User
Reviews 49 Approval 87%
Soundoffs 48 News Articles 57 Band Edits + Tags 229 Album Edits 87
Album Ratings 602 Objectivity 90%
Last Active 02-24-11 3:55 am Joined 02-21-06
Review Comments 6,760
| Albums That Get Too Much Crap
Self explanatory. No douchebag replies if you can help it, but I'm not holding my breath. | 1 | | Angels and Airwaves We Don't Need to Whisper
Yeah, it's a pretty boring meshing of U2 and pop punk. But it has one good song in The Adventure, and it's better than at least one Blink album (Take Off Your Pants and Jacket) | 2 | | Atreyu Lead Sails Paper Anchor
Their best album, without question. If you give this a 1, everything else they've done better have the same rating. Much less horrid screaming, and more than one decent song (which is what you'd find on each album prior). | 3 | | Metallica St. Anger
Iai said it perfectly. "Hey, it's not as bad as everyone makes out, at least. It does contain 3 decent tracks in "Frantic", "St. Anger", and "The Un-Named Feeling". Okay, so they were all released as singles, which means you've heard them and don't need to buy this record. Yes, it's Metallica's worst record. But this isn't the worst thing ever released, or even the worst album of 2003. Lay off the hate! | 4 | | Jay-Z Kingdom Come
Lazy, boring, uninspired, and mediocre. I'd mostly agree with each of these, but the first three songs are good. | 5 | | Bullet For My Valentine The Poison
No, the band does absolutely nothing new in the almost completely stale metalcore genre, but the execution is done well enough that it's not a real chore or pain to listen to. The instrumental performances are pretty solid, and with all the screaming you might not notice the lyrics might as well be written by Hawthorne Heights. It's better than several other bands at the bottom of the spectrum. | 6 | | My Chemical Romance The Black Parade
Just look at the rating distribution. | 7 | | Rise Against Appeal to Reason
Best for last. Lyrics for "Hero of War" suck? Polka part in "Entertainment" doesn't work? I disagree, but even if they did, that doesn't stop the rest of the album from being good or great. "Re-Education Through Labor", "The Dirt Whispered", "Kotov Syndrome", "Savior", "Whereabouts Unknown"....album rocks. But why listen to me, I'm just a fanboy. | |
kitsch
04.21.09 | these dont get enough crap imo
until all the copies are amassed and burned they will not have gotten enough crap | Waior
04.21.09 | lol mcr
I will refrain from douche-fagging this list. | illmitch
04.21.09 | new darkthrone gets way way way too much crap | roofi
04.21.09 | so you're saying the first 5 still suck? why bother defending them then?
not trying to be a prick just sayin | kitsch
04.21.09 | hes not defending anyone, shithead | roofi
04.21.09 | thanks for clearing that up | willfellmarsy
04.21.09 | frantic is a terrible song...rise against have always sucked and do not get enough shit for suckage... | myhigherpie
04.21.09 | nah aside from 7 these are all pretty terrible. | BallsToTheWall
04.21.09 | Hit The Floor and Tears Dont Fall rule undenaibly, 6 isnt too shabby tbh. | DaveyBoy
04.21.09 | "so you're saying the first 5 still suck? why bother defending them then?"
Read the list title. I know most others don't make any sense or are irrelevant, but gee... He said they get "TOO MUCH Crap". In other words, they deserve some crap, but not as much as they get. Pretty bloody obvious, isn't it?
Good list Steve & I obviously agree with the final two since I have rated them both a 4.5. | absurdismwine
04.21.09 | 1 2 5 and 6, definitely
kingdom come was sooo boring though | Shadowskos
04.21.09 | don't really see the dislike for 7, so I'm going to agree with you there. | roofi
04.21.09 | no shit davey, i get the list, i just don't see the point in saying "oh this should be a 2 or 2.5 instead of a 1." who cares, it's still not good | TheGreatD17
04.22.09 | The Black Parade is a good album, but the rest are pretty bad. | ninjuice
04.22.09 | stfu willfellmarsy.
I'm glad at least one person agrees with me, of course I knew Davey would agree with the last two.
Roofi, there's still a significant difference between "this is really awful" and "this is isn't bad, it's just boring" which is how I feel about all but the last two. | upagainstthewall
04.22.09 | 6 and 7 are awesome. Especially 7, not their strongest but still fucking epic. | kintups
04.22.09 | *throws crap at 1 and 7* | ninjuice
04.22.09 | *beats kintups face in* | upagainstthewall
04.22.09 | *upagainstthewall punches kintup in face also* | ninjuice
04.22.09 | *gives upagainstthewall a high five*
Kintups gave AtR a 3. Why the "throwing crap"? | YouAreMySilence
04.22.09 | agree with 1 but not 7 | Hyperbore
04.22.09 | The only way 'St. Anger' can possibly be "not as bad as everyone makes out," is if it's even worse than people make out. It's a terrible, soulless, retarded piece of shit album that should be an embarrassment to everyone who made it. Don't defend crap. | kintups
04.22.09 | @ ninjuice: I was confirming the list's truthfulness. I don't see why you'd want to beat my face in. On the other hand, I now have a good reason to beat *your* face in... and upagainstthewall's.
*Beats ninjuice's and upagainstthewall's faces in*
| upagainstthewall
04.22.09 | oh no my face.
| ninjuice
04.22.09 | Ah, well, hopefully you can see why I misinterpreted your post.
Or not, since your face and eyes have been beaten. | DaveyBoy
04.22.09 | " i just don't see the point in saying "oh this should be a 2 or 2.5 instead of a 1." who cares, it's still not good".
Roofie, I would agree with you if Steve has rated them all a 2 or a 2.5. It's still a fail, as such. But I doubt he has. In fact, I just took the time to look up the last 2 albums and he has rated both a 3.5. In that case, I think the list is warranted. | ninjuice
04.22.09 | Yeah except for St. Anger these are all a 2.5 or better. | MusicinaBox
04.29.09 | i strongly agree w/ 2 and 5-7. lol at the fight up there ^^^^^^^^^^lol. | AtavanHalen
04.29.09 | 5 deserves all it gets | fireaboveicebelow
04.29.09 | I agree with 3...that's it | Douchebag
04.29.09 | list needs american idiot.
entertainment is one of my favourite rise against songs. | lglag
05.17.09 | I agree on The Poison, but I don't think St. Anger could ever get too much crap |
|