">
 

Cake
Comfort Eagle


5.0
classic

Review

by e p USER (4 Reviews)
January 15th, 2005 | 24 replies


Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist


Comfort Eagle

History










Quote:
Cake was formed in Sacramento, California in 1992 by vocalist/songwriter John McCrea, who'd recently returned home after spending a few years in Los Angeles, unsuccessfully trying to break into the music business.
Cake is an unknown alternative band. Their music is simple, yet complex. It is hard to explain, yet those that have listened may know what I mean. Cake's simple choice of melodies and ability to blend their instruments is one of their talents. Another would be John McCrea's sometimes bland, sometimes emotional, vocals. Perhaps another would be their use of trumpets and another would be their driving bass. All in all, Cake is very unique and seem to offer a style of their own.

Tracks
Opera Singer
Fast drum work starts off this catchy opener. Simple guitar lines and pushing bass keep this song driving. The verse is primarily about the narrator being an Opera Singer and his adventures. Background organs and horn accompaniment keep this song fresh. One of the best tracks on the album. 5/5

Meanwhile, Rick James...
Despite what the title may suggest, this is not a "super freaky" romp. It is actually a laid back song with bass and organ/piano being the dominant instruments. Reverby guitar and echoing vocals give it an interesting feel. Personally it reminds me of a rainy day. Violin, too.

Shadow Stabbing
Catchy lyrics and acoustic guitar parts. Percussion-oriented. Laid-back yet driving(true Cake). Low 4 possibly but I'm giving it a: 3/5

Short Skirt/Long Jacket
Trumpets and bass driven. Catchy verse-riff. Vocals drive the song for the most part. One of the catchiest and "rockiest" tracks on the album. It has small Latin influences. 5/5

Symphony in C
The instruments mainly are background to the main part of the story, a man who tells his tale of the Symphony that he heard. Great vocals and catchy song, though a bit bland at times where it should be, the bands keeps it going. 4/5

Arco Arena
Guitar driven instrumental. Extremely rythmic and riff-heavy. Good use of the organ/electric guitars to provide an eerie sense to it. If it wre streched into 3+ minutes it would definately be a high 4 or 5 but it is only 1:30. 3/5

Comfort Eagle
Heavy. Pulsing drums and buss/guitar in unison. Great use of all the band members' ability to sing. McCrea does a great job on this title track with his soinging/lyrics. Eastern sounding at times. Catchy, heavy, distorted, great. 5/5

Long Line of Cars
Often Drifting at times, yet pulled together with a multiple brass instruments. Dominated by trumpets, vocals, and oddly, a shaker. A song of bitterness and spite, I believe. 3.5/5

Love You Madly
A simple love song. Once again ryhthmic drums, pushing bass. Vocals and hand claps add to the excitement, while the horn riff pushes it into a peak. 5/5

Pretty Pink Ribbon
Easy going song about devotion. I've never quite understood the lyrics or the song in general. This song does nothing for me. 3/5

World of Two
Serene. Little percussion. Tambourine. Occasional bass, but mostly organs and vocals. Nice way to end the album. 4/5

Overall I would rate this a: 5/5

I believe it comes only second (maybe first) to Cake's Fashion Nugget, which also is deserving of a 5/5. Great album for new and old fans alike.

[URL=http://www.mtv.com/bands/az/cake/295826/album.jhtml]Samples[/URL]

:thumb:


user ratings (442)
3.9
excellent


Comments:Add a Comment 
keep on phishin'
October 22nd 2004


71 Comments


I've been wanting to get into Cake for some time now. I think now I'm going to download some songs.

Good Review as well.

The JoZ
October 22nd 2004


345 Comments


Cake is awesome, from the singles I've heard.

Now I have a reason to pick up an album

Per Ardua Ad Astra
October 22nd 2004


106 Comments


I love this album.
This is the only alternative album that i can listen to, i love it.

Dancin' Man
October 22nd 2004


719 Comments


The biggest flaw with Cake is the trumpet playing. It's not very good. Not bad, but if they had a really good trumpeteer it would up the music that much more. Great album and band.

e p
October 22nd 2004


9 Comments


Thanks guys.

I also edited a link where you can listen to some samples. It's up top ^

sr800bkBassist
October 22nd 2004


115 Comments


my cousin from Indiana is a huge fan.

i like their bassist a lot.

Scott Herren
October 22nd 2004


192 Comments


How is the album 5/5 when only 4 songs of 11 are 5/5? This is far from a 5/5. I'd say more of a 2.8/5.

manuscriptreplica
October 22nd 2004


431 Comments


Their bassist is one of the reasons I became one myself.

e p
October 22nd 2004


9 Comments


[QUOTE=Scott Herren]How is the album 5/5 when only 4 songs of 11 are 5/5? This is far from a 5/5. I'd say more of a 2.8/5.[/QUOTE]


But you'll notice that a lot of the songs are 4/4.

The few 3/5 songs are rated for shortness, not talent. Were they stretched out they would be 4+.

Like I said before, this is some of Cake's best work. But keep in mind this is obviously all my opinion. This album relies on the power of all the tracks rather than a few. That's why its a 5/5.

Dark Hero
October 23rd 2004


160 Comments


I'll look into this.

manuscriptreplica
October 23rd 2004


431 Comments


[QUOTE=e p]But you'll notice that a lot of the songs are 4/4.

The few 3/5 songs are rated for shortness, not talent. Were they stretched out they would be 4+.

Like I said before, this is some of Cake's best work. But keep in mind this is obviously all my opinion. This album relies on the power of all the tracks rather than a few. That's why its a 5/5.[/QUOTE]

It's an easy way to get into the genre, which is why it gets a 5/5 from me.

Gibbers3095
October 23rd 2004


2 Comments


I like Cake quite a bit, but I think Fashion Nugget was definitely far better.

OrbDragon
October 23rd 2004


152 Comments


Great review...this is one of the most fun bands around in my opinion.

Scythe404
October 23rd 2004


43 Comments


Nice review. They are a criminally underrated band in my opinion. Any Alt fan should at least listen to an album.

Dancin' Man
October 23rd 2004


719 Comments


[QUOTE=Gibbers3095]I like Cake quite a bit, but I think Fashion Nugget was definitely far better.[/QUOTE]


Seconded.

e p
October 23rd 2004


9 Comments


[QUOTE=Gibbers3095]I like Cake quite a bit, but I think Fashion Nugget was definitely far better.[/QUOTE]


[QUOTE=Fast Fingers]Seconded.[/QUOTE]



[QUOTE=e p]
I believe it comes only second (maybe first) to Cake's Fashion Nugget...



:thumb:[/QUOTE]



I'm well aware.

:thumb:

FillInTheBlankHere___
October 23rd 2004


64 Comments


This is one of my favourite CDs of all time, and the one that broke me out of my mainstream listening ways. :thumb:

It well deserves another good listen on my part, I haven't been listening to it frequently for almost 3 years. I worshipped John McCrea for a *very* long time.

Kwash2
November 28th 2004


6 Comments


[QUOTE=manuscriptreplica]Their bassist is one of the reasons I became one myself.[/QUOTE]
Agreed.

Tangy zizzle
November 28th 2004


253 Comments


Cake aren't unknown. They're actually one of the bigger "alternative" acts.

manuscriptreplica
November 28th 2004


431 Comments


When they are on MTV they are not unknown



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy