Velvet Revolver
Libertad


3.5
great

Review

by Dave de Sylvia STAFF
July 6th, 2007 | 21 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A handful of jukebox-friendly hard rock tracks is almost as good an outcome as could be expected from this group of aging rockers.

Listening to Velvet Revolver’s new album Libertad, it’s more apparent than ever that, as a singer, Scott Weiland sounds infinitely more comfortable atop his current group’s compact, dynamic hard rock arrangements than he ever did with his one-time cohorts in Stone Temple Pilots. While the DeLeo brothers continue to make a hell of a racket with Filter’s Richard Patrick in Army Of Anyone, Weiland often appeared lost in the expanse between the brothers’ spacious, Sabbath-inspired riffs; the archetypal singer of instinct, it often felt with STP as if Scott had too much time to think. Almost without exception, the best-remembered Stone Temple Pilots tracks remain the ones which broke this mould: ‘Sex Type Thing’; ‘Crackerman’; ‘Interstate Love Song.’ Now, with three former members of Guns N’ Roses and an LA punk stalwart to back him, Weiland appears in his element, even more so here than on the cobbled-together debut Contraband.

Contraband’s many flaws were immediate and apparent: as early as the second track the lack of sonic diversity was apparent, and Josh Abraham’s (Static-X, Limp Bizkit) streamlined, muddy production did little to highlight the instrumental prowess of Slash & Co. With producer Brendan O’Brien, overseer of all five Stone Temple Pilots releases, in tow both problems have been rectified- Libertad is simultaneously more cohesive and more diverse than Contraband; for the first time, Velvet Revolver sound like a band rather than ‘Guns N’ Roses with Scott Weiland.’ If anything, the album is too accommodating of the singer- the hard hitting instrumental section remains, arguably, the band’s greatest asset and, while Duff McKagan’s thumping bass is too often conspicuously hidden in the mix, guitarist Slash and drummer Matt Sorum appear oddly restrained, exhibiting little of the playful indulgence which made tracks like ‘Set Me Free’ and ‘Slither’ so exciting.

For the most part, the compromise between the two poles yields satisfactory results. Lead single ‘She Builds Quick Machine’ is obviously tailored for radio, similar in structure and sound to Contraband’s ‘Slither,’ boasting a sultry, lustrous middle section which culminates in a firework-display solo from the bepermed one, while anti-drug rocker ‘Pills, Demons & Etc.’ (never use a comma when an ampersand will do) recalls Jimmy Page with a wah-assisted boogie guitar riff and Bono-inspired coo-ing from the singer. Token ballad ‘The Last Fight’ has shades of The Wildhearts’ ‘Lily’s Garden’ and the Marvelous 3’s ‘This Time,’ telling the story of a soldier who leaves for the front lines on bad terms with his significant other and all the ominous conclusions it entails; unlike Contraband’s ballads, however, ‘The Last Fight’ avoids standard rock ballad clichés, climaxing with additional layers of backing vocals rather than progressively loudening guitars a la ‘Fall To Pieces.’

Thematically, Libertad presents little outside of the ordinary: both Weiland’s brother Michael and Sorum’s brother Daniel died from separate drug overdoses during the recording of the album: ‘For A Brother’ and ‘Pills, Demons & Etc.’ are dedicated to the brothers’ alternating paths with regards to the demon drug. Weiland also finds time to comment on the state of the nation, decrying modern America’s misguided sense of entitlement on the Rubber Soul-inspired rocker ‘American Man’ and politely inviting the Paris Hiltons and Lindsay Lohans of this world to neuter themselves for the greater good in the hilarious Rose Tattoo-meets-Johnny Rotten punk rock number ‘Spay.’ Righteous anger aside, Weiland still manages to take things down to a personal level, taking a page out of his own diary with the Stonesy ‘Mary Mary’ (his wife’s name), the empathetic bonus track ‘Messages,’ which is inspired by reports of phone calls home from the doomed United Airlines Flight 93, and the aforementioned ‘The Last Fight.’

Yet where Libertad succeeds, it also disappoints. Weiland’s never quite regained his lyrical mojo since the troubled latter days of STP- limiting himself in recent years to the occasional irreverent classic like “went too fast, I’m outta luck and I don’t even give a fuck and “somebody raped my tapeworm abortion”- and Libertad does little to redress the balance; even well-meaning ballads like ‘The Last Fight’ and ‘Messages’ come across a little foolhardy, and “sister keeps her motor clean” (from ‘She Builds Quick Machines’) was a terrible line when AC/DC coined it thirty years ago, and posterity has done it few favours. ‘For A Brother’ is affectionate but unrefined, boasting the sole hastily-assembled chorus of the record, while ‘Fall To Pieces’-pastiche ‘Gravedancer,’ ‘American Man’ and ELO cover ‘Can’t Get It Out Of My Head’ pass by without leaving much of an impression, though the latter cover is delivered with a refreshing lack of irony (not to mention Slash’s best performance), symptomatic of the earnest, fun-loving spirit which permeates each of the band’s recordings.

Special mention must be made for Libertad’s opening trio: ‘Let It Roll,’ ‘She Mine’ and ‘Get Out The Door,’ and standout old-time rocker ‘Just Sixteen.’ ‘Get Out The Door,’ composed by guitarist Dave Kushner, is the obvious choice for a third single (following the obligatory ballad), juxtaposing a fuzzy, hard rock verse with a funky, dance-floor friendly chorus. ‘Let It Roll’ is an appropriately brainless blues-rocker to open the rocker, allowing Weiland to show off his cocksure Jim Morrisson-inspired brogue, while ‘She Mine’ and ‘Just Sixteen’ juxtapose Chuck Berry-style rhythms and blues licks with sugar-laden pop chorus about bi-polar disorders and horny teachers respectively. Libertad, regrettably, can’t sustain the quality of the above tracks over forty-five minutes- but a handful of jukebox-friendly hard rock tracks and a thoroughly replayable album is almost as good an outcome as could be expected from this group of aging rockers.



Recent reviews by this author
And So I Watch You From Afar GangsAll Time Low Dirty Work
Linkin Park A Thousand SunsAdebisi Shank This is the Second Album
AFI Crash Lovefun. Aim and Ignite

user ratings (412)
Chart.
3.1
good
other reviews of this album
AshtrayTheUnforgiven (4)
Although Libertad does succeed where Contraband fails, and shows a musical progression, the band's r...

bastard (3)
Slash and friends do a nice job....

tribestros (4.5)
The true defining 80s rock revival record to have. Slash is at the top of his game and so is Scott ...

grungekicksmetalsass (3.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
StreetlightRock
Emeritus
July 6th 2007


3899 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Took your time didn't you? >: ( Sounds exactly as I thought it would turn out, and another solid as hell review.This Message Edited On 07.06.07

Digging: Julien Baker - Turn Out The Lights

renegadestrings
July 6th 2007


1510 Comments


fantastic review, one of the best i've read. the ending is especially smart..

"‘Get Out The Door,’ composed by guitarist Dave Kushner, is the obvious choice for a third single (following the obligatory ballad)"
i will definitely pick this up

The Jungler
July 6th 2007


4826 Comments


I'm not big on this band, and I would be amazed if I ever hear anything off this besides the singles.

Review was great though.This Message Edited On 07.06.07

JohnXDoesn't
July 6th 2007


1354 Comments


this is a good review. they have this on rhapsody i'll listen one day....maybe next year

Aficionado
July 6th 2007


1027 Comments


Terrible terrible band...good review though

ZFighter142
July 6th 2007


205 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

nice review and not bad as in far of ratings for the album...i'll pick it up but one thing for sure is that i wasnt all that impressed by there single.. This Message Edited On 07.06.07

Bfhurricane
July 6th 2007


6211 Comments


Very nice review. Ill be sure to check this out. If its better than Contraband then Ill be pleased

McKagan
July 8th 2007


7 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Disappointing album tbh Scott Weiland's mediocre talents really drag everyone else down

Skyler
July 10th 2007


1084 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Excellent review as always. I haven't heard a good straight-up hard rock album like this in quite a while.

Meatplow
July 11th 2007


5524 Comments


I am quite fond of STP, and i liked the Gunner's. I also liked Velvet Revolver, though not as much. I will have to check this one out.

Two-Headed Boy
July 12th 2007


4527 Comments


Great review as usual.

Ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh not a big VR fan.

Shuffle It All
July 26th 2007


121 Comments


man, this album is nothing compared to contraband, the lyrics on contraband were weird, these are just childlike, its just quite sad to hear this album.

duff's awsome bass tone has dissapeared, and theres no where near as many sounds and experimentation form dave kushner.

the review is good, but i think youve got it wrong, this is a bad album, and im a big VR fan.

P3arlJamm3r
August 4th 2007


8 Comments


Weiland? Mediocre? Get the hell out of here with that crap.

Ire
November 15th 2007


41948 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Why I had this at a 4.5 I will never know.

shindip
April 4th 2009


3536 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Liked the review more than the album. Some songs are pretty good, but most are forgettable.

NastyVJ
March 25th 2010


17 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Opinions on music are as diverse as those who have them - I like this album a lot, but I get why others don't. I had low expectations and was pleasantly surprised.

joesmoe4000
May 29th 2010


582 Comments


very disappointed with this one

Digging: Young Lay - Black 'n Dangerous

EVedder27
May 29th 2010


6088 Comments


whole project was a disappointment for the most part

Ire
May 29th 2010


41948 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Silly me.

danielcardoso
Contributing Reviewer
August 27th 2014


11555 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

edit



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy