">
 

Celtic Frost
Monotheist


3.0
good

Review

by Dethtrasher USER (232 Reviews)
December 5th, 2006 | 91 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist


Celtic Frost, was and are probably one of the most influential metal bands in Europe during the eighties, especially in the black and occult metal scene. Hellhammer was the ultimate beginning for the band but with time the band changed both name and style. Celtic Frost was born thanks to the front man Tom Hunter, and Celtic Frost is a band that has been experimenting with their material. I have heard a lot of bands that has changed their sound quite a bit but still had their basic formula still present in their music. But Celtic Frost is probably the only band I have seen done such drastic changes in their music, as I once saw a second-short video clip where Celtic Frost was playing live and they performed the song called Circle Of The Tyrants. It sounded pretty much black and death-metal and I thought that this band would probably stay outside my personal interests, but I started later to look for some of their music after listening to Obituary's cover of that particular song. I looked for facts and then I saw the genres that the band has been playing in and are still playing: from thrash/black/death to even glam rock and then onto some sort of gothic doom metal mix. Their three first albums are considered to their best albums because they represent the band musical style much better than the other albums. The band broke up a few times, as Tom Hunter was also during that time working in an other band called Apollyon Sun. But that band would also run its own race and later Tom came back and reunited Celtic Frost to record their comeback album. It was a huge gap from 1992 to 2006, and during that time the band was working on the album called Monotheist, but this album also proved to be a fan splitting album.

All is cold and frozen.
Frozen the sea, frozen the sky.
Frozen is death, but I cannot die.

With Monotheist, the music is at least as sick as the spooky album cover, and I would describe this album as twisted, sick, weird but still melodic and beautiful at times. It was released in 2006 and they even took help from the metal god Peter Tagtgren from Hypocrisy during the final recording of the album. The songs here varies between intense black/doom and sometimes gothic ballads, with Progeny, Ground and Os Abysmi Vel Daath being some of the tracks that I think have more black-metal influences, both musically and vocally, and these are also some of the songs that dislike the most. A Dying Good Coming Into Human Flesh starts with both calm vocals and guitars making it very melodic from the start, but it will eventually get more instruments and a different vocal work which will make also sound a bit black/doomish. Drown In Ashes and Obscured sound more like peaceful ballads, because here you even have beautiful, angelic female vocals haunting the songs alongside Tom Hunter's "speaking" so to say. The songs are also quite atmospheric and they do have a catchy and melodic vibe. Obscured takes on a more depressive and sad approach rather than haunting and beautiful as Drown In Ashes. Domain Of Decay reminds a bit of morbid Hypocrisy essence, as it enters with heavy soaring guitars and strained vocals and has a twisted but half-groovy tempo. Ain Elohim starts off with a more death-metal based formula, because it enters with double bass kicking drums and simplistic guitar work, and the vocals sound once again strained and loud, though it varies a bit near the end when it sounds more calm and has a chanting sound. Totengott is a very dark and atmospheric song but it is probably the worst song too, at least in my opinion. A foreboding and very slow sound is present while explosions echo in the back ground. The song soon gets horrible thanks to the ear-splitting shrieks from Tom. If you have seen The Lord Of The Ring movies and are familiar to the creature Gollum, then you know how these shrieks will sound like. Synagoga Satanae is also a very sluggish song with screechy guitars and more strained vocals, but it does though have a bit variety both musically and vocally, which is needed because this song is the longest song at 14 minutes. The last track Winter (Requiem, Chapter Three: Finale) is an instrumental song with violins, and this is a good song to complete an album with such chaos and confusion. This song remains slow but it is very atmospheric and melodic, and it feels very sad, depressive and hopeless, yet you will still think it sounds beautiful.

I have never heard his voice nor have I ever seen his form.
Yet still he casts his dark shadow on the light of my being.

Sometimes you just want to get an album just to hear how the band sounds like, but I got this album and I didn't know what to expect. When I was told that this was a gothic/doom record which had some melodic moments I thought: "Well this could be interesting". I don't know what to say about this album now when I have been listening it through, since my negative thoughts might be just as many as my positive thoughts regarding this album. Since I don't have basically any knowledge about doom or gothic-metal I will still try to end this review with straight answers. Things that I liked about this album were its melodic moments, since they gave you a moment to "rest" before you headed on towards the other sick and distorted songs. The female vocals were a huge surprise, partially because I like female vocalists, and this time they were a perfect contrast to the dark sound that hovers over the other songs. The variety was a good thing indeed; every song didn't have this sluggish tempo, and all the songs had their own character more or less, if you like it or not are just another matter about personal taste. I might come up with more good thoughts but now I will tell you my bad thoughts. For once, the guitars were probably the most annoying guitar work I have heard yet. I know that it is wrong to judge an artist or an album if you just have heard one album single album, but this is the way I feel about this album. The guitars were horrible, and even if you gave a guitar to ten year old kid he or she would probably play similar notes or even better, since there was a lot of string bending and the riffs were nothing else but simple chords played in different tempos, there was no signs of technique or variety. The acoustics were good though even if they sounded very simplistic and same goes for a few solos and other melodic guitar tunes, but the guitars overall sounded pathetically bad in my ears. If it is meant to sound like that in the doom-metal genre then fine but I didn't liked it at all. The vocals was both bad and good, as Tom's calm vocals sounded like they suited the music better than his raspy hybrid black-metal vocals, and the most horrid part was in the track called Totengott.

Feel my holy wrath. I am glorified.
I cannot be denied. I am he who is.

That was pretty much what I felt about this album. I'm going to check out more of Celtic Frost's so I can judge this album better, but now I think this was a weird album, and this is without a doubt the most hardest and most difficult album I have reviewed yet. I have split thoughts about this album, since the songs I like get better and better the more I listen to them while songs I really hate just get worse. But as I said before, since I'm a huge fan of the thrash-metal genre and other intensive metal genres I might not be the right person to review a doom-metal album but I have said my words regarding this album and I will stand by my words I have used to review this album. I would recommend this album people who like the doom-metal genre; it has slow songs which I know is very typical for the doom genre. Fans of this band might enjoy this album, if you happen to like all of Celtic Frost's album, otherwise this might be a huge disappointment to you who love their earliest achievements.

Band Members
Tom G Hunter (Thomas Gabriel Fischer) – vocals and guitars
Martin Eric Ain – bass
Franco Sesa – drums

Pros
+ The female vocals contributed a great contrast to the other darker songs
+ At times very melodic and atmospheric songs
+ Still a fairly unique record though
+ Decent variety in everything basically

Cons
- If I would create a comeback album I would return to my old roots so to say
- I personally hated the guitar work (most of the time)
- This album does not suit everybody, it has very limited fan base in my opinion
- Sometimes you just want to trash the album because of it’s sometimes highly annoying and boring songs

Recommended Tracks (Notice that these are my favourite songs.)
-- Drown In Ashes
-- Obscured
-- A Dying God Coming Into Human Flesh
-- Winter (Requiem, Chapter Three: Finale

This album will be given a vague 3/5



Recent reviews by this author
Opeth DamnationFleshcrawl Made of Flesh
Sear Lamentations of DestructionTormented Rotten Death
War (SWE, Black Metal) We Are...Total WarCrucified Barbara Til Death Do Us Party
user ratings (728)
3.9
excellent
other reviews of this album
beyondthethreshold13 (4)
Return of the King...

B3nnysBack2 (5)
Monotheist is a monument of the dark and despaired. A celebratory ritual of the evil and occult natu...

metalheadpiyush (4.5)
monothiest is certainly one of the darkest and heaviest album ever period.............

RYMsfullofscenesters (2.5)
Monotonist...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Dethtrasher
December 5th 2006


2211 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Sorry but I couldn't come up with a good summary for this album. I'm not bothered by doom-metal but I have heard better doom-metal than this thats for sure.This Message Edited On 12.05.06

Neoteric
December 5th 2006


3243 Comments


I think your reviews would be a lot better if it wasn't in first person all this time e.g. "I'm going to check out more of Celtic Frost's" "I don't know what to say about this album now when I have been listening it through"

But I guess it's up to you, it's your writing style after all.

Cravinov13
December 5th 2006


3854 Comments


Good review. I rather enjoy this CD.

Cravinov13
December 6th 2006


3854 Comments


This isn't doom metal. At all.

Tyler
Emeritus
December 6th 2006


7927 Comments


I remember some Doom on this, but I havent listened to it in a while.

And Acidity, I seriously hope you didnt neg this review just because he has a different opinion. The votes are based on "Is the review well written", not "do you agree?!"This Message Edited On 12.05.06

Wizard
December 7th 2006


20509 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This is definately a good comeback from a legendary band. And yes they do have lots of doom to them on this album. The songs sludge on and are brutal as fuck. But I like their gothic approach too.

Dethtrasher
December 7th 2006


2211 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Well someone negged it because my opinion was different than his/hers. I let people proofread my reviews nowadays so it is still ''well-written'', I actually knew that someone was going to neg this because I thought different about this album.

Tyler
Emeritus
December 7th 2006


7927 Comments


It's definitely heavily doom influenced, after listening to it again.

And ignore the neg, it was petty. You can always report it, and see if the person who was clearly a fan-boy neg'd you for a differing opinion.

Dethtrasher
December 7th 2006


2211 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Yea, definitely a fan-boy case.

Dethtrasher
December 8th 2006


2211 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Comment accepted, I agree with what you just said and I understand what you mean. This isn’t my favourite style of music and it is always a bit more challenging to review music that doesn’t fit your own taste.

MrKite
December 8th 2006


5020 Comments


Love this band. I will end up getting something by them. This is the only band I've heard from this genre that I actually like.

jrowa001
December 24th 2006


8752 Comments


their new video for My Dying God... scared the crap out of me, but it was tight too

Dr. Jake Destructo
January 17th 2007


86 Comments


Isn't it Tom Fischer, not Hunter?

Eakflanderyof
February 2nd 2007


5379 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Celtic Frost doesn't really appeal to me. It's a little too raw. I like some raw music though.



Most of it doesn't even sound black metal to me. It's more thrash sounding.



I did read an article about Fischer in Guitar World magazine though. He had a really crappy childhood. I kinda felt bad for him while reading it.

XulOnerom
February 12th 2007


1818 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I think this was a good album. The downpoint is that some songs sound very much alike. But "Obscured" makes this album worthwhile

Tyler
Emeritus
February 12th 2007


7927 Comments


"Most of it doesn't even sound black metal to me. It's more thrash sounding."

Because it came before Black Metal. Just like the first Bathory albums.

Eakflanderyof
February 14th 2007


5379 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

^^ Yea, I know, but I at least expected a small resemblance to black metal and there wasn't. I enjoy some thrash though too, but not this.



Chaves
March 14th 2007


3 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

It's all about the first song only!



But hey if the first song is so bad like this u can imagine the entire shit ah!



"Progeny" is really really suck! God damned i've just saw the vomit all over my screen after listen this a couple of times... Now seriously i think it's one of the most uninspired song that i ever heard! Nothing interesting here but the the mainly problem (despising the singer and all the rest!) is the poor guitar work which is a very serious fault for me in anything that i heard by any genre.



I know this review will not help you about anything and try avoid expressions like "Come on the bastard write about one song blah,blah,blah.." but in the same time here goes the best advice you can have about you money in this page: "LISTEN THIS BEFORE BUYING!"



Eakflanderyof
March 14th 2007


5379 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

^^ No offense, but is English your first language?

Jondur
March 16th 2007


92 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm a huge fan of Hellhammer and early Frost but I loved this anyway. I think you'd be better off namechecking bands like Godflesh for reference points. Very industrial sounding.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy