Havey
10.25.23 | interesting |
Scoot
10.25.23 | coloring book is their masterpiece imo
the first two lps did not age well, particularly the debut
whereas cb has only improved with time |
YoYoMancuso
10.25.23 | i feel like you gotta include the EPs on this |
Scoot
10.25.23 | if coloring book and our color green were meshed into an lp it would be their masterpiece |
JayEnder
10.25.23 | "the first two lps did not age well"
Worship and Tribute aged magnificently imo but yea I can't really listen to Silence anymore |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.25.23 | [2] Worship and Tribute is such an of-and-beyond its time record in the same way as RoC, and while the debut highlights fuck like stray cats, there ain't no way I'm end-to-ending that shit again without a very good reason |
beamlith
10.25.23 | I just changed it a good bit, adding the EP's and listening through everything
|
Deez
10.26.23 | 2/1/3/4/5 for me |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.26.23 | list is v different now. looks like you really soured on Silence |
Slex
10.26.23 | 2/4/3/1/5 |
cylinder
10.26.23 | i included EPs so now my #1 is #5 |
Spec
10.26.23 | I think calling Coloring Book their masterpiece is appropriate. |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.26.23 | Coloring Book is cool but doesn't have the same level highlights as any of their other list-worthy releases. Material Control probs has equal claim |
cylinder
10.26.23 | Coloring Book is the best thing they've done
Material Control is aight but clearly ain't no Coloring Book |
MoM
10.26.23 | 1-4 are 1 and 5 is 3 |
JeetJeet
10.26.23 | Switch 1 with 4 and yea, nailed it |
Larkinhill
10.26.23 | Scoot — agree about the debut but Worship and Control is a timeless classic. |
beamlith
10.26.23 | I did, going back to it. Lyrical themes aside, I think Everything is such a roller coaster in terms of songwriting. Where I feel that W & T is more consistent. But all of their output since W&T is the "Glassjaw" sound and their first two albums feel like trial runs toward that sound. |
AlexKzillion
10.26.23 | perfect discog that can be ranked in any order so long as silence is last, and even that's a 4.5 |
FREETHEGUYS
10.28.23 | I feel like if you posted this list 5 years ago people would think it’s bait which is crazy |
tcat84
10.28.23 | 4/3/2..... 1/5 Last time I listened to Material Control I didn't finish it and it's not long. Its not even bad its just not good and 2,3,4 are god tier |
