Godsmack
Godsmack


2.5
average

Review

by AshtrayTheUnforgiven USER (19 Reviews)
December 13th, 2007 | 15 replies


Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist

Review Summary: While Godsmack's debut album seems enjoyable at first, if you look at this album for the talent it displays, you'll take notice to the fact that this album is not as good as it would appear. Still, it does have its moments.

Godsmack. In the late 90's, Godsmack was just another band trying to get known. Well, when Godsmack dropped Whatever, the first single from their self-titled album, they got what they were looking for, soon obtaining mainstream popularity in the genre of hard rock quickly with Whatever and smash hit Keep Away. It's obvious that the band was majorly influenced by that of Alice In Chains, with guitar solos in 90% of only one single album. It's also said that Godsmack was influenced by Metallica, in terms of being "in your face", if you will. What's quite humorous about these influences is the fact that frontman Sully Erna sounds just like what would happen if Alice In Chains frontman Layne Staley was mixed with Metallica's James Hetfield. Why? As previously stated in one of the Faceless reviews on Sputnik, Sully shows traits of both vocalists: the "whiney depressed" tone, a la Layne Staley, and the "aggressive yell in your face" style of James Hetfield into one vocal.

Nonetheless, this obvious mixing of vocals manages to be overshadowed with Sully's ability to deliver catchy hooks and choruses into Godsmack's mainstream debut, such case as in Keep Away, Whatever, and Bad Religion. In addition to these catchy lyrics, Sully manages to create good lyrical structure in terms of verses, never with one song looking familiar to the other in terms of structure, but the problem with these structures lies within the choruses. As catchy as the choruses may be, the problem with these choruses is that they mainly consist of only two to four lines, usually sung twice on average. In other words, the choruses are nothing surprising: they're something to be expected from Godsmack. Furthermore, Sully's lyrics deal with the same thing over and over again, primarily speaking of hate for a person, telling the person to keep their distance from Sully(Keep Away, Whatever, Time Bomb), and threats of what Sully says he's going to do to a person(Stress, Get Up, Get Out!).

While Sully has mixed results in terms of being a lyricist, guitarist Tony Rambola is one of, if not the main driving forces behind Godsmack's success. If it wasn't obvious enough that Godsmack was influenced by Alice in Chains, just take a listen to Tony's playing style, and notice how Tony contributes guitar solos to almost each and every song on not only the first album, but each album to come later on in the future for the soon-to-be world's most successful Alice in Chains tribute band. Like Alice In Chains though, Tony is able to deliver enjoyable solos. Cases in point: Keep Away and Immune. However, the problem with Tony Rambola in this album is the fact that over 80% of the entire album fails to break away from their main riffing except for in the solos. Bad Religion is an example of this, using the same D chord over and over again. Instrumental Someone In London would have been one of those opportunities that Tony could have taken advantage of in terms of unleashing a two minute solo, but this doesn't happen. Someone In London is the same riffing over and over, never even attempting to change the riffing and go into a good solo.

The thing that I can't seem to shake that I can actually dig about Godsmack is the existence in Robbie Merrill's bass. Robbie's bass is actually what gives the band life; you can hear it clearly even with Tony and sometimes Sully's combined riffing. Robbie even gets the spotlight with his bass in the tribal closer Voodoo, delivering a low, haunting bassline. Even Tommy Stewart does give something to remember him by, standing out in instrumental Someone in London. There really isn't nothing else to say about Tommy Stewart, seeing as the only moment that seems memorable from Tommy is Someone in London.

So why a 2.5? Well, while you have Godsmack's debut appearing to be enjoyable upon first listen, it isn't until you take one good listen into the album to see what's really wrong. Sully delivers catchy and relevant lyrics, yet the structures in his choruses are nothing surprising, consisting of the same number of lines, followed by a repeat of the same lines. Tony's guitar work is nothing impressive, with the only eye catching fact about his guitar playing would be his soloing, while overall, his diversity when it comes to straying away from a song's main riffing is seldom. Tommy manages to make his mark with his drumming in Someone in London, yet he does not manage to catch the listener's attention through the other tracks. However, with surprising existence found in Robbie's bass, he manages to give the album some brownie points, but because of the other flaws overshadowing the positives, and because of the major repetitiveness and rehashing of the same song topics, this lowers the musical value of this so-so release. In the future, Awake would manage to turn this around somewhat, allowing Godsmack to mature musically, but Faceless and IV would end up being where Godsmack hits the major bump in the road. I wouldn't recommend picking this album up, but I will say that it does deserve a good listen or two.



Recent reviews by this author
Queens of the Stone Age Lullabies to ParalyzeQueens of the Stone Age Era Vulgaris
Slipknot IowaSlipknot Slipknot
Army of Anyone Army of AnyoneKorn Greatest Hits Vol. 1
user ratings (821)
3.2
good
other reviews of this album
Bwgrotha1s (3)
Lacks originality in some areas, but overall gets the job done better than most....

The JoZ (3.5)
...



Comments:Add a Comment 
AshtrayTheUnforgiven
December 14th 2007


94 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

There really wasn't much to say about this album IMO. I could have went into detail more, but I was looking to summarize this album in a nutshell, plain and simple.



Feel free to drop feedback.

Poet
December 14th 2007


6156 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This is my least favorite Godsmack album. The first five songs are good, just like about every album Godsmack's released, but then it goes down from there to only be brought up at the end...and this is no exception.

AshtrayTheUnforgiven
December 14th 2007


94 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

^I agree, especially when it comes to Awake.

Metalikane
December 14th 2007


851 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Aww. I think this was the best Godsmack album... Actually, the only, some what, decent one,,,,,,,,,

superfascist
December 14th 2007


119 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

[quote=Review]It's obvious that the band was majorly influenced by that of Alice In Chains, with guitar solos in 90% of only one single album.[/quote]

What? The last time I checked, Alice in Chains wasn't 90% solos, and neither was this album.



[quote=Review]The thing that I can't seem to shake that I can actually dig about Godsmack is the existence in Robbie Merrill's bass.[/quote]

...What?



This is a bad review. I've read through it a couple of times, thinking it will make sense, but it doesn't. And just like your last review, you focus way too much on the singing and lyrics, and almost not at all on the rest of the album, and the stuff about the singing and lyrics is just nitpicky stuff that isn't that important.







Altmer
December 14th 2007


5714 Comments


the wackiest thing about this album is the lol cover

SynGates
December 14th 2007


2467 Comments


that is a pretty terrible cover.

jrowa001
December 14th 2007


8752 Comments


i used to absolutely love this album. it was one of my first "heavy" albums when it came out. like you said in your summary, once i started to get into more technical music i noticed how terrible this album is

rleechb
December 14th 2007


21 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Decent review. I wouldn't say Sully has "mixed results" as a lyricist; I'd say he has one result: CRAP. The songs on this album are full of hooks and are certainly catchy... but I can never get past the horrible lyrics:



Go away!!!

Stay away!!

Don't come near me!!

I don't want you anywhere within my general vicinity!

You're invading my personal space!

Back off!



Sully probably suffers from claustrophobia.

Slaytan
December 14th 2007


1185 Comments


Ehh review, you focus way too much on the vocals and lyrics, and not enough on the musical aspect of the album. Also, you compare them to Alice in Chains too much.

Eakflanderyof
December 15th 2007


6635 Comments


I actually kind of like Voodoo. The rest that I've heard sucks ass and the lyrics are embarrassingly bad. I definitely do see the Alice in Chains influence as well in his singing style.

Big Baby Jesus
April 19th 2008


549 Comments


I do not like godsmack. They're pop-"Metal", They steal the name off a AIC song, and the song "Time Bomb" is a DIRECT Ripoff of last by Nine Inch Nails. They don't even try and make it sound different. The riff and the vocals. Just maddens me.

NaturalLaw
September 29th 2025


347 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I went into it thinking I was going to enjoy it for more than I ended up doing. Once someone said he sounded like the singer from Alice in chains I couldn't shake that either haha. Heard the second album is quite good.

DominionMM1
September 29th 2025


21542 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

second album’s got a few bangers for sure

Hawks
Staff Reviewer
September 29th 2025


115309 Comments


First bump in 17 and a half years, respect lmao.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy