DoubtGin
11.22.10 | list is digs |
Spec
11.22.10 | Overrated. |
Terrifyer
11.22.10 | ugh
when pitchfork does something u like its all merriness and mirth, and then when they dont 'omg gay site hate those cunts' |
DoubtGin
11.22.10 | yea, because Ive done that before |
AggravatedYeti
11.22.10 | ^^ pretty much.
don't you know? |
Terrifyer
11.22.10 | im sure you have |
conradtao
11.22.10 | it's already dropped to 4.1 from 4.3 |
JWT155
11.22.10 | Everything drops with more votes. |
robertsona
11.22.10 | i was really surprised by this
i knew it was gonna be a really high score but lol |
greg84
11.22.10 | 4 and 7 are awesome. 9 is also good. I don't care much about the new Kanye album though. |
Leatherneck
11.22.10 | what the fuck is it that people likes that album? i can't get into it, it bores me to death |
theacademy
11.22.10 | its really good
like recovery/teflon don good. |
Inveigh
11.22.10 | lol except Recovery was really bad, and new Kanye is pretty awesome
8 and 9 rule btw |
theacademy
11.22.10 | 1. MMLP
2. SSLP
3. College Dropout
--------------------------5's--------------------------
T-4. Recovery
T-4. The Eminem Show
6. (This)
---------------------4's-------------------------
7. 808s and Heartbreak
----------------------3------------------------------
T-8. Late Registration
T-8. Relapse
------------------------------2-----------------------
------------------------------1-----------------------
10. Graduation
11. Encore |
Inveigh
11.22.10 | I'd put it more like
College Dropout
SSLP
This
MMLP
Late Registration
The Eminem Show
Graduation
Encore
808s
Recovery
Relapse |
theacademy
11.22.10 | "This
MMLP"
wut |
8bit
11.22.10 | Is it really that good? |
couldwinarabbit
11.22.10 | first new album since Kid A to get a 10/10. Well there was a couple but they lost the rank when they were like in the 100's on the decade list. |
conradtao
11.22.10 | yankee hotel foxtrot was definitely in the top 20 |
TheStefan
11.22.10 | i havent even rated the new kanye yet because i cant make up my mind. i mean, its good, but its nothing special. like i kinda expected everything thats on there to be there and he isnt really doing much new. ill probably just end up giving it a 2.5 because its nothing special imo. i cant see why Pitchfork gave it a 10, its nowhere near perfect |
couldwinarabbit
11.22.10 | It didn't get a 10 though did it? |
robertsona
11.22.10 | what |
Inveigh
11.22.10 | acad: yeah, I've just never been a big Eminem fan, even back when he first came out (I was like 13, but whatever, I definitely liked him more then than now). He always came off as pretty gimmicky to me. |
vmcoia91
11.22.10 | @couldwinarabbit, yes Yankee Hotel Foxtrot did get top 10. I think it was like number 4 or something. |
SeaAnemone
11.22.10 | http://saladdaysmusic.net/?p=2048 |
couldwinarabbit
11.22.10 | oh nvm wilco is the last album to keep a 10 sorry guys |
DoubtGin
11.22.10 | ye, and before that, it was Source Tags & Codes afaik |
PuddlesPuddles
11.22.10 | Come the fuck on
Album is weaker than it is strong |
klap
11.22.10 | what do you mean by 'keeping a ten.' they don't change ratings except on re-releases, the decade list doesn't have a bearing on an individual album rating. source tags and codes was/still is a 10 |
DoubtGin
11.22.10 | I think he just meant "getting a ten" |
