Eric Dolphy
Out to Lunch!



by Zappa USER (12 Reviews)
January 16th, 2005 | 66 replies

Release Date: 1964 | Tracklist

Eric Dolphy, a California native, was born in 1928. Little did anyone know at the time, that little Eric would grow up to be one of the most controversial figures in jazz. Whether a fan of avant-garde and free jazz, or on the side of the naysayers that were so common in the 1960s, it’s pretty much universally accepted that the contribution that Eric Dolphy made to jazz music were and are incredibly important. This multi-instrumentalist, whose main instrument could either be called alto saxophone or bass clarinet, depending on who you ask, was one of the forerunners in the world of avant-garde jazz. His voice on any instrument calls out loud and clear. His joyful, humorous playing style is undeniably Dolphy. Though he did not disregard chordal improvisation as some of his contemporaries (e.g., Ornette Coleman) had, his idea of chordal improvisation is quite distant from that of the beboppers. For example, he may arpeggiate a minor chord to correspond with the rhythm section playing a major. While I could go on and on discussing his playing style and some of his unique ideas, it’s the music that speaks it the best. Whether you’re a jazz theory expert, or a casual listener, his music will speak to you nearly the same.

This is basically the top of the heap as far as Eric Dolphy albums are concerned, and arguably the best example of avant-garde jazz. It basically sounds like it is from another planet. The level of tension created by these musicians is absurd, and the loose, sensitive interaction of the band members is something to admire. All the musicians are top notch, and none provides a lesser contribution. Whether it’s Hubbard’s flurries of slurred notes in the forefront or Hutcherson’s strategically placed splashes of dissonance deep in the mix, it’s all an integral part of what makes this record what it is: a masterwork.

Let’s break it down track by track:

Hat And Beard (8:24) A loud, short note by Freddie and Eric opens up the album, and in come the rest of the band. It sort of sounds like the whole band is doing a walking line. First Eric and Richard Davis do it, then Bobby Hutcherson takes that little line himself for a few bars. In comes the main melody, which is a jarring line that seems to be slowly rolling off a cliff. After that, it’s Eric’s first solo on the record. His bass clarinet cries and squeals. A disturbing, gutteral blast of beautifully atonal sound, dedicated to Thelonious Monk. Tony’s accompaniment during Eric’s solo is great, and Bobby’s listening real hard and placing his vibe hits in all the right places. After Eric Dolphy’s solo, Freddie starts his. As is throughout the album, Hubbard plays decidedly more traditionally. It’s still out there, and nowhere near hard bop, but it isn’t the squeaks and squawks of our friend Eric Dolphy, either. He gets some great little licks in this solo. All throughout these solos Richard Davis is playing with some of the most beautiful bass tone you can imagine. This continues, and sort of comes closer to the forefront during Bobby Hutcherson’s solo, since Tony has to play quieter to accompany the quieter instrument. Richard Davis switches between arco (bowed) and pizzicato (plucked) playing, and is adept in both techniques. In fact, I think I like his arco playing better, which is rare for a jazz musician. During Hutcherson’s solo he seems to be beating the hell out of his vibes, making loud, ringing sounds at times. After his solo, Eric and Freddie come back on the melody from the beginning. Eric takes the lead on his own briefly, then Richard, and it sort of fades out. An interesting way to end such a piece. 5/5

Something Sweet, Something Tender (6:03) This one wastes no time. Eric’s bass clarinet melody comes in right away, with only Richard Davis’ bowed bass playing along with him. This is a ballad of sorts. The interplay between Eric and Davis brings back memories of the sessions of 1963 that are released as the albums “Iron Man" and “Conversations," where these two minds met for duet playing frequently. Soon, the trumpet and the vibes come in, but Tony’s nowhere to be found. The tune is still very pretty, but there’s a certain tension about it. It isn’t a comfortable ballad by any means. Eric takes an incredibly expressive solo, managing to get the point across perfectly in a very indirect way. It’s about as far from clichéd ballad playing as you can get. There’s another written melody after Eric’s solo, where Eric and Freddie play together, and Richard and Bobby punctuate interesting accents behind them. It almost sounds like they’re playing two different songs, but it’s obvious too that the musicians are all incredibly in touch with each other. After this middle section, Eric and Richard play a duet part again. I think this last duet is the prettiest part of the whole tune. 5/5

