by Clumpy USER (29 Reviews)
October 2nd, 2007 | 11 replies

Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Ba da da da da. . . ba da da da da. . .

Battles - Mirrored
Review by Clumpy

Think about the last time you really heard a classic electronica record. I mean CLASSIC, as in an indispensable part of your record collection. "Neon Golden" doesn't count. That record had heavy beats, but was very indie. Getting into the field of math rock and noise, the pickings get even slimmer. The Boredoms" Nice and weird, but not classic. And Yoshimi's side project OOIOO was mad good but too fond of the dolphins-being-tortured sound effects to really vie for classic status. So where's the real deal"

A caveat: I never got into techno. Sure, I liked the odd Secret Chiefs 3 or Air song, but I just couldn't find the melody I needed in music to really get into the field of techno.

Enter Battles. Masterminds, absolute masterminds. How they managed to come out of left field with such an awesome, imaginative, melodic and (we'll see) completely unmarketable album astounds me. The key is in the progression. Sure, some of these songs hover near the volatile eight-minute mark (and one track even surpasses it), but darn if these songs don't use their copious time effectively. No "Here We Go Sublime"-style repetition here. These songs develop, progress and fold upon themselves. Battles are songwriters first and foremost, and these songs are more than mere background noise.

Every second on this album is absolutely planned. The band is never content to pick out a neat groove and just settle into it. Single "Atlas", for example, juggles three or four independent riffs balanced by the manic drum line before subtle and gradually building up to a thrilling crescendo. Even the end - where the instruments fall apart and the track sounds like an engine shutting down - is perfect.

The vocals are unintelligible enough for this album to qualify for instrumental status. Drums and arpeggiato guitar fill nearly every second of this album's runtime. How can an album be so artifical and yet feel so organic" There's something inexplicably exciting about artists willing to step beyond the comfort zone of modern music and create something truly wonderful. Yes, this sounds like an album from the year 2020, but only because modern music has stagnated so. Battles make no sacrifices for their sound.

Each song is a showstopper. Opener track "Race In" builds up slowly and perfectly to an seemingly-epic finish. "Atlas" sounds like the Munchkinland song on hallucinogenics, pulsing beat and ferocious drumming aside. And "Leyendecker" is a sinister, chillingly-perfect pop song, the kind that Mike Patton would like to make. Err. . . tried to make.

Again, this album may take some time to get used to. But when finally crack the code (probably during the moment you hear "Race Out", the great final track that plays as an inverted version of the first track) this album will have you for its own.

Sure, it may not blow you away upon first listen. But keep it up, and you'll begin to hear the non-obvious melodies and musical chops driving this record. And it will slowly, inevitably seep into your soul and infect your consciousness. And if, in so doing, it earns a permanent spot in the top tier of your record collection, so be it.

Read Clumpy's omniscient blog at
Feel free to vote for this review if you liked it. You'll probably never meet me,
but if on the off chance you do, can you imagine having to tell me that you
went straight to your e-mail or something without voting" I don't want to put you into
that sort of awkward situation.

Recent reviews by this author
Man Man Six Demon BagArctic Monkeys Favourite Worst Nightmare
Belle and Sebastian The Life PursuitEels Electro-Shock Blues
Gorillaz Demon DaysThe Hives Tyrannosaurus Hives
user ratings (896)
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • AtavanHalen (5)
    The future of music? It's here today....

    specialk21 (4.5)
    "Mirrored" is one of the best albums of 2007, and while the sound may not be for everyone,...

    pixiesfanyo (4)
    With "Mirrored" Battles extends their sound past the typical realm of math rock and succee...

    ValiumMan (4.5)
    US math rockers Battles manage to overcome a whole bunch of genre trappings on this mighty...

  • bananaoracle (4)
    Battles release one of the most varied and unique musical releases of the year....

    WizardZombie (5)
    A classic math rock album for the ages...

related reviews



Gloss Drop

Dross Glop
recommended by reviewer
Secret Chiefs 3 Book M

Comments:Add a Comment 
October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

well, unmarketable is wrong for a start, 'Atlas' is played in indie clubs up and down the country and has been used for adverts on the BBC.

This review is ok, you're enthusiastic but lose your points due to that occasionally. Potential, though!

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

I was referring more to a Billboard sort of market, not saying that it wouldn't fly in certain circles. Thanks though.

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

Though I wouldn't necessarily use words like techno, electronica, or instrumental to describe this album, I understand where you're coming from.

And Leyendecker rocks.

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

Whole album fucking rocks.

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

yeah but BBC is pretty much as big as Billboard. Just British.

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

This album is soooooo good.

October 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

Amazing album, Battles at Big Day Out 2008 wooo.

Apocalyptic Raids
October 3rd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

great album

October 5th 2007


i disagree with a lot of the things that you say in this review. mainly that they're not repetitive: all of the songs are based on repeated and maniplulated samples and i fail to see how that is not repetitive.

February 6th 2008


Album Rating: 4.5

Well, minimalist music for one uses endless repetition of individual segments, but songs evolve and progress much like any other music. Battles certainly isn't minimalistic, but they tweak the repeated samples enough that they're as legitimate as any instrument (though they do use guitars on this record).

Sorry for the really late reply - I have been busy with some musical projects of my own.

Shadowed Reflection
November 23rd 2009


nice review but....did you call secret chiefs 3 techno?

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy