Seether
Finding Beauty In Negative Spaces


3.0
good

Review

by MoonlightBleeding USER (18 Reviews)
October 23rd, 2007 | 21 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Seether gets a bit more experimental and better instrumentally and vocally. They still suffer from poor lyrics, variety, and originality though.

Fake it if your out of direction
Fake it if you don't belong
Fake it if you feel like infection


For two albums, Seether's been faking it. Their music was horribly ripped off from every other post-grunge/hard rock band out today. Disclaimer II was just horrid, and Karma and Effect was a step in the right direction. That's why the lead single Fake It accurately describes Seether's career, up to Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces. Seether's latest record moves away from well, the blandness of Disclaimer and Karma and Effect. Seether's latest album successfully recovers them from being like, well, Nickelback or Taproot. They're way better, and proved this with Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces.

This album isn't excellent, even though it's a good listen and a step in the right direction. I can truly listen to the album from start to finish without skipping a track. Is that a positive" Yes, I haven't been able to do that on ANY Seether album. That's most likely one big positive to the album. The rhythms are catchy and really great on most of the songs (notably Fake It). Shaun Morgan's vocals are grittier and more powerful than ever. The guitar work still reeks of nu-metal, though, and the artwork is well, almost as bad as Limp Bizkit's Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water. The songs don't flow well together as a whole and seemed severed from one another. Really, a gigantic lack of variety. But somehow, Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces isn't that bad.

Like Suicide: 3.5/5
Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces opens up with Like Suicide, a heavy track that showcases Seether's heavier, grittier sound. The new rhythms aren't as awesome as they are many of the tracks, but the simplistic rhythms work well with the song. It may feel a bit bland and radio rock fodder, but you can't not admit it's melodic and catchy. The riffs are perfectly detached and well subdued, and Morgan's vocals are simplistic, heavy, and overbearing. His vocals aren't excellent here, but the screaming definitely adds a metal edge to the song, and let me tell you, the breakdown where Shaun screams a whole stanza, it's perfectly executed.

Fake It: 4/5
Throw your hatred towards Seether aside, at least for one track. Fake It, the first single, showcases a perfect rhythm that clearly makes the track stand-out. The riffs are rather rehashed and boring, but Morgan's vocals are spot-on perfect, and the song is VERY catchy. You'll be singing it for hours. The solo is well done, it's simplistic, but gives off the overall sense of the track. Definitely one of the album's best songs.

Breakdown: 1.5/5
Oh, god, you've got to be kidding me. The Gift Part II takes track three on this album. Slow beginning and verse, aggressive chorus, emotional lyrics and vocals. Anyone heard this before" The guitars are a bit odd and off-the-wall in parts and Seether takes advantage of guitar feedback in plenty of places. The song is once again, catchy, but when Morgan sings "soooooooooooooo...", you're almost in awe at how cheesy this line sounds upon first listen. The solo riff is just, not good as well. This song screams second single, but it's a rather mediocre song.

FYLYHM (*** You Like You Hate Me): 4/5
Yes, the title of the track is moronic as well as the premise of the track, but the song is just great. The song slowly builds, and plenty of the guitar work has an 'eerie' Orgy feel, and the slow-burning song structure is excellent. The aggressive chorus is great and crazed, and Morgan lets you know he's got plenty of anger, even if blatantly showcasing his terrible lyrical approach and writing. The rhythms of the album are in full-force, moving the song along with passion. But even with stupid and immature lyrics, the song manages to stick out and be one of the album's best.

Fallen: 3/5
Well, apparently Shaun felt compelled to trash his ex-girlfriend Amy Lee by stealing her biggest hit's name. Evanescence" Whatever, Seether's got a track called Fallen now. Looking past the blatant shot at Lee, Seether grasps more excellent rhythms, adds in some heavy basslines, and backup screams in the chorus. You've definitely got one of Seether's heavier tracks that borders on Chevelle-like alternative metal. Morgan's voice cracks a bit too much in the chorus though, and adds a bit too much grit and anger to the chorus. His vocal performances pull away from a rather excellent guitar solo and riffage.

Rise Above This: 1/5
Seether isn't macho enough to drop the ballads, and integrates a ridiculously soft ballad for post-grunge. Morgan makes uncanny resemblences to Lifehouse's vocalist in the verses and choruses. The whole acoustic/electric, melodic thing is way over and getting really aged.

No Jesus Christ: 5/5
Here's where Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces really shines. Seether shows some of their newer influences and styles with No Jesus Christ, arguably their most experimental song yet. Starting off with a barely audible bassline, the song slowly builds into a melodic masterpiece. Taking advantage of the time of the track, Seether adds a song without any blatant structure, showing off Morgan's screaming, atmospheric riffs, and Seether's soundscapes. The song is relaxing and aggressive at the same time. Quickly changing pace for the 7 minute lifespan, No Jesus Christ lets Morgan vent his anger while showing off one of Seether's most atmospheric pieces. The rhythms lead the song perfectly, and truly show Seether's reliance on rhythms. Clearly the standout track, right here.

6 Gun Quota: 3/5
Seether pulls of an ultra-melodic track with catchy choruses, fun riffs, different song structures, and plenty of riffage. Morgan belts out some of his best vocals on the album, and the song is only led by some of Seether's best lyrics. The growling vocals mix well with the 'eerie' riffs, and the song is definitely a wonderful track, inhibited by the similiarity to Fake It.

Walk Away From the Sun: 2/5
Morgan is a lyrical trainwreck. He doesn't resort to anger, just really poetic misery, and Walk Away From the Sun is proof of that.

Walk Away From the Sun and Kill Everyone.

Yeah, I'll get right on that.

The guitar work isn't terrible, in fact it's some of Morgan's best stuff. The solos are impeccable, and the riffs create a nice backdrop, spearheaded by the acoustic guitar in the back. The drumming sets some nice rhythms and the bass fits perfectly with the rhythm. The 'oh-ho-ho-hooooo' in the chorus is a bit strange, though.

Eyes of the Devil: 2.5/5
More miserable lyrics are right here on Eyes of the Devil. Shaun Morgan continues to dig a lyrical hole, barely held up by really bland guitar work. The song is definitely slow burning and led by the bass. Morgan's vocals are especially powerful and extreme though, but I really can't get past the line "it irks me when I get burned.". We may have a candidate for a worse one-liner than "I got my arms a-flip flop-flip.".

Don't Believe: 4.5/5
Just when you think the album will hit a downward spiral, Seether picks the ashes off the floor and dusts them off for a really great track. The quiet verse/loud chorus structure is overused, but the aggressiveness of the track makes it a great listen. Morgan's heavy metal screaming is actually very desirable, and the tradiitonal singing is very refined, in a good way. The guitar work carries a strange 'oriental' feel about it, but definitely gives off the dark, endless vibe of the album well. Plenty of the riffs integrate some VERY metal riffs, and the Evans Blue-ish chorus actually works very well for Seether. Rhythms are spot on and perfectly executed, and it carries an experimental feel about it. One of the album's best, by far.

Waste: 3/5
Waste is a slower track with some very excellent guitar work, almost country in parts. Morgan once again screams at the top of his voice, but the track really feels like something off of Daughtry's self-titled (which IS NOT a good thing). There's definitely experimental parts to Waste and shows some of Seether's possible further directions, and I like it. Just more refined and perfected would be a good thing. Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces ends on a fairly good note, just like it began.

All in all, Finding Beauty in Negative Spaces really isn't bad at all. Experimentation plays a bit part in Seether's attack on audio on this album. The guitar work has moved up a level, as well as Morgan's vocals (which were never all that good in the first place). No matter how bad an album may be, I can always appreciate a band trying to move in a new direction, and it looks like Seether is moving into a more rhythm-led melodic approach, versus their former 'balls out' rock style of Disclaimer and Karma and Effect. The tracks also don't work that well together either, they seem like a collection of miscellanious tracks more than an album that was meant to be released as a whole. There's some real gems on here, and some real duds, but Seether's change is welcome, and crafted their most accomplished work yet.



Recent reviews by this author
Rivers Cuomo Alone: The Home Recordings of Rivers CuomoEve 6 It's All In Your Head
Red Hot Chili Peppers CalifornicationThe Mars Volta The Bedlam in Goliath
My Chemical Romance The Black ParadeNine Inch Nails Year Zero
user ratings (614)
Chart.
2.9
good
other reviews of this album
bentheREDfan (3.5)
Break out the scalpel......

willhun (3.5)
Good cd, but lacks second guitar, and the album is alot less darker than the past. Still was catchy ...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Jom
Staff Reviewer
October 23rd 2007


3001 Comments


A good track-by-track analysis with your personal sidebar comments, but we definitely have diverging opinions on a lot of the songs, haha.

Willie
Moderator
October 23rd 2007


17318 Comments


This band and this album are horrible...

MrKite
October 23rd 2007


5020 Comments


They still suffer from poor lyrics, variety, and originality though.

I know it's only the summary but the way you worded it makes it sound like they're actually suffering from having variety and being original.

Walk Away From the Sun and Kill Everyone.

Yeah, I'll get right on that.

Bring on some xXxroflsxXxThis Message Edited On 10.23.07

MoonlightBleeding
October 23rd 2007


452 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I thought my Dredg review was VERY poor, so I did a track-by-track of this album, and feel like I successfully pulled off a better review.

MoonlightBleeding
October 23rd 2007


452 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

How come I can't post on the forum?

AtavanHalen
October 23rd 2007


17920 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Interesting review. I loved Karma And Effect, shall have to check this one out.

Aubiefan23
October 23rd 2007


2 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I personally like the album. It is not mind blowing or anything, but def a good listen.

fXpT
February 8th 2008


44 Comments


The album wasn't to bad, I liked Don't Believe, Fake It, Like Suicide, and No Jesus Christ. Everything else was just not that well written or not that great of songs.This Message Edited On 02.08.08

joshieboy12345
June 23rd 2012


5401 Comments


Fake It is ridiculously catchy, will think about getting this, cool review.

nickg42084
September 13th 2012


90 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

This is when Seether lost me, I hate fake it and the rest of the album is sub par. I really don't know what happened to these guys they showed a lot of potential with their first 2 albums then this comes out. Unsurprisingly enough their newer album is just as bad. Might as well put them in the middle tier semi annoying mainstream rock section along with the likes of Three Days Grace. Not quite bad enough for top tier douche bag rock though such as Nickelback, Hinder, Saving Abel ect.

Pndi
October 25th 2012


464 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

can't believe this is already 5 years old, i remember being disappointed when it came out but it had quickly grown on me.

NeoSpaz
May 19th 2013


4529 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Shit is cray.

Album is good for an occasional listen

DegausserGuernica24
May 19th 2013


1134 Comments


They did a great job at ripping off track titles from Evanescence (Fallen), Soundgarden (Like Suicide), and Breaking Benjamin (Breakdown).

AliE
July 21st 2013


19 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

it's not a very good album at all i just liked fake it

Sciroccu
July 21st 2013


883 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

the same for me.

DegausserGuernica24
August 13th 2013


1134 Comments


WOW WAY TO FUCKING RIP OFF INFECTED MUSHROOM

sapient
July 11th 2014


2407 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Not gonna lie, Fake It is seriously catchy



Probably my fav album from them, it doesn't feel nearly as ripped from Shaun Morgan's grunge influence

SweeneyTodd
April 10th 2015


1474 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Review should be less "I think this". It makes it sound too personal. otherwise its well written. Disagree though, I enjoyed this album as much as I did Karma & Effect

Digging: Glassjaw - Material Control

Angelboros
February 8th 2016


1347 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Personally, the artwork for this record's the best part about it. That isn't saying a whole lot, but I digress. No Jesus Christ is one of the stronger cuts off here.

AlexMichels
April 20th 2017


18 Comments


"Breakdown: 1.5/5"

neg



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy