ArsMoriendi
12.03.23 | First of all: we share the same #1
2nd of all: I love how unique this list is. Feels like a lot of thought went into it.
Usually Radiohead lists feel like dull rehashings of common opinion, but this is a good one
Needs Packt Like Sardines though |
ArsMoriendi
12.03.23 | Also, your join date is 11/8/23? WHOA right before signups died
Are you the newest member ever? |
mouldypigeon
12.03.23 | Packt Like Sardines could go in here tbf, I felt a sense of denial while making this list, made me realise that Amnesiac is probably still my favourite Radiohead album. In Rainbows kinda stole the show for such a long time and I have trouble letting it go.
I still know very little about how this site works, signups definitely weren't dead a month ago? Although I do remember suspiciously the confirmation email link kept saying it didn't work, but it logged me in anyway. That felt pretty lucky at the time, so maybe I got in by skin of my teeth yeah. |
ArsMoriendi
12.03.23 | Yeah, this site has a ton of issues haha... and wait: you had that email-confirmation issue, but still were able to sign in anyway? I wonder if the mods know that the confirmation doesn't necessarily block new members just misinforms them that it does |
mouldypigeon
12.03.23 | Yes, all I really remember is signing up, it told me to verify my email so I followed the link in my email but it had an error message. So I just went back to the main site page from the window I signed up with and I was already logged in. |
ArsMoriendi
12.03.23 | Just asked Sowing (a mod) and he had no idea this was the case, keep talking
Unless that's it. Welcome aboard anyway, Did you check new PJ Harvey? haha |
myri14
12.03.23 | Great list. AMSP is my favorite Radiohead album and Decks Dark is a great pick for best song from it! |
widowslaugh123
12.03.23 | Sick list 1 is in my top 5. Yeah the little x has fucked me over a bunch but it’s probably for the best |
mouldypigeon
12.03.23 | Thanks! Well, I could never get into PJ Harvey, tried a couple times but not for some years now. Where should I start? Would hope my ear is more mature now.
The only other thing I can tell you is that after getting the error message from the verification email, I also tried to just log in from the main site and it gave an error too like my account didn't exist. It was at that point I gave up and figure I'd just browse the site as a guest, then I saw I was logged in!! |
mouldypigeon
12.03.23 | myri14 - thank you, I feel like A Moon Shaped Pool still has a lot to give from repeated listens
widowslaugh123 - I am genuinely relieved I'm not the only one to click the 'x' |
ArsMoriendi
12.03.23 | @pigeon: Is This Desire? and To Bring You My Love are both pretty good spots, her new one could be too if you like spacious indie with folk influence |
Titan
12.03.23 | Great top 40……based on the songs that are here, I’m surprised Last Flowers didn’t make the cut….props for Go Slowly |
Veldin
12.03.23 | You and Whose Army is so damn good |
cylinder
12.03.23 | Come OOOOOOoo-oooooon
Holy roooooooman empiiiiiiire! |
zakalwe
12.03.23 | You’re definitely wrong |
DoofDoof
12.03.23 | Two most recently overrated at 1 and 2 yeah
‘You and Whose Army’ has grown on me a lot recently though |
JohnnyoftheWell
12.03.23 | Solid list, but too much from AMSP and 2 is one of their most overrated, but I love how little time your picks have for the bullshit parts of their discog |
bighubbabuddha
12.03.23 | your top 15 is great |
Trifolium
12.03.23 | Yeah I'm happy with many of these as well, especially love 3 being so high and many TKOL tracks being here 🥳 |
Titan
12.03.23 | Codex is probably top 5 for me |
HooperD87
12.04.23 | No Jigsaw makes me sad. Cool top 5 though |
