives Hill’s crew a launch pad for their solos and aural explorations.

Which brings me to the rest of the performers on this album. While the record is clearly Hill’s brainchild, no jazz session can launch successfully without the perfect lineup to bring its ideas to life with conviction and animation. Given Hill’s own idiosyncratic sensibilities, it seems important that whomever he recruited for this record, they would have to be musicians who could tango with the in-out push-shove; musicians with a solid grasp on tradition but with a third eye looking towards the future, striving for the unknown…

Enter John Gilmore, forgotten monarch of the avant garde and one of the tenor saxophone’s most imposing explorers. Gilmore is known as Sun Ra’s most devout sideman, having played very little outside of Ra’s group. But, of all the sessions Gilmore laid down in the 60s, for Ra or otherwise, this one is certainly among the best. Gilmore works perfectly with Hill, jumping “in” and “out” like his mind was fractured between sanity and lunacy at birth. Alongside Freddie Hubbard on trumpet, the two horns weave lines of haunting freedom. Hubbard is a captivating trumpeter, but his traditional nature always seems to hold him back on the freer jazz sessions; with Hill directing the show, though, Hubbard feels perfectly at home, in fact providing some of the most unrestrained displays of passion on the entire disc and allowing the beauty of his unique melodicism to show through in unorthodox ways.

Of the four cuts here, all but one blaze along in a volcanic fashion, ready to burst with free energy. Only “Premonition” slows things down into a brooding calm. This track features bass maestro Richard Davis in place of Cecil McBee, switching between evocative, complex bowed textures and his trademark angular fingerstyle playing. Hill opens the piece with the most tranquil instance of piano on the entire record, immediately introducing a foggy respite from the unrelenting driving rhythm of the previous tracks. Hubbard then has a mournful duo with Davis, accented by sporadic percussion hits before Hill storms back in on piano, setting the stage for Gilmore, who makes a godly appearance on the bass clarinet. The two, helped by the atmospheric clinking of an African thumb piano, evoke strange images as they explore the interconnecting textures of their instruments, drifting into a dreamy haze that eventually morphs into a ghostly ending theme between trumpet, bass clarinet, and subtle, rolling percussion.

The more upbeat tracks keep the energy high throughout the disc. Hill’s playing is crushing, yet full of movement, dense with dissonance and imbued with bird-like agility. One of the most intense sections of the disc comes in the title cut as Gilmore’s tenor sax solo mounts all the melodic tension it had been implying and rides towards the sun with squalls of ecstasy as washes of pounding percussion punctuate his wails, with Hill’s twinkling, percussive piano trailing off into the ether. Gilmore’s climax rides into a dangerous, frenzied restatement of the main theme, with desperate screams from the trumpet punctuating a dense and seductive melody from Gilmore’s sax and Hill’s piano pounding mercilessly.

This record is notable not only as one of the few sessions John Gilmore recorded outside of the Sun Ra Arkestra, but also as a telling look into the obsessions of Andrew Hill and his ability as a leader. He elicits some of the most effective trumpet playing Hubbard ever laid down, and the fusion of these out-jazz giants with the primal thud of African rhythms makes for one of the most fiery, propulsive jazz performances ever set to tape.

Recent reviews by this author
Ra Black SunProjeKct X Heaven and Earth
The Nels Cline Singers Draw BreathQueen Elephantine Yatra
John Coltrane Live in JapanJack Rose I Do Play Rock and Roll
user ratings (16)
related reviews

Point of Departure
trending jazz albums


Comments:Add a Comment 
August 25th 2008


I'd consider myself an Andrew Hill fan but i don't have this one. i'll look into it though, good review.

August 25th 2008


Album Rating: 4.5

As a fellow Andrew Hill fan, I can say you need to hear this immediately.

August 25th 2008


All I have is Black Fire from pixies. Rad.

August 25th 2008


black fire is snore

August 27th 2008


I have Black Fire and Point of Departure but it sounds like I should get this too. I hope the Blue Note sale is still on. $8 Blue Note albums ftw.

August 28th 2008


There's not nearly enough exclamation points in that album title.

August 7th 2009


I heard legacy and it was okay. I might check this out.

September 12th 2010


Album Rating: 4.0

it pains me to see such a good review and only the one rating. ill check this asap.

February 23rd 2012


great review, i like that you brought up the convergence of past jazz scenes that was the 60s. For that decade either an artist was looking forward or looking to combine previous outings-that or they werent met with much success. I guess in that way it differs from the big band/swing eras and the new orleans rag time era. Although I prefer point of departure this is excellent. It always amazes me that he can appeal to melodic sensibilites even while firmly bound to bop and free jazz. people who dont like "free" often like this.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy