The Walkmen
Everyone Who Pretended To Like Me Is Gone



by Scott Herren USER (42 Reviews)
January 16th, 2005 | 8 replies

Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist

Released: 2002

The Walkmen rose from the ashes of two garage rock bands, Jonathan Fire Eater and the Recoys, and formed in New York, New York in 2000. This is a very close-knit band, as the members grew up in the Washington, D.C. area and have played with each other in the same bands since the fifth grade. As if they couldn't get any closer, two of the band members (Martin and Leithauser) are actually cousins.

The Walkmen intentionally change their sound to move away from their garage rock roots. They are one of the few bands that uses an upright piano, and boy what a defining feel it gives to their songs. They also experiment with various instrumentation and recording techniques. Their influences are a who's who of 70's and 80's post-punk and alternative, deriving their sound from such bands as Joy Division, The Cure, The Pixies, The Velvet Underground, Brian Eno, The Smiths, and Television.

Everyone Who Pretended To Like Me Is Gone is the full length debut for the Walkmen, and was critically acclaimed despite staying mostly within indie circles. They are known by many as "the band from that car commercial", as their single "We've Been Had" was the theme for Mitsubishi for a while. That song, oddly enough isn't even one of the stronger songs on this great album.

Depite the obvious attempt to get away from a garage rock feel, the songs are still driven by dark, raw guitar riffs, and with some lovely piano parts intertwined with them. This is a very gritty album, similar in that right to their New York City counterparts Interpol and Radio 4.

Since the release of Everyone Who Pretended To Like Me Is Gone, The Walkmen have gone on a world tour, and recently (this year) released their sophomore effort Bows & Arrows (which I will likely review). The new album is more polished, but lacks that freshness of their debut.

Hamilton Leithauser - Guitar, Vocals
Paul Maroon - Guitar, Piano
Walter Martin - Organ, Tapes
Matt Barrick - Drums
Peter Bauer - Bass
Kirsten McCord - Strings

Notable Songs

Wake Up
This song starts off with a repeating distant grungy guitar riff, then the distinct upright piano comes in plucking away at keys seemingly at random. The drums come in banging away. One of the most identifiable voices in music then comes in lazily, and the song melts into one odd hosh-posh of sounds that may have been thrown together on a whim. The lackidasical singing fits nicely with the mood of the song. Did he just wake up" A great opener. "Haven't we met before" Under brighter skies I......................" The part right near the end is the highlight when the guitar backs off and he sings "anyway that's fine...we're walking through an...unfamiliar scene...we're choking on it..."

Everyone Who Pretended To Like Me Is Gone
This song is slow to develop as what sounds like an organ slowly fades in. Then there is the sound of cymbals and finally drums to go along with the droning organ. After a minute or so the song has faded in and some falsetto vocals come in. This is a more uptempo song than the previous one. There seems to be more focus, which is a good thing for the type of song that it is. The highlight is when he sings the chorus of "I made the best of it."

Revenge Wears No Wristwatch
This song starts with a grity guitar riff repeated. As expected drums come in shortly after. The sustained notes from the organ fit nicely. The way he sings the lyrics are again in a lazy type of way. It seems like the lyrics don't fit the emotion of the song. "I've had it up to here". So" If this is him upset, I would love to hear him calm. Anyway, the song progresses nicely. Right after the chorus there is a instrumental section where the guitar switches things up a bit. After the second verse the drums all the sudden lose the cymbals and switch timings, but it all meshs beautifully. This is my favorite song on the album.

French Vacation
A high shimmering guitar riff characterizes this song. It is a bit distorted and there is some drone. The change up in the high guitar after the first line of vocals is beautiful and one of the highlights on the album. There are some arpeggios as the vocals end, then there is a short guitar solo where the beautiful guitar riff takes center stage. This is actually a song that could be straight out of a 60's or 70's film about the streets of New York. It just has that sort of grity, dirty feel to it (see album cover). I really love this song.

We've Been Had
This is the song that most people have heard as it is the single and was featured in that car commercial. It isn't one of my favorites on the album, but deserves mention because many people like it. It has a different feel from the rest of the album. There is a repeating clean piano that fades in. Vocals are "I'm a modern guy...I don't care much for go-go...or the retro...image I see so...often telling me to keep...trying and maybe you'll get here...someday." The shimmering piano is joined by what could be organ or guitar with effects. Not that this is a bad song, but it is more poppy than the rest of the album. I do like the part where he sings "see me age 19 with some dumb haircut from 1950". You will probably like this song because it's hard to dislike, but don't get the idea that this is typical Walkmen.

Recommended for fans of:
The French Kicks

I'm not going to lie to you and say that I just put on this album and it was the greatest thing. The style, particularly on the vocals, takes some getting used to, but after a couple listens this album is like nicotine. I try to give this a spin at least once every couple of weeks because it is just a very solid debut album from a band that is growing into one of my favorites.

Recent reviews by this author
Royksopp Melody A.M.Metric Old World Underground, Where Are You Now
Ride NowhereClearlake Cedars
The Walkmen Bows + ArrowsJamiroquai A Funk Odyssey
user ratings (85)

Comments:Add a Comment 
December 1st 2004


I love this album and I think it's better than Bows and Arrows. Likewise you're right in saying that this album takes some time to enjoy, I loved it off the bat, but for others it may take sometime. I like the bleakness of the album and the 'bare to the bones' production really helps this album out.

I'm a Spoon fan aswell and I'm looking forward to the new album coming out some time this year. However, I find Spoon to much 'fuller' with their sound. You should do a review on Kill the Moonlight or Girls Can Tell.

P.S. My band covered 'French Vacation'.

December 1st 2004


Well i was disappointed with Bows and Arrows. I though there was a lot of good stuff on it but the production frustrated me every now and again. Some of their ideas didn't come out well in my opinion, and as you say the vocals are very much an aquired taste. But if you two think this is better than B+A then i will certainly give it a go.

December 1st 2004


[QUOTE=moderaterock222]Well i was disappointed with Bows and Arrows. I though there was a lot of good stuff on it but the production frustrated me every now and again. Some of their ideas didn't come out well in my opinion, and as you say the vocals are very much an aquired taste. But if you two think this is better than B+A then i will certainly give it a go.[/QUOTE]

Yeah I think you should give this album a listen. Bows are Arrows though isn't a bad album though, if it was a follow up to any other album it would definatly be looked upon as being a better peice of work. It kind of gets the cold shoulder but EWPTLMIG is just that great of an album.

December 1st 2004


I saw them live; they opened for a Modest Mouse show. I rather liked them, though no one else seemed to. I'll definitely have to go pick up the album, now that I know what it is.

The Jungler
June 15th 2006


I'm starting to get into these guys, they're great.

December 17th 2012


Album Rating: 4.0

Just got this...very cool album

Digging: Glassjaw - Material Control

June 30th 2013


I like this a lot, but I can't get into fsr

Digging: Mortiferum - Altar of Decay

July 4th 2015


Album Rating: 4.0

coolest walkmen album for sure

Digging: Girl Ray - Earl Grey

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy