Neil Young
Harvest Moon



by BasementMovies USER (7 Reviews)
April 1st, 2007 | 16 replies

Release Date: 1992 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The sequel to Harvest, what more could you want?

After the loud, raw Ragged Glory/Weld tour in 91, Neil Young was recovering from tinnitus and had decided to put down the distorted electric guitar and to revisit his acoustic side, as exhibited on the chart-topping Harvest and lesser-known Comes A Time. The result was Harvest Moon.

1) Unknown Legend

This song sets the tone for the rest of the album. It’s played in a very country style, with the lyrics telling of a free-spirited woman who rides the desserts with a Harley-Davidson. Neil Young veteran, Ben Keith’s slide guitar stands out, as well as with female backing vocals from (also Neil Young veterans) Nicolette Larson and Linda Ronstadt. There are some nice clean electric guitar fills in between verses that you will be humming for hours after hearing. 4/5

2) From Hank To Hendrix

This is an upbeat song about a woman Neil loves who he’s been with since, well forever. It’s a nice upbeat song with lots of Neil’s classic folk harmonica, pump organ between verses and a prominently thumpy bass line. Neil does it again with his lyrics, especially how he expresses his love for music in “Can we get it together, Can we still stand side by side, Can we make it last, Like a musical ride?” 5/5

3) You and Me

One word. Reverb. This song is performed solo by Neil, sounding like he’s playing alone to himself in an empty auditorium. It’s a very mellow, repetitive song (like Round and Round off of Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere) with lots of his trademark slides and hammer-ons. He starts to duet with Nicolette Larson after a while, and the song ends suddenly at nearly the four-minute mark. 3.5/5

4) Harvest Moon

This, the title track, most popular song and sole Greatest Hits representative off of Harvest Moon is by no means overrated. Corny at times, yes, but a solid song as well. The sound of a broom being swept features in the background prominently, providing an atmospheric touch to the mellow country-style ballad that is ‘Harvest Moon’. The lyrics are pretty unremarkable, just a typical love-ballad, but are still very catchy, along with the acoustic lick the pops up here and there. The harmonica solo towards he end is one of Neil’s best. 5/5

5) War of Man

This is (how can I say this?) the “heaviest” song on the album. Like ‘No Wonder’ off of Prairie Wind, this song definitely stands apart from the other songs, mainly because it features more ‘rock’ style instrumentation (dig Kenny Buttrey’s drums) than the country feel on the rest of the album, and the lyrics paint a more abstract mental picture. The backing vocalists take over at one point, and Neil lays his patented acoustic playing style all over the place. A nice little solo mimicking the vocal line pops up at the end, and the song fades out right before you start to get bored. Perfecto. 4/5

6) One of These Days

This is one of the songs you just know is going to close the concert when he plays it, it just has that feel to it (he actually did so in the ‘Heart of Gold’ movie, which you should check out by the way). The chorus is catchy as hell, and it’s hard to not sing along with it if you’re driving in a car or are alone listening to it. The lyrics are uplifting, but closer analysis really shows their sour side; the line “One of these days, I'm gonna’ sit down and write a long letter ,To all the good friends I've known” could actually mean that he he’ll never actually get around to said task. Still, nice song. 4.5/5

7) Such a Woman

Ah, the big, orchestral piece, the ‘There’s A World’, the ‘A Man Needs A Maid’, the ‘Living With War’. It’s over before you know it, but it’s a beautiful love song. The lyrics are few, but nice, telling of the only woman who can fulfill Neil’s love so much. Give it a listen, Jack Nitzsche (pronounced Nitch-ee, and not Neech-yeh)’s string arrangement is fantastic. 4.5/5

8) Old King

This is a fun song. It features Neil plucking a banjo riff that’ll be bouncing around in your head for days and a fast-paced tempo. The song itself is about Neil’s faithful dog, Elvis, and their adventures together before he “up and died”. I’m not sure if it’s a satire off hick-style music or just unintentionally that way, but this little two-minute gem is a funny one. 4.5/5

9) Dreamin’ Man

This song is a predecessor of ‘Here for You’ from Prairie Wind, with similar arrangement and vocal line, and since I heard the latter first, I can’t help but compare this one to that one. It’s an upbeat song, with a little, plucky riff between verses and somewhat angelic backing vocals. This is one of the more forgettable numbers (I stress no bad connotations on that statement), but it is not as bland and empty like, say, ‘You And Me’ or ‘War of Man’, so it’s still worth a listen. 3/5

10) Natural Beauty

Over the years, Neil Young has been known for either long, drawn out epic album closers (i.e.: Cowgirl In The Sand and Words) or short little ditties that discretely end the albums (* la Cripple Creek Ferry). Natural Beauty is a long (clocking at over ten minutes long) acoustic eco-ballad seemingly recorded live. After some rowdy fan applause, the epic tale begins, with Neil proclaiming that “Natural Beauty should be preserved like a monument” and how the world is going to hell. Great harmonica and words and that still ring true today fill this song and even though it’s extended length can seem like a lot to fill in without numerous distorted guitar solos and thousands of verses, the song barely gets boring, and the album goes out like Rust Never Sleeps, fading out over the sound of the audience applauding, but this time cross-fading into the sound of a cricket chirping, on this Harvest Moon. 5/5

Recent reviews by this author
The Doors Absolutely LiveNeil Young Live at Massey Hall 1971
Neil Young Time Fades AwayThe Band Stage Fright
John Lennon Live In New York CityThe Band Cahoots
user ratings (349)

Comments:Add a Comment 
Two-Headed Boy
April 2nd 2007


I need to spin up some Neil. I've been digging Rust alot lately, so I might have to dig into my dad's collection and take some stuff out.

Good review, quite descriptive.

April 2nd 2007


i've heard neil young's name being thrown around a whole lot on sputnik lately, im intrigued... any suggestions on where i should start? i was looking at checking out stuff from this album based on this review. good job man

April 2nd 2007


i've heard neil young's name being thrown around a whole lot on sputnik lately, im intrigued... any suggestions on where i should start? i was looking at checking out stuff from this album based on this review
you should check out Decade first. Great review btw. Neil Young is simply...awesome. This Message Edited On 04.02.07

April 2nd 2007


thanks wakeupdead, i'll look into Decade,

and hopefully ill look into Harvest Moon as well and be able to rate and comment on this album for you, mr. basement movies

April 2nd 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

Instead of Decades (it might be expensive) get Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere.

Great review, dude.

December 4th 2007


Album Rating: 4.5

Fucking underrated album right here.

December 24th 2007


I got this a little while ago, and it has grown on me. Very nice.

August 14th 2014


colliding with the very air she breathes~~~~~~~~~~~~~

July 3rd 2016


Album is the bollocks

Staff Reviewer
July 18th 2017


This one's hitting the spot right now.

March 5th 2020


Album Rating: 4.0

I know this isn't a unique opinion but the title track just makes me melt every time.

Methinks this album doesn't get quite the attention it deserves

November 17th 2020


Album Rating: 4.5

on Sput it sure doesn't. Has 3.7 on RYM which is equivalent to 4.1 on Sputnik. In my realm of consciousness, this is one of the most popular Young albums next to Harvest and After the Gold Rush. It's definitely grown on me over the years, because when I first heard it I thought it was lame compared to Ditch trilogy. Review doesn't mention that "You and Me" has very similar chord progression to "Old Man" and also features Ronstadt who was on both songs.

February 3rd 2022


Album Rating: 3.5

Unknown Legend is fucking awesome

February 3rd 2022


Tbh you strike me as the type to be boycotting Neil Young right now reef

February 3rd 2022


Album Rating: 3.5


July 29th 2023


Album Rating: 4.0

Neil's 1969-1976 run is so GOATED it truly outshines his other stuff even when it reaches 95% of amazingness, tbf.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2023
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy