Limp Bizkit
Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water


3.5
great

Review

by dedman USER (1 Reviews)
September 18th, 2007 | 29 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Overall I feel this was a very good effort, if you put aside songs like Hot Dog and focus on serious songs like Boiler, it's extremely good results. The album after this (Results May Vary) was awful, I can admit that, but I like this album and everything

I can say that I am a Limp Bizkit fan, but I can understand why people would dislike this band if I can be honest, although it seems these days it's a trend to hate Limp Bizkit. Anyway, I have listened to this album, while it has it's good and bad's, it could have been better, some of the lyrics really damage the songs, anyway, let's get on with it...


1. Intro

No rating for this, it's just an intro, but I must say, it's pretty catchy

2. Hot Dog

This song has some nice funk to it during the verses, and Fred Durst does well with the vocals, but the lyrics are awful. The song is just an excuse for Fred Durst to swear about fifty times, the only other notable thing is the chorus, which rips off Nine Inch Nails, not a great song whatsoever

Rating 2/5

3. My Generation

Some good work here, nice little drum solo is the beginning, and a nice turntable solo near the end, plus some good guitar work in both the chorus and the verses, and a great bridge, the only problem? The lyrics, most of the time they neither ryhme nor make sense whatsoever, but a great chorus and all of the above makes up for it

Rating 3.5/5

4. Full Nelson

Some fine work here as well, a great vibe throughout the song, and music you could really get pumped to, the verses are ok, but I feel that the bridge and chorus really take the song

Rating 3/5

5. My Way

Great song here. some good lyrics about someone leaving because things aren't going there way (ironic since Wes ended up leaving the band) one to watch out for

Rating 4/5

6. Rollin

Not a great song. The problem is, the song is rather repetitive, add some confusing lyrics, plus the fact that Fred Durst seems to be trying to hard to be a 'playa', not really much when you look at it now, but it was f*cking huge when it came out as a single

Rating 2/5

7. Livin it up

The worst song on the album, the lyrics are horrible, the bridge is f*cking stupid, chorus is pathetic, and Fred Durst takes a needless shot at Nine Inch Nails, some of the lines in this song are cringe-worthy

Rating 1/5

8. The One

A good song here, the lyrics are sortof on and off, at times they're good, other times they're weak, I would have given it a 3/5, but the bridge is really good, and improves it

Rating 4/5

9. Getcha Groove On

A collaboration with Xzibit, Fred Durst tries, but his lyrics are terrible, and the chorus is really stupid and confusing, skip this one

Rating 1.5/5

10. Take A Look Around

One of my favourite tracks, some great lyrics, with a fantastic chorus, and a terrific bridge, Fred Durst really shines here

Rating 5/5

11. It'll Be Ok

Starts off ok, but Fred Durst really ruins it with his screaming, and changed from being despressive to annoying with Fred Durst's vocals, the song just doesn't cut it afterwards

Rating 1.5/5

12. Boiler

My favourite song on the album, Fred Durst does extremely well with the vocals, plus some great lyrics, add a great chorus and you have a great song, but the bridge is by far my favourite part, and shows off Fred's good screaming

Rating 5/5

13. Hold On

A very good song with some top lyrics, rather ordinary, non-standout but it's good nonetheless

Rating 4/5

14. Rollin (Urban assault vehicle)

Hip hop song here, but cannot cut it at all, not to mention how weak Fred is compared to the others, a must-skip

Rating 1/5

15, Outro

Simply f*cking stupid, nevermind the outro

Overall I feel this was a very good effort, if you put aside songs like Hot Dog and focus on serious songs like Boiler, it's extremely good results. The album after this (Results May Vary) was awful, I can admit that, but I like this album and everything else, and I hope Limp release there new album soon, I could really get back into it.


user ratings (2147)
2.7
average
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
samthebassman
September 19th 2007


2164 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Sorry mate, review sucks... better luck next time.





emogangstascotty
September 19th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Nice review, short and sweet. IMO the Rollin' remix was PHAT. It makes me feel all Gangsta wen im rollin' into da hood.

Haha honest I reallyed liked the remix, reminded me why I liked them in the first place (oh god help me), because they experiment. The video clip to the orginal Rollin' is great if you can find it. I had it on DVD single

Thor
September 19th 2007


10354 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

No, sorry. This album sucks.

tinathefatlard
September 19th 2007


2049 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm not hating on the review but it seems like you could have just told us that your favorite songs were Take a look around and Boiler. I mean why the hell else would you give them 5's and every thing else 1's and 2's?

PhoenixRising
September 19th 2007


277 Comments


7 of the 14 songs you rate at a 2 or under, or just say that they are terrible, then you say that this is a solid effort?
I think if you go back and read your own thoughts with fresh eyes, you'll see what we do: this sh-t SUCKS!!

AtavanHalen
September 19th 2007


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Pretty amateur, dude. Better luck next time, as Sam said.

lunchforthesky
September 19th 2007


1039 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I find this to have amusing novelty value.

Doppelganger
September 19th 2007


3124 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

The only points this album gets from me is that Rollin' is the perfect music for 4 extremely white kids (me included) riding in a new Honda Ridgeline through the ghetto stealing traffic cones to blast out the windows.

AtavanHalen
September 19th 2007


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

I love Scott Weiland on Hold On.

BallsToTheWall
September 19th 2007


51216 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Hot dog and rollin the rap version slays.

dedman
September 19th 2007


1 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Phoenixrising what are you talking about?



1. Hot dog- 2/5

2. Rollin- 2/5

3. Livin it up- 1/5

4. Getcha groove on- 1.5/5

5. It'll be ok- 1.5/5

6. Rollin (urban assault)- 1/5



7. The one- 4/5

8. Boiler- 5/5

9. Take a look around- 5/5

10. My generation- 3.5/5

11. Full Nelson- 3/5

12. Hold on- 4/5

13. My Way- 4/5



More good songs than there are bad

Spectrum
September 19th 2007


347 Comments


This review isn't anything more than a track-by-track rating with extremely minimal information otherwise. There aren't many opinions to back up, but despite that, none of the opinions presented are backed up or represented properly. No explanation of why the good songs are worthwhile, just "I like this one and this one, those tracks are great, but not this one or this one, those ones are dumb". It's simply a really amateur review.
Still, even if his math was a bit off, Phoenix's point still stands. An album that is admittedly half 'great' tracks and half 'terrible' tracks isn't in any way 'solid'; the way you describe the album fits the bill for 'very uneven'.
Better luck next time, mate.

PhoenixRising
September 19th 2007


277 Comments


"Phoenixrising what are you talking about?"

The six you listed plus the outro which you said was terrible. 7 right???
50% of the songs being rated at 2 or below or just called terrible does not make a classic record PERIOD.
Sorry bud.This Message Edited On 09.19.07

PhoenixRising
September 19th 2007


277 Comments


Just to be clear I think your ratings of the songs are pretty good. I'm just not sure how you arrive from those ratings, which you made youself, to a perfect score for the album. Doesnt add up my friend.
This Message Edited On 09.19.07

publicastration
September 19th 2007


57 Comments


Limp Bizkit is worse than Korn, and that's saying something.

emogangstascotty
September 19th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

No no no. Korn is way more shite. Wait, they are both shite equal-wise. LOL to Doppelganger's comment.

Wizard
September 19th 2007


20509 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Welcome to Sputnikmusic. I know this was your first review, but it really needs some work. Try reading some of the 'Approved Reviewers' reviews on this site to get a feel for a good one. Even though I still listen to Nu-Metal sometimes, I think you will find this site to be a little bit more purist towards the genre. That just means Limp Bizkit reviews will possibly be negged or trashed (for future consideration).

emogangstascotty
September 19th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

The man makes a good point, kiddo.

Wizard
September 20th 2007


20509 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

emogangstascotty,

Thank you, just constructive criticism.



jason_f90
September 20th 2007


207 Comments


Take A Look Around is a pretty well structured and written song. Can't say the same about the rest though ;[



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy