Nagrarok
09.09.10 | 'OMG you left so much from Dirt off' |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Hence it's position at the top of the list. |
kangaroopoo
09.09.10 | Nice, but with some tinkering of the order.
I'd also have to sub in 'I Can't Remember' |
BeardedIdiot
09.09.10 | 'OMG you left so much from Dirt off'
should've done "honorable mentions" in the comments, but eh, who am I to complain. List is pretty spot on |
BigHans
09.09.10 | Cant argue with alot of these. Nutshell is definitely number 1.
|
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | It's one of those classic cases where one of the band's songs is cleary and undeniably the best. |
Romulus
09.09.10 | your first two songs are spot on, awesome list.
HOWEVER you are missing something. from the s/t. can you guess what it is? |
LepreCon
09.09.10 | Can't argue with this really...
though for the sake of it I'd probably exchange one or two of them with tracks from BGWTB depending on my mood, though nostalgia would obviously make it very difficult to do so given that I practically grew up with AiC |
LepreCon
09.09.10 | Also, 'Would?' would be my #1 and 'Nutshell' my #2 |
BeardedIdiot
09.09.10 | I think it just goes to show that it's impossible to make the "15 definitive AiC songs" list. It should be like "30 definitive AiC songs" list |
BigHans
09.09.10 | if "I Stay Away" didnt have that fucking awful pre-chorus, and its fucking cringe inducing, it would have been one of their top 5 songs. |
Romulus
09.09.10 | but I Stay Away is one of their top five songs cause the pre-chorus is a little funky but it's definitely not terrible |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | Except, 'I Stay Away' rules all the way through |
BigHans
09.09.10 | no, that pre-chorus is fucking dreadful. It seriously pisses me off, because it ruins what would have been a watershed song. WHY YOU ACT FRIGHTENED I AM ENLIGHTENED. Layne could sing that part better dead than he did on the record. |
Romulus
09.09.10 | you must not like God Smack too much |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | But after that, the chorus is one of the best AiC moments ever |
BigHans
09.09.10 | Rom, yes, Godsmack is by far the worst song off Dirt
Brandon, you're right. |
vanderb0b
09.09.10 | SITTING ON AN ANGRY CHAIR
Awesome list. Just re-listened to the s/t today (thanks to Maniac!), and it's really good. |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Ryan, I really can't quite recall. Something with blame? aim? claim? flame? lame? frame? game? name? tame?
Conor, this is a classic era-only list, after all. |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | God Am and Sludge Factory are my favorites off that one, b0b. |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Oh, and I totally agree with you there Hans, it feels annoyingly out of place in the song. |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | I guess it's just my fanboyism, I really like that song all the way through. |
BigHans
09.09.10 | Nag, one song you are definitely missing is DONT FOLLOW |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | ^ I agree |
theacademy
09.09.10 | yeah these 15 songs are 'definitely' by alice in chains but i don't really get the point of the list |
Romulus
09.09.10 | I always thought Don't Follow was the second-worst of JoF even though it's still great |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | I always thought Don't Follow was the second-worst of JoF even though it's still great
but... RomRom :( |
Romulus
09.09.10 | Well nothing and seriously I mean nothing matches the opening three tracks of JoF.
and I have an unnatural love for Whale & Wasp |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Don't Follow is fantastic and would 'definitely' go to the honourable mentions. |
BigHans
09.09.10 | I just 5'd Jar of Flies because it would be stupid not to. |
Maniac!
09.09.10 | I just 5'd Jar of Flies because it would be stupid not to.
Good man |
LepreCon
09.09.10 | I feel stupid for not 5'ing Jar of Flies |
BigHans
09.09.10 | Do it Connor |
LepreCon
09.09.10 | Hrm, 'twould be the first EP to ever get a 5 from me |
BeardedIdiot
09.09.10 | Yeah, do the honourable mentions already. Been waiting all day for it :D |
EVedder27
09.09.10 | great list although I'd have Damn that River in mine |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | HONOURABLE MENTIONS (especially for BeardedIdiot):
Dam That River
Rain When I Die
Don't Follow
Sludge Factory
Heaven Beside You
Killer is Me
|
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Yeah I know, it was a pretty useless comment of mine. |
BeardedIdiot
09.09.10 | YESSSSS!!!!! |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | I'll include them at the beginning next time if I feel like it. |
theacademy
09.09.10 | nice title change!
iapprove |
Nagrarok
09.09.10 | Especially for you academy. |
Jethro42
09.10.10 | man, list is win |
Gmork89
09.10.10 | Good list, everything by them is essential however. |
wyankeif1337
09.10.10 | them bones. |
ShadowRemains
09.10.10 | 12 would be higher on mine |