Gazzeloni (7:23) Here’s Dolphy’s one statement on flute on this particular album. This is a bright, raucous tune. It’s sort of playful, but also feels a bit dangerous. I really like the way Freddie Hubbard accompanies Eric as the band falls out going into his flute solo. Of course, the second horn doesn’t play for long, and soon it’s a true flute solo. Even though Eric’s picked up a different instrument, it’s incredibly obvious that we’re listening to the same person. Eric Dolphy is no one else, no matter what horn he happens to be blowing. One thing I like about this tune is Tony Williams’ totally over-the-top accompaniment. So often, when a reed player picks up a flute, it’s nap time for the rhythm section. This is totally not the case, and Tony takes advantage, pounding very expressively through the time changes. After Eric’s solo comes one of Freddie’s best on the album. This tune seems to fit the entire band really well. Where Freddie seemed a bit apprehensive on “Hat And Beard", he comes out swinging on his solo here. The bass is much lower in the mix here than it has been so far, which is alright. Richard really showed off quite a bit on the last tune anyhow. The vibe solo could be Hutcherson’s best on the album as well. It’s got such a direction to the phrases, and an overall slope that really feels right. Then Richard Davis comes in with a bouncy pizzicato solo. Somehow, Richard manages to play really LOUD on this record. On so many recordings you have to dial the volume way up to hear the bass solo, but this one doesn’t demand that, even over Tony Williams’ heavy handed beating. I love this tune, even if it’s missing the bass clarinet sound that I’ve come to appreciate so much. 5/5

Out To Lunch (12:09) This one starts with Tony playing a military drum part. It’s very strange. Then Dolphy comes in on alto sax along with Freddie Hubbard to play the melody, and the rest of the band comes in here as well. The melody is wild and brief, and Dolphy quickly starts his solo, with the kind of accompaniment we’ve grown accustomed to from this rhythm section. Dolphy’s alto playing is as marvelous and distinctive as his bass clarinet playing, and he utilizes the full range of the instrument like no one I’ve ever heard. In fact, it’s incredible how large his range on bass clarinet is, for that matter. Freddie and Eric are both soloing at the same time briefly, but Eric drops out soon after. Freddie’s solo swoops above the music with these disjointed, but somehow sloping lines. He sort of gets a momentum going, but knows exactly where to land and when. It’s nice, and I really dig the vibe accompaniment going on here. The interaction on this tune is high all the way through, as it has been through the entire album. Here especially they all seem to be really communicating, though. After Freddie’s solo the rhythm section just sort of plays. No one seems to take the lead for a little while, but then it starts to be something of a vibes solo. The few bars of collective improvisation are interesting, though. Richard Davis’ incredibly expressive, rich tone goes a long way to improve the solo of Bobby Hutcherson, and soon it becomes more of a duet. This sort of passing around of the solo section is what makes this album so unique, and what rewards repeated listenings. Everyone is doing something all the time (except when Tony had no part on the second tune). It all goes together (or against each other) in a very interesting way. Richard Davis plays an unaccompanied solo. He sounds like he’s searching for something. After his solo, Dolphy and Tony return with a ruckus. Eric, Tony, and Freddie trade for a while, but Tony never really sounds like he’s taking a solo until his last section, where he goes on for awhile. Then it’s back to his little military band part, and the main melody comes back. Perfect. 5/5

Straight Up And Down (8:21) This song starts with some vibe hits, and then Dolphy (on alto saxophone) and Freddie play an interesting melody. It’s sort of like the musical equivalent of a jogger with a limp. Eric once again takes the first solo. Actually, this solo section seems to be the rhythmically most straightforward on the entire album. That is to say, you can actually find the beat without having to try. Eric’s solo is long, and it once again overlaps Freddie’s. Freddie quotes the original melody real quick at the beginning of his solo, which is an interesting choice. Mostly there’s little vibraphone throughout his solo, but Bobby starts to inch his way in near the end, showing that he’s ready for his turn to solo. And solo he does. Bobby plays sort of a flowy, watery solo. The individual notes are less important than the overall direction and slope of the lines. I really like it. I also really like that whenever Bobby takes a solo you get to hear a lot of Richard Davis’ amazing bass tone and creative walking lines. After this solo, the two horns come back in squawking like drunkards, and it’s back to the head. 5/5

To me, this is a perfect album. There was nothing like it in 1964, and there has been nothing since. I really meant it when I said that it sounds like it’s from another planet. There is not one misplaced note here. Not one bad judgment call by any improvising musician. All that can be found are 5 marvelously weird compositions and 5 musicians interacting like only brilliant ones can. The net effect is a deeply effecting listen that will seep into your consciousness like an album rarely can. It is a masterpiece of American music.

Recent reviews by this author
Return to Forever Return to ForeverRahsaan Roland Kirk Bright Moments
Rahsaan Roland Kirk The Inflated TearFreddie Hubbard Straight Life
Oscar Peterson Oscar Peterson Trio Plus OneLatyrx The Album
user ratings (323)
trending jazz albums


Blue World

Comments:Add a Comment 
November 27th 2004


I DLED this CD off of you. It really is as great as you said. This is also a really nice review and as you said "your best yet".

November 27th 2004


I love your in-depth review style, Zappa. I've never heard of anyone who featured the bass clarinet so prominently; it always seemed like the bastard son of the saxophone to me.

Zesty Mordant
November 27th 2004


wow, thats quite a review. i'm very interested in hearing this album, you can't go wrong with blue note.

fantastic job. :thumb:

November 27th 2004


I'm glad you guys can appreciate this review. When it told me I was over the 10,000 character limit, I got a little worried that I'd made an uh-oh and gotten to be long-winded. Anyhow, I urge you guys to check this album out, if the review didn't already make that abundantly clear :D.

November 27th 2004


Looks interesting! I'll get this along with the Rahsaan stuff when I get the time. I've been very busy lately

Two thumbs up for your review.

Dark Hero
November 27th 2004


Really good review. I will definitely be checking it out.

November 27th 2004


Wow, great review I wish I could describe instruments that well let alone know all of them. I will defintley be downloading this off you :thumb:

The Ashtray Girl
November 27th 2004


Wow, my respect for your musical knowledge just jumped through the roof.

I will most certainly investigate this album now.

Absolutely stellar review.

November 27th 2004


Thanks guys. Hope you like it WRM, and whoever else gets ahold of it.

BlackDeathMetalJazz or really ANYTHING else please-
June 1st 2005


Album Rating: 5.0

Wow I love this album and this reveiw too. Good job Zappa you did it justice. :thumb:

August 12th 2005


Album Rating: 5.0

This album is absolutely amazing. When I first bought it and listened to it I also thought that it sounded like it was from another planet. The band plays in such a loose style. The slow sections of the songs get to sound very eerie, like it could be the soundtrack to some weird sixties detective show, or from the soundtrack to that movie Bartleby.

What other Eric Dolphy, or even Avant-Garde Jazz, albums would you recommend for further listening?

August 12th 2005


For more Dolphy: Iron Man, Conversations, and Out There have more of his great avant-garde playing, and the At the Five Spot volumes have some great sort of bop-based, but still out there, playing with the fantastic Booker Little on trumpet.

For more avant-garde, check out:
Cecil Taylor's The World of Cecil Taylor album
Andrew Hill's Point of Departure and Black Fire albums
Grachan Moncur III's Evolution album
Jaki Byard's The Jaki Byard Experience album
Pharoah Sanders' Karma album
Sam Rivers' Contours album
Yusef Lateef's Eastern Sounds album

Manticore Guy
February 1st 2006


This cd looks insane if not for all the great things I've heard about it, but for the members playing on it! I definetely need to check this out.

May 11th 2006


Album Rating: 5.0

You do this album justice! It's a fantastic album - one of my favourites. Great review, one of the most detailed track by tracks I've seen on here.

Did I say that this album is awesome?

January 7th 2007


Been diggin' on this alot lately.

June 23rd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

"Hate and Beard" and the title track really make this album shine.

August 19th 2008


Album Rating: 5.0

Astounding album.

May 28th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

This is listed as funk for some reason, I tried to change it but I guess editing bands is messed up at the moment or something. Great album, but a little tough to get into.

August 7th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Music might very well be different today if Dolphy didn't die in 64... at only 36. This is sick, but I think he had a masterpiece left in him.

:[ :[

Shadowed Reflection
March 8th 2010


Album Rating: 5.0

fantastic review

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy