Silver Side Up



by Fort23 USER (33 Reviews)
July 14th, 2007 | 9 replies

Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The album might have hooks, but it can't over shadow the mediocrity of the record and, therefore, the band.

Nickelback has made a career of mediocrity . Their constant recycle of cliche filled vocals, cliche filled guitar riffs, and a rhythm section that would be cliche filled if it wasn't for the fact that the rhythm section is basically inaudible, and if you could hear it, it would be as dull as it is inaudible.

Ahhh but as with many dull bands, there is always moments, sometimes entire albums where it works enough to please the hook laden section of the ear. With Nickelback, they make a handful of moments work on their breakthrough record, Silver Side Up. The most enjoyable, and therefore important part of the record is, of course, the hook factor. The band certainly has a niche for cooking up catchy hooks, and it is obvious in the lead off single, How you Remind Me. The crunchy guitar work flows well with the aforementioned hook laden part of the ear. Rhythm guitarist and lead singer Chad Kroeger might sing half heartedly in terms of the emotional aspect goes, his gravely voice is a good addition to the already well rounded, but pretentious song. Too Bad is another section of lacking lyrical potency, but it does leave a slight emotional touch that's lacking in almost all of the other tracks. The cheesy guitar solo might take away a little bit of the touch, but compared to what follows, little is to be explained.

But of course, the catchy aspect of the record does a bad job of overshadowing the band's obvious lack of lyrical chops. Chad Kroeger obviously has inspiration for his "angst-ridden" songs, but the overall turnout is very dull. With lines like, "My hopes just fell, and I can't see The reason why, why there is blood on my sleeve", it's obvious the bad teenage poetry is still rubbing off on the band's work.

Little hope is left elsewhere. We see ourselves watching the band churning out a track called Hollywood, a very sad attempt at lyrical inspiration, but comes out as a totally uninspiring track, with an a couple of equally dull guitar lines. The closing "ballad", Good Times Gone actually gives a country rockesque feel, which might seem like a welcome change from the incredibly dull outcome of the rest record, but it actually is part of the incredibly dull outcome of the album.

So we've seen the best of Nickelback in the full blown picture, and it comes out to be average at it's best. Hooks are plentiful, but they can't overshadow the overall dull aspects of the record, such as the lyrics. If any Nickelback interest might ensue, look here but look no further.

Recent reviews by this author
Future 56 Nights12million Nobody (with Chief Keef)
Earl Sweatshirt SolaceChief Keef Sorry 4 The Weight
G Herbo Welcome to FazolandToro Y Moi Causers of This
user ratings (1253)
other reviews of this album
Brendan Schroer (3.5)
Just a well-written, fun slab of post-grunge... nothing less, nothing more....

tiesthatbind (3)
As good as it was going to get for Nickelback....

The JoZ (2)

Storm In A Teacup (3.5)

Comments:Add a Comment 
July 14th 2007


You say "hook laden aspect" about 50 more times than you need to.

July 15th 2007


^Agree. The intro paragraph is really good, but it goes downhill from there. I've seen a lot better reviews from you.This Message Edited On 07.15.07

July 15th 2007


Album Rating: 3.5

aw, thats a shame

i love this album.. well most of it anyway

i suppose i'm biased though, because it reminds me of a certain period in my life

anyway, i much prefer this to their new, pop material

July 15th 2007


Album Rating: 1.0

Review is pretty good, but, like Valium said, there has been better from you. I don't like this album either.

July 15th 2007


How You Remind Me was a huge hit a while back and I guess it isn't too bad. But as a rule, Nickelback were never destined to be any good.

July 15th 2007


There are plenty of hooks in this review but it kinda came out dull at the end.

I'm kidding, but I agree with everyone when they say you have done better.

July 15th 2007


Album Rating: 3.5

Kool. If there is any tips on how I could do better next time, shoot.

July 29th 2007


Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

This was a good read, man- and I like the band.

Well, more this record than anything else they've done.

Also, calling a record label with The Dresden Dolls on it "mediocre"? Bad call.

April 1st 2015


Album Rating: 3.5

This fi

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy