">
 

The White Stripes
Icky Thump


3.5
great

Review

by sonictheplumber USER (92 Reviews)
June 24th, 2007 | 14 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist


We've all waited two years. Finally, The White Stripes have released a new album. To be quite honest with you, I was hoping for another White Blood Cells or another Elephant, because both of which are superb albums. But I'm fine with Icky Thump. It's more hard-rocking than Get Behind Me Satan, and more diverse than some of the other albums by the band. Overall, it is a satisfying release.

The title track kicks off the album as being one of the greatest songs on here. "Icky Thump" is a fantastic song with everything I love about The White Stripes in it. It's raw. It's got power. It's bluesy. It's flat-out fun. The main thing that truly bugs me about this track is the over-usage of the Univox synthesizer and some (and I use this term loosely) bland guitar-work, but overall, this track is very diggable.

Another one of the highlights of this album is the track that immediately follows the title track. "You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do As You're Told)" is a shining moment on here. The song is just great fun, much like the song that precedes it. The guitar is not wankerish in any way whatsoever. It's smooth, and the riffs go right along with the flow of the song, whereas in "Icky Thump", there was some over-usage of wankerish guitar-playing and such. This song is a nice country-ish tune, with an old, classic rock sound to it. "Icky Thump" is the better song, but this is quite enjoyable as well.

Already we have straight-forward rock and roll (with some strange elements to it) and a country-esque tune. Those are two highlights, so yeah, we're off to a superb start. But, not everything is fine and dandy, and you will learn this by listening to "Conquest". It does grow on thyself after many listens, but it is certainly not a highlight, by no means. It is similar to "I Think I Smell A Rat" off of White Blood Cells, but that is a much better song. This track is a cover of some old 50's tune, and while it may be considered experimental for the Stripes to put this on here, it's really just an annoying (yet catchy) song that has a Latin feel to it.

Also, the celtic Scottish folk songs are not that great either. They may be better than "Conquest", but these are not highlights at all. One of these two tracks did happen to grow on me though. "Prickly Thorn, But Sweetly Worn" is by no means a crappy number, but compared to some of the other things that this album has to offer, it is not that great. Now, "St. Andrew (This Battle Is In The Air)" comes right afterwards, and it follows the same tradition as the track that precedes it. The two are in fact almost identical. So in conclusion, St. Andrew is Scottish filler, but Prickly Thorn is a grows-on-you-after-numerous-listens type of track.


Hey Sonic, wait just a minute. What is your personal favorite song on the album; a song that everybody should hear or download? What is a track so delightfully catchy and fun that it deserves to be two lines seperated from everything written above it? Well, my friend/enemy, the answer to that question is this: Rag And Bone. This track is the main highlight of Icky Thump. This is a classic Stripes song if there ever was one. The pure, bluesy catchiness of this song is magnificent and unmatched by any other song on here. The guitar? Jack White's playing is simple and subtle, and I cannot stress this enough: It's freaking bluesy. The song is Meg and Jack talking, singing, and playing their instruments. The two of them describe the events of being rag-and-bone people. They take one person's junk and turn it into something useful. This song shows that the band still have a good sense of humor, and that they know when to record a goofy and fun track like this. It blows everything that surrounds it right out of the water.


The remainder tracks on the album are also quite well-done, but nothing compared to the sheer magnificence of Rag and Bone.

In conclusion, The White Stripes' Icky Thump is a pretty good album, and it is truly their best album since 2003's Elephant. It is not quite White Blood Cells, which is (if you have not yet guessed by now) my favorite Stripes album. It cost sixteen dollars, but after listening to it many, many times, I truly think that it was money well spent. So, once again, the Stripes have put out a very enjoyable record, and it is one that fans of their more rock-oriented material will greatly enjoy.

The Best:
Icky Thump
You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do As You're Told)
Rag and Bone

The Worst:
St. Andrew
Conquest

3.75/5



Recent reviews by this author
Autopsy Mental FuneralEd Wynne Shimmer Into Nature
ZZ Top Tres HombresBeherit Seventh Blasphemy (Demo)
Johnny Winter Live Johnny Winter AndCeltic Frost Emperor's Return
user ratings (1295)
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Iai EMERITUS (3.5)
    A successful return to the band's roots after the self-indulgent Get Behind Me Satan. Jus...

    theoddthinker (4.5)
    Dividing opinions though it may be, this White Stripes album has something for everyone....

    tribestros (2.5)
    Doesn't sound as raw and garage rock as The White Stripes should; borders on Scottish folk...

    TwistandShout (3.5)
    A good album, minus the scottish crap. Still need to go back to their roots, but they're g...

  • TheSpearKid (4)
    The latest effort from the White Stripes shows that after a year in radio rock, Jack White...

    LoganKYoung (3)
    Bottom line, whatever you've heard from The White Stripes before - even all you pre-fame t...



Comments:Add a Comment 
MeowMeow
June 25th 2007


662 Comments


Unnecessary.

Yazz_Flute
June 25th 2007


19174 Comments


popular album to review lately. Still, pretty good one, ill vote now.

muchtallerthanu
June 25th 2007


648 Comments


I never was big on the White Stripes, but this is a good review. I don't like the drummer though. Give me a set of drumsticks and I'll out-drum her ass any day :cool:

astrel
June 25th 2007


2615 Comments


Even if cut both your arms off and have them shoved up your ass...you would still probably be a better drummer than Meg White.

ValiumMan
June 25th 2007


493 Comments


The White Stripes are overrated as fuck IMHO. Review was kinda average.

El_Goodo
June 25th 2007


1016 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Ah Meg White bashing yay! Her drums fit the songs perfectly and unlike some drummers she has no problem with being quiet or not playing for some parts of the songs. She is the Ringo of the Stripes...playing simple yet imaginative parts that fit the songs in ways no other drummer could. Would anyone else think of playing only the bass drum during Seven Nation Army? That bass drum adds a hypnotic sound to the song...any other drummer would not have been content with playing that they'd add in something else.

Aficionado
June 25th 2007


1027 Comments


Unnecessary


Fuck, what review IS necessary. All i've seen from you is writing unnecessary in everyone's review. If you think it's unnecessary then don't read the review.

Good job.

tribestros
June 25th 2007


918 Comments


Unnecessary is when there's 10+ reviews for an album. btw, nice review.This Message Edited On 06.25.07

Aficionado
June 25th 2007


1027 Comments


If i wrote a 10'000 days review.

THAT'd be unnecessary. Heck there's only been 4 prior to this.

tribestros
June 25th 2007


918 Comments


LOL...

I've never seen so many reviews in my life...

rattlehead42147
June 26th 2007


1345 Comments


sonic ventured outside his comfortable classic rock/metal zone

colbywieseler
June 26th 2007


4 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

dude i agree with you megs drumming fits the song very well but, true she does suck.

chronikkda_punk
July 6th 2007


27 Comments


Cool, ill def get this album, i luv white stripes :D

KILL
March 5th 2012


81582 Comments


gay band agreed



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy