Brand New
The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me



by Understanding In a Crash USER (60 Reviews)
November 21st, 2006 | 45 replies

Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Well if your interested in the "Jesse Lacey" show you'll probably find yourself right at home. For long time fans and even fans of ONLY "Deja Entendu", becareful because you may find yourself banging your head against the wall bored. A dust collecter is

Brand New is during the The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me:
Jesse Lacey - guitars/vocals
Brian Lane - drums
Vin Accardi - guitars
Garrett Tierney - bass

Produced By: M. Sapone and Brand New
Recorded By: C. Mittendorfer
Released: November 21, 2006
Label as produced: Interscope Records

Brand New
So I grew up in Long Island one town over from these guys and its easy to say I pay a local homage. I represent Long Island pretty hard, and basically love a lot of the things that happens here. I’m talking about the music scene and also just the place itself. I can still remember it like yesterday how my freshmen year of high school revolved around three bands. Thursday, Taking Back Sunday, and Brand New. These bands were everything to me and most of these bands were just breaking out of there shell. Thursday was out with there second album “Full Collapse”, Taking Back Sunday was busting out with “Tell All Your Friends”, and Brand New had “Your Favorite Weapon”. Despite some may say, my musical tastes have changed drastically from that year, but all 3 of these albums are stored in my heart in a safe place. Now that was almost 4-5 years ago and all of these bands have gone through there changes. Taking Back Sunday of course being the most infamous with it’s lineup changes and mainstream publicity. Thursday steering the reigns still in the music they make but “A City By The Light Divided” goes at a much more mature tone then “Full Collapse” did. Now it’s Brand News turn with it’s first album in 3 years.

Fight Off Your Demons
Now let me first before I start on this album say that I am a long time lover of “Your Favorite Weapon”, it was an instant click for me. “Deja Entendu” wasn’t at first at instant hit but I eventually liked it more than “Your Favorite Weapon” with its more mature sound. This album is probably as highly anticipated as any other new release this year (if not more) and it’s been 3 years since there last release with only a demo called “Fight Off Your Demons” in between. Let me be that this album came at a shocking halt to what my ears wanted to believe. The sound once again will be evident but not subtly note the listener on a dramatic change. You begin to believe that maybe only the first two songs would have been slowed but the entire pace of the album seems lethargic. There is no “Jude Law & Semester Abroad”, “Failure By Design”, or even a sensing hint of “Good To Know That If I Ever Need Attention All I Have To Do Is Die”. A lot of the pop-punk edge that this band had on its debut album faded to Deja Entendu, and now seems totally non existent. I listened to the album enough times to write this review and as many times as I wanted to find something new and inviting, I found myself simply unimpressed and bored.

You Won’t Know
The album starts off very clean and melodic in almost a monotone setting with “Sowing Season”. The song in about a minute in bursts the seems open and grows loud with Jesses voice being backed by a raging electric guitar. You can sense the growth in his voice from what once was pretty nasal in “Your Favorite Weapon”, sounds like a man now instead of a teenager. “Millstone” is an ear opener right after “Sowing Season” going on the same roots of introduction as “Sowing Season” and growing with tempo and harmony. The vocals in this song are what I really envisioned what the new album would be all about, but I was disappointed. The construction of this song is well built with a catchy chorus and a lot of hooks. Even with the monotone setting in the introduction and verses it feels like the song never leaves the listener out to dry, scratching his head. In this song also I found myself being first introduced with the maturity of the music backing behind the valorous front man of the band. The guitar is right there on par in the right step forward from “Deja Entendu” and the bass fills a nice void in the music. “Jesus” was a song that totally killed my ambitiousness towards a song like “Millstone”. It takes everything down to a coarse, choppy, pace. I feel like I’m in Church when I’m listening to this song because yeah the lyrics are there but the music just really has no emphasize or “oomph”. The song shows no real structure and it just lacks in any punch to even be considered a classy acoustic song. The interlude of the song has a nice vocal breakdown which was probably the highest peak of the song which seemed almost screamed. “But we all got wood and nails, your tortured and hanging factory”. By the time “Degausser” comes onto track 4 I’m cupping my face realizing that every song so far has started off at such a monotone and slow pace it’s JUST irritating. To be quite honest, I feel like on the exception of “Millstone” I’m sitting at church and listening to the band play above me. At least this song is showing some life of the band with a faster paced chorus and group vocals. To just hear anything different then very similar barely audible monotone vocal introductions and soft acoustic guitar would have been pleasing to the ear.

Oh god, once again low audible Jesse Lacey over an acoustic on “limousine”. At this point it’s the 5th track and this album seems to be more than anything the “Jesse Lacey album” more than anything. This song definitely isn’t like the others though and actually turned out to be really liked by me. It takes a nice approach with the soft;loud contrast (much better then the other songs). The lyrics at times barely audible do tell a good story and read that Brand New trademark. Yes, we all know Jesse Lacey is a greatng writer but up until a few songs it really felt like he was totally lost. The song “You won’t know” reassures everyone that probably all of these songs are going to start off slow, melancholy, and monotone. As this song speeds up though once again it seems more than listener able then ever and that’s probably mostly because the listener isn’t being put to sleep/making them tear there hair out. It’s a nice change from the “I’m as bored as you guys” voice to actually show some range and emphasize.

I can’t even put myself to words because I was on the verge of tears when I heard “Not The Sun”. The song starts off with bass and then grows into a full band effort instead of the “Jesse Lacey Album”. The guitar uses some pretty sexual effects over clean electric (reverb and delay). I think Cannsaw hit the nail on the head so I’m going to quote him. “I mean most punk bands do their fast paced stuff and a slow song as a bonus, but Brand New seem to be the other way round and it can get quite tedious with all this slow, quiet acoustic stuff around, but when Brand New do belt out a heavy punk song, it can usually be worth the wait.” This song is a fresh breathe of air that almost seems non-existent most of the album where it’s fairly slow on a lot of standards but FAST for this album. I mean I feel like I can at least sway back and fourth to this song instead of sit in the corner in the fetal position rocking back and fourth.

I mean on paper the band has shown it’s growth but I think that this is a prime example of how a band maturing doesn’t always equal good music. This album was tedious to get through, and wasn’t really an easy listen on any means. I’m fairly diverse in my field of music and don’t really show any bias to any genres but this had a lot more Indie/Alt tendencies then Pop-punk. Keep this in mind if you’re going out to get this album because there is no “Jude Law”. The instrumentals seem delicate and well crafted but at the same time painstakingly boring. The vocals do show growth but also seem to be a hermit crab staying and hiding in one place. The lyrics are as tongue in cheek as you'd expect, but the sardonic attitude towards relationships is replaced with a vague yet persistent irritation with organized Christianity, which isn't as charming or as convincing as his (charaded) superiority complex expressed in songs like “Okay I Believe You” from Deja Entendu. If you didn’t even like “Deja Entendu” but loved “Your Favorite Weapon” then definitely be careful by this. The band just seems flat, and lacks “pop”. I’m not talking about “pop” like Ashlee Simpson or Britney Spears, but any song just lacks any inspired effort or emphasize outside its lyrical box. There are albums that put me to sleep that I love and just because they are soothing such as Jack Johnson or John Mayer. This album isn’t as boring as it is soothing. There are some good songs on this album but nothing that stands out on the level other infamous Brand New songs has. The lyrics as they are tongue in cheek don’t seem as clever as they are forced. Overall this album was a huge disappointment for me on a level of a Brand New fan as it seems like Jesse Lacey took the band over totally. Not for the better either… I do know that there are people who will appreciate what this band has to offer this time around but I know more than enough that this obviously isn’t the same band they used to be and in my eyes, it’s a step backwards.

+ Growth
+ Experimenting

- Lack of any type of “Oomph”
- Really drags on a lagging pace
- Some of the songs should have been demos and stayed that way.
- For almost every song to start off so slow… why
- There are other bands that execute music in this spectrum that aren't half as boring.

I'm listening to Deja Entendu right now.

Recent reviews by this author
Saves the Day In ReverieThe Menzingers On the Impossible Past
Converge All We Love We Leave BehindMemphis May Fire Challenger
Stick To Your Guns Comes From the HeartTimes of Grace The Hymn of a Broken Man
user ratings (6286)
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
November 21st 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

Wow man this is a very nice review. This is probably some of your best work. I have never been big on the Brand New so I'll have to see how a bandmate of mine likes this since he is.

Zesty Mordant
November 21st 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

Great review, but from what I can understand from, the breadth of your criticism involves you not understanding the heavy post-rock feel of this album (i.e. the emphasis of dynamics over "oomph", the flow of the album, and its general pace)

At worst, you seem to suggest that they should have never progressed from their debut.

November 21st 2006


As far as I can tell this is a long review. And I'm soooooo lazy. But the bolded things are well-written, so thumbs up!
I really want to hear something from this!!!

The Sludge
November 21st 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

You actually hit what I thought on the album, yet this has been growing on me alot since last week.

Understanding In a Crash
November 21st 2006


Album Rating: 2.5

I'm actually scared of that happening and being stuck in this position but I've been listening to this for a week now. I'm really trying to like this by giving it endless chances to somehow click. I never tried so hard on an album I think.

November 22nd 2006


There's a difference between not understanding and not appreciating the post-rock feel.

Dan is obviously the later, and illustrates this throughout his review. The fact that he didn't use the word "post-rock" specifically is erroneous.

And if you read his review, you would have seen that he actually liked Deja Entendu more than YFW, so by no means is he suggesting that growth is not a good thing.

There are a fair amount of grammar mistakes and such that shouldn't be in a review, but overall it gave me a pretty clear idea of what this album was all about. Good stuff, Dan.This Message Edited On 11.22.06

La Revolucion
November 22nd 2006


Or maybe he just doesn't like the post rock feel.

January 10th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

Nice review. Sadly I disagree.

March 11th 2007


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

I feel that this is their best work. But I shall definitely check out their first album.

July 19th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

The review is fairly well written, although if you want to listen to their debut you can still listen to it, I'd much prefer the band changes their style than keep churning ou the same album for their whole career.

December 4th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

This review was written well. The one problem is that you are reviewing the pop/punk elements of an album that is neither. I believe if you asked Brand New if they were a pop/punk band that you would probably get a pretty resounding "no". This is a completely different band than the one who made YFW. I don't really like pop/punk music, and when I listen to Your Favorite Weapon I don't hear a "Jesus Christ", just as you don't hear a "Jude Law" on The Devil and God.

July 10th 2008


Album Rating: 5.0

This is very nicely written, and I have to laugh at some of the things you say because I can see exactly how they are true (I have listened to this entire album countless times). However, I disagree. The songs do start off slow, but if you listen to the entire album from start to finish, there seems to be a natural flow/progression that makes fast starts and sudden pace changes unnecessary.

I believe that your opinion of this album is influenced mostly by your expectations for it; you want something fast and punchy. I approached this album after hearing "Jesus" looking for an experimental, mellow yet over-the-top type of album. And that is what we have here. For me, it is one of the best albums I can think of in my recent lifetime.This Message Edited On 07.10.08

Digging: clairo - Sling

August 6th 2008


nice! a typo in the summary! 'be careful' is not one word. That turned me off to the rest of the review. well done!

February 3rd 2009


Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

you're stupid

I am BM
February 3rd 2009


Album Rating: 4.5

This CD is amazing this guy is hella wrong.

February 3rd 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

I think this review is fair enough tbh, I used to feel the exact same way.

April 21st 2009


I can't believe 8 of 12 thought this was well written. Grammatical and spelling errors throughout the review threw away any credibility I thought you might have. I mean even your emphasized points weren't correct..."wasn’t really an easy listen on any means." Really? It's BY any means. Plus for God Sakes learn how/when to use "there, their, they're" and "your, you're". Idiot.

April 21st 2009



April 21st 2009


I mean for real. For God Snakes!

April 21st 2009


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

l-o-l. i haven't encountered such an e-rebel since i quit online gaming. what a guy!

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy