Killing Heidi
Reflector


2.5
average

Review

by taylormemer USER (92 Reviews)
August 24th, 2008 | 16 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A good album, with some good catchy music, but clouded by guidelines, a safety blanket embroiled by $ symbols, and a whole lot of crying out, but not much to say.

Back when kids were listening to grunge, the news of Nirvana’s passing and the continual demise of the genres itself, meant that the emergence of Killing Heidi in 2000 was everything an aspiring Australian adolescent who just missed the grunge era could ever have hoped for. Vocalist Ella Hooper’s own desire to be ‘different’ is a place where you’ll discover the ins and outs, and the lows and highs of an angsty teenager (no surprises there), priming if you will, the future youth, but in a less demanding manner then your typical grunge or punk band would. Arguably, they began as most bands do, until the contract came along with a horde of guidelines and requirements. This means that Reflector is an album where the surprising commercial success of Silverchair’s Frogstomp defines the sound, packages it, but offers it to the listener with more colour, and the idea of grunge-pop obscuring the music behind it.

It’s hard to try and describe exactly where Heidi obtained their name (possibly from the novel), and how and where they actually formed. Simply put however, Violet Town (population ~500) in semi-regional Victoria, Australia is where the Hooper siblings first began playing music as any brother and sister should. With Ella on vocals and her brother Jesse on guitars the garage band resounded their post-grunge tunes all throughout the happy community, gathering both gooey and bad reactions, particularly from the unfortunate elderly. This disturbance of miniature proportions interestingly caused enough outside reaction to have both the Hooper’s and their two co-members Adam Pedretti and Warren Jenkin (who form the rhythm section), gather a wealth of preliminary radio airplay for a few demo songs. Furthermore, it also caught the unbroken interest of producer and songwriter Paul Kosky, who in search of a group to complete his recording contract, took upon the task of recording and releasing the group’s debut.

Kosky’s expertise is crucial to the commercial success of this album clearly. He and Heidi spent quite some time rehearsing and arranging before admitting themselves to the studio. The album itself yields some catchy and sweetly produced singles, such as “Mascara”, “Superman/Supergirl”, “Weir”, and finally “Life Without You”, all of which are thoroughly enjoyable. You can’t necessarily approach the impression of every album with seriousness, but the main dilemma that does surface quite quickly is that most of the tracks nibble fruitlessly at the unexciting equation of slow verse, hard chorus and back again, with predictable musical accompaniment from either synthesizers or strings. It’s ok to reiterate similar ideas during an album, but sometimes it becomes tedious, and more likely to generate a selective stance from the listener rather then a general appreciation, making Reflector a success for the group, but less of a success from which they could anchor any further recordings, given that their main sound is derived from places that were already at dead ends.



Recent reviews by this author
Hans Zimmer InterstellarMachine Head Bloodstone and Diamonds
Arch Enemy War EternalCavern Cavern
Hans Zimmer The Dark Knight RisesPeriphery Periphery II: This Time It's Personal
user ratings (6)
Chart.
3.2
good
recommended by reviewer
Silverchair Frogstomp

Comments:Add a Comment 
AtavanHalen
August 24th 2008


17920 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

This record is far better than you give it credit for.

And this is far more genuine than the ironically-titled Somewhere in the Real World; you confuse me.

taylormemer
August 24th 2008


4962 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Amorosi's first album is a 1.5. I don't see any logic in this whole how can you give that a 4, when it's crap blah blah blah, and give this a 2.5 because it's clearly better.

Jim
August 24th 2008


5110 Comments


great review tbh
i saw these guys at a scout jamboree :lol:

taylormemer
August 24th 2008


4962 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Hey I was there as well. High five!

Jim
August 24th 2008


5110 Comments


fuckin sweet :smoke:
frenzal rhomb played too. and i recall lano and woodely making an appearance :cool:

AtavanHalen
August 24th 2008


17920 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Amorosi's first album is a 1.5. I don't see any logic in this whole how can you give that a 4, when it's crap blah blah blah, and give this a 2.5 because it's clearly better.


wut

billy33
August 24th 2008


216 Comments


i had this at some stage, dunno where it is now though.
had some alright stuff on it i think.

AtavanHalen
August 24th 2008


17920 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

It really did, dude. Weir, Astral Boy, A Jar Labelled Small, Black Sheep...all fantastic songs.

badtaste
August 24th 2008


824 Comments


Hmm, only remember the singles that received airplay. Was mere pop rock to me.

billy33
August 24th 2008


216 Comments


i remember weir i thinkThis Message Edited On 08.24.08

Jim
August 24th 2008


5110 Comments


of course you remember weir

billy33
August 24th 2008


216 Comments


its a struggle, i was only nine when it came out.

AtavanHalen
August 24th 2008


17920 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

How could you not?

billy33
August 24th 2008


216 Comments


cos i remember being obsessed with the chili peppers at the time and disregarding everything else.

badtaste
August 24th 2008


824 Comments


I remember Mascara more than I remember Weir. Time for some youtube action.

edit: ah, good stuff.This Message Edited On 08.24.08

DemandMore
August 24th 2008


18 Comments


I had forgotten these guys!
I loved them so back then..



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy