by punkgeekalt USER (3 Reviews)
November 30th, 2007 | 48 replies

Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Evanescence is inspired and the best Christian rock band ever.

From the time, they form the band, a star-is-born, it is Amy Lee, of course, and she writes most of the songs. Much of the credit goes to her. Ben Moody and Amy Lee are the founding members of Evanescence. They met at church camp. John Lecompt, the guitarist and Rocky Gray, the drummer later join the band. They are a force to be reckoned with. After the "Fallen" disc is multi-platinum, the Arkansas-based band is a stealth success. They worked on the album for so long, it seems it took them forever. They form as a Christian rock band, and they stick with their roots. They sound like metal and Goth rock mix with pop.

Bigwig Enterprises release their first album, called "Evanescence EP" December 1998. The tracks include "Where Will You Go, Solitude, Imaginary, Exodus, So Close, Understanding," and "The End (Outro)." Then they released the second album, "Whisper EP/Sound Asleep EP" in August 1999. It is mostly instrumental. The version of "Whisper" on this CD is different from the album. "Origin" is released before the most acclaimed "Fallen" It seems every "Whisper" song is different from every album.

Amy Lee, a songwriter and front woman is largely an amazing songwriter. She does not miss a beat when she goes on the stage performing live. She might get tired and her voice starts to jerk and tremble, but she keeps up herself in her expression and movement.

Evanescence's material stirs fluently from classic orchestral hope to understudy. It is moody piano arrangements and hip-hop-laced alternative sound. With the talented lead guitarist, Ben Moody and the haunting vocal of Amy Lee, the band is dark and full of emotional.

"Everybody's Fool," A nice little quirky upbeat rhythm starts this song off which breaks out with lyrics, "Perfect by nature, icons of self indulgence, just what we all need, more lies about a world that. Never was and never will be, have you no shame don't you see me, you know you've got everybody fooled" then it rocks in the chorus, harder and softly departed. It is really all about taste.

"Going Under" is rude and loud in the beginning. "Now I will tell you what I've done for you 50 thousand tears I've cried, screaming deceiving and bleeding for you." Take from Evanescence's disc, the breakthrough hit, "Bring Me to Life" is rock and metal. It is high spirit song, energetic and full of emotion. Nowadays, rock bands are adding rap in the songs. In "Bring Me To life", Paul McCoy of 12 Stones sings the rapping lyrics and he sounds good. The lyrics on the album are interesting, literate, and urbane.

"Tourniquet" is the highlight of the Goth metal rock song for me. It is upbeat. Amy sings, "My God, my tourniquet, return to me salvation." It gets unsettling for some. And it gets upsetting for some. If you believe in God, and faithful, you listen to the point, it gets louder and angrier, to me, but it is just words that not worse than you’ve read the articles in the newspaper. It is from the album "For the Incomplete" released by the band, Soul Embraced. One of the tracks is "My Tourniquet" written by the band Soul Embraced.

The "Imaginary" song has the interesting orchestration from the beginning. "I linger in the door way. Of long night, monster calling..." "In my field of paper flower and candy clouds of lullaby." It is an interesting lyrical imagination. I can imagine if in a long sleepless night, a monster calling me that is very scary, just like I might dream but the dream is over. I hope I do not have those nights when I cannot fall to sleep, and have a dream is better. But it sounds pretty darn cool.

"Taking Over Me" song lyric goes, "I have to be with you, to live, to breathe, you’re taking over me. I look in the mirror and see your face. If I look deep enough. So many things inside that are just like you are taking over."

"Haunted" is the song, "Long lost words whisper slowly to me, still can't find what keeps me here... watching me wanting me, I can feel you pull me down." It starts with the loud guitar and strikes me and Amy's voice kicks off, it is angry and deceiving. It is clearly her style of Goth rock and Christian rock or confronts Satan. It is about feeling the loneliness inside her, and the challenges in front her. We deal with at some point of our lives the life.

"My Last Breath" has an interesting mixture of heavily produced guitar chords. It rocks. "Holding my last breath, safe inside myself." "I'll miss the winter, a world of fragile things. Look for me in the white forest, hiding in a hollow tree."

"Hello," the song is slow.

"Playground school bell rings again
Rain clouds come to play again
Has no one told you she's not breathing"
Hello I'm your mind giving you someone to talk to

If I smile and don't believe
Soon I know I'll wake from this dream
Don't try to fix me I'm not broken
Hello I'm the lie living for you so you can hide
Don't cry

Suddenly I know I'm not sleeping
Hello I'm still here
All that's left of yesterday"

"Whisper," a song is inspiring and moving. "Shall I give in, upon my end shall I begin, forsaking all I've fallen for, I rise to meet my end"

After listening to the CD again, come back the same songs again, I listen, and I still love it. What I like about the band is that all songs from evanescence make you think your CD is skipping at one point. It comes from the rhythm and melody. The heavy distortion of the guitars very much covers the entire album. The melodies are heavy at times, it might not sound good for younger age children listener, but are still listener-friendly, for adults who love classical music or pop, and country.

Some have already heard of the song, "Missing" before you found out the song from their latest release, "Anywhere but Home." It's a great song, it is similar to "My Immortal" but not the new band version, and it is slow and graceful. The "Missing" lyrics include, "Isn't something missing" Isn't someone missing me"" And the chorus goes, "And if I bleed, I'll bleed, knowing you don't care. And if I sleep just to dream of you." It is breathtaking and it is whole new material.

Evanescence's line up:
Amy Lee, vocal, John Lecompt, guitar, William Boyd, Rocky Gray, the drum, Terry Balsamo, and Ben Moody, lead guitar and David Hodges, Keyboards and piano.

user ratings (1357)
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
November 30th 2007


Album Rating: 1.0

I'm not going to neg it, but there are a few things very wrong with this review. Difference in opinion aside, it feels really awkward and there is a lot of unnecessary, poorly structured filler here. To be honest, it doesn't seem so much like a review as it does a wikipedia entry.

The only reason I could see this review working in favor of rating this as a classic is this being a significantly overhyped record that gathered a large fanbase. But even that is a stretch.

November 30th 2007



south_of_heaven 11
November 30th 2007


Grammar is your friend.

Digging: RAM - Rod

Staff Reviewer
November 30th 2007


Good review for a first, but your angle that Evanescence is a Christian band makes your review a bit erroneous. The Christian tag wasn't Amy's idea and never was - it was a Moody thing, and now that he's out of the picture, you can't blanket the band as "the best Christian rock band ever."
Also, bear in mind that Balsamo was not part of Evanescence during the Fallen years.
I also don't really follow why you included sentences like this:

If you believe in God, and faithful, you listen to the point, it gets louder and angrier, to me, but it is just words that not worse than you’ve read the articles in the newspaper

I don't understand the point you're trying to make there.
However, once you started talking about Fallen's songs, I think you did a good job for a first. I think your writing style is extremely awkward and fragmented, like you wrote it in a stream-of-consciousness fashion. But, with practice and more reviews, you'll be great. So, welcome!

November 30th 2007


Yeah we've got a real James Joyce here.

November 30th 2007


i think he's trying to say that he's a christian and he thinks evanescence is a christian band.

ill read the review later, but a big downer on the rating.

November 30th 2007


Okay properly read the review.

In future you should write your reviews in some word processor and proofread it one or two times just so it reads right. You make a lot of grammatical and spelling errors and it's not really necessary to include song lyrics in every paragraph.

But ya, just work at it like Jom said.

November 30th 2007


Not mentioning the score, the summary makes it apparent that the review will be biased.

November 30th 2007



November 30th 2007


Album Rating: 2.0

Is English your first language?

November 30th 2007


I read the summary and I think Amy Lee would beat the shit out of you for saying they're a christian band. They had a huge issue with the Christian record billboard charts because they didn't claim to be a christian band but were on those charts anyway.

They reference god in one song and are labelled christian. Great.

November 30th 2007


Is English your first language?
I'm also curious as to that. If not, kudos on the effort.

November 30th 2007


Terry Balsamo didn't play on this album, but he's in your line-up at the end, may want to remove him.
Also, this review is very biased.

November 30th 2007


Album Rating: 3.0

There are a lot of awkward grammar errors and tons of mistakes in this review. Also, there's only two short paragraphs that really say anything about the music, except for short phrases like "orchestration from the beginning" and "heavily produced guitar chords". It's also pretty biased.

A decent first attempt, but still pretty bad.This Message Edited On 11.30.07

November 30th 2007


reading this review was like driving a car with no shocks on a road made of potholes

November 30th 2007


have you ever heard of conjunctions?

November 30th 2007


Album Rating: 2.0

If you put this in the past tense, didn't you so many useless quotes and didn't seem to just mash random sentences together, this would be readable.

December 1st 2007


I can't believe you just used "you so" for "use so".

December 1st 2007


haha, 0 out of 7 agree with the review, It wasn't a terrible review but a 5? for Evenescance, come on. the best can get is 3 if someones real generous.

December 1st 2007


haha, 0 out of 7 agree with the review, It wasn't a terrible review but a 5? for Evenescance, come on. the best can get is 3 if someones real generous.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy