by Robert Crumb USER (49 Reviews)
January 16th, 2005 | 2985 replies

Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist

A man of great intellect scarred by horrible circumstances and driven towards abject enmity, Victor Von Doom continually threatens the Marvel Comics Universe to surrender to his will or suffer the consequences. Though his foes stand firm in his way, Doom’s genius and ingenuity service him well, making him a villain unmatched.

Of course, in the real world, there are no time machines, no Doombots, no Latveria. Metal-faced conquerors, though? Sure, why not? Tormented by the cruel and horrible world of corporate hip hop, Daniel Dumile (a.k.a Zev Love X) is rejected by the world, only to return as the bitter, jaded, probably a little stoned, MF Doom. Armed with an encyclopedic, hyper-referential flow and a crusty-*** metal mask, MF Doom will not rest until he is known as the “best emcee with no chain that you ever heard"

If it sounds a bit odd (see: nerdy) that a rapper would pattern his career after a comic book character... well, that’s because it is a bit odd. I suppose that’s part of the attraction of MF Doom, who could probably give a certain college dropout a run for the crown of the hardest working man in hip hop. Doom’s slurred, almost zen-like game is the result of years of mostly unrecognized efforts, from early 90's work with his late brother, DJ Sub-roc to his solo revival in part thanks to Bobbito Garcia’s NY-based Fondle ‘em record label. Following a string of underground releases in the past few years, 2004 gives way for three MF Doom releases, the most notable project, Madvillain, a pairing of MF Doom with another eccentric underground hip hop figure, Madlib.

Both Madlib and MF Doom have a lot in common, which makes the collaboration feel like the two have been partners for years. The love of jazz the two have is most apparent in Madlib’s production. A lo-fi affair, Madlib revisits the shades of blue he touched upon with his Blue Note-inspired/sampled release and the work of his fictional jazz unit, Yesterday’s New Quintet. Despite hailing from Oxnard, California, Madlib’s style is reminiscent of East Coast beat producers in a gritty, almost unpolished sense. It's far from minimalist but his technique here might fall somewhere between a more earthy Dan the Automator and a less apocalyptic El-Producto. This style molds perfectly around Doom’s monochromatic garble and the album is dressed appropriately for the occasion; Doom’s foreboding portrait stares back from the cover, Madlib on the back, looks on knowingly.

The duo also share a penchant for multiple personalities, many of which make guest appearances on Madvillainy. Madlib’s helium-voiced alter-ego, Quasimoto drops some Sun Ra-influenced philosophy on “Shades of Tomorrow," a droning number that has Madlib and Lord Quas wandering through a haze of stoned meanderings like “Yesterday belongs to the dead/Because the dead belongs to the past/The past is yesterday". Whispering vocals echo behind the verses and float in the smoke along with flutes and scratches. The track is an example of sum-of-parts-greater-than-the-parts-themselves theme which perhaps defines the effort. The lyrics are very atypical, non-rhyming (and might not amount to much except to those in altered states) and the syncopated beat is a bit daunting but the track is definitely a unique twist that works fairly well as a whole.

Not to be outdone, Viktor Vaughan (one of MF Doom’s other identities) takes a few shots at his other persona on “Fancy Clown," a phone conversation between a love spurned Vaughan and his woman, who cheats on him with “tin crown face", MF Doom. As if it weren’t bizarre enough to write a diss track about your other personality, Doom tries to top himself with songs about the horrors of a chick with bad breath (“Operation: Lifesaver A.K.A. Mint Test") and declares himself America’s Most Blunted. Doom spits like he has the encyclopedia of pop culture memorized word for word. Many other rappers drop in-jokes, sneaky wordplay and references in the lyrics but Doom draws on antiquated phrases and insanely obscure name drops as a major staple of his work. Among the most dense? Try the third verse on the album closer, ‘Rhinestone Cowboy" where he alludes to Eddie Murphy, Archie Bell and the Drells, The Great Space Coaster and even the circumstances surrounding the album itself, the demos of which leaked out onto the internet over a year before the final album made its debut.

Madvillainy lays out the premise very simply: MF Doom emcees, Madlib does the beats. Each artist is allowed to focus on their strength, lyrics and production respectively. Perhaps the most astounding result of this cooperation is how trim the final product is. The album is made up of 22 tracks but only three tracks break the 3 minute mark. A few sound-collage instrumentals pepper the album and add a noir-ish, old school Fantastic Four cartoon feel, “Rainbows" has MF Doom crooning instead of rapping and “Eye" is a R&B driven diversion. While these songs sidetrack a bit, they aren't the main reason the album comes out so thin. Rather, it is the lack of catchy hooks on any of the tracks really, that remove the fat. Doom comes out on the mic, spits a couple verses and then on to the next tune. It’s fairly refreshing to hear this kind of no-nonsense structure and the formula doesn’t harm the cohesion of the album as a whole.

It’s the fact that each piece, despite sometimes ending up fragmented and fleeting, builds into a unique presentation that makes Madvillainy a pleasure. With his work here, Madlib further cements himself into the role of hip hop visionary, continually orchestrating progressive and intriguing beats while never eschewing the more enjoyable and amusing aspects of the genre. Doom’s candid, laid-back lyricism is simplistic, street-smart and often extremely clever but perhaps takes a few listens to embrace. With that, a bit of wisdom from the man himself:

When he get the mic it's like the place get like, ‘Aww yeah!
It's like they know what’s ‘bout to happen
Just keep your eye out, like ‘aye, aye captain
Is he still a fly guy clappin' if nobody ain’t hearin’?
And can they testify from in the spirit
And living the true gods
Givin’ y’all nothing but the lick like two broads
Got more lyrics than the church got ‘ooh-lords
And he hold the mic and get your attention like two swords
(Either that) Or either one with two blades on it
Hey you, don't touch the mic like it's AIDS on it

Hooray for an album that stood up to the hype.

Recent reviews by this author
Times New Viking Rip It OffCaribou Andorra
Lee Hazlewood Cowboy in Swedenof Montreal Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?
OutKast IdlewildJohn Cale Fear
user ratings (2414)
other reviews of this album
Urinetrouble (4.5)
remember: ALL CAPS when you spell the name...

Necrotica (4.5)
A labyrinth of complexity and density, Stones Throw Records' finest ace their first album in stride....

hydeyomoney (4.5)
Too real for y'all?...

BaselineOOO (2.5)

related reviews

Madvillainy 2: The Madlib

Comments:Add a Comment 
December 31st 2004


Great review, and again this sounds interesting, what with the comics and all.

EDIT: and this is 12121th post, which I like.

December 31st 2004


I like this album. However, whenever I put it on I don't end up listening to it the whole way through, because there just isn't enough here that grabs me and keeps me with it. I find it interesting and I respect their originality, but it's not something I find myself listening to often. Good, but not among my top for the year.

Dig the Zappa sample in "Meat Grinder."

Zesty Mordant
December 31st 2004


^^^^, yeah what song is that?

man, i was just thinking of reviewing this album too. thank god i didn't because your review is way better than what i would've written. another excellent job man.

rep ++

oh yeah, and this album rocks too.

December 31st 2004


It's from "Sleeping In a Jar" on the Uncle Meat album.

Dancin' Man
December 31st 2004


Looks like we have a resident cool hip hop reviewer. Nice job. I'll check this out.

Robert Crumb
January 1st 2005


Room for one more? :wave:

February 7th 2005


good review, but should've given it 5 stars

February 24th 2006


Album Rating: 3.0

I still have yet to consider this album as 'classic' as everyone else. I guess I haven't listened to it much. I know there's something special in it though, so I guess in time.

Great review as always.

February 24th 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

This is a great hip hop album, but it's a bit overated.

The tracks that feature Lord Quas are my favorites, along with 'Rainbows.'

I think the album is just to long. Things don't get boring or anything but I can't sit all the way through this. I'm still not very familiar with the last three tracks or so.

February 25th 2006


This album is pretty good but got a lot of hype from some BS websites (thanks pitchforkmedia). I am a bit agitated by the short songs that a lot of indie hip hop (notably Prefuse73) assume. I like Deltron3030's more expansive sound.

May 22nd 2006


Album Rating: 4.5

Madvillain's second album is rumored to be coming out later this year ... awww yes.

Great review, by the way. I wish more Madlib and MF Doom projects got love in the Sputnik universe.

February 23rd 2007


Just picked this up on the weekend a long with Special Herbs Box Set. Although most of the songs are really good I didn't like how brief they were not to mention they were basically just one really long verse, not to say that verse wasn't amazing, I'm just saying I'd rather have at least two long 2 minute verses than just one in a song, with many instrumentals,most coming in at less than a minute, I felt the songs with lyrics should just have a little more.

Aside from that I loved the samples and beats the rhymes were tight and the album is pretty good overall. I don't see it as a classic though, there's just not enough here, Zappa had it when he said there's just not enough to "grab you" and "keep you with it"

4/5This Message Edited On 02.22.07This Message Edited On 02.22.07

The Jungler
March 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

this is better than I thought.

not as good as Quas' solo stuff though.

Dried Muffin Remnants
December 31st 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

This isn't overrated at all... MF Doom's got dirty rhymes and his synchrony with Madlib's beats is tight.

Dried Muffin Remnants
December 31st 2007


Album Rating: 4.0

Dr. Octagonecologist I like a bit more, though... The craziness has longer more enjoyable songs. Though nothing can match Madlib's production.

January 18th 2008


hey guys

this album is fuckin awesome

March 25th 2008


Hopefully it's better than your Have a Nice Life review.

March 25th 2008


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Neoteric, the master of giving witty responses to two month old posts.

August 10th 2008


Album Rating: 4.0

I love the album art

August 14th 2008


Love this album. The best.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy