Pikazilla
01.30.22 | m/ m/ m/ m/ m/ |
MonumentsOfParalysis
01.30.22 | No such thing as a bad Meshuggah ranking m/ |
Pikazilla
01.30.22 | No such thing as a bad Meshuggah album m/ |
MonumentsOfParalysis
01.30.22 | For comparison (starting with top):
5
8
7
2
4
3
6
1
9
(I love Nothing, just love the others more) |
Senetrix666
01.30.22 | surprised to see the gap between 9 and 2. i dont find them all that different |
Pikazilla
01.30.22 | Production-wise they are similar, but otherwise not sure what you're getting at here. |
DType
01.30.22 | "No such thing as a bad Meshuggah ranking m/"[33]
They all rule hard, the rest is a matter of preference
|
Tundra
01.30.22 | 3 is shit, facepalm |
MonumentsOfParalysis
01.30.22 | 4/5 rating is "shit"? Facepalm |
AlexKzillion
01.30.22 | 1 is 1 yepp |
DType
01.30.22 | "4/5 rating is "shit"? Facepalm"
Yeah i don't know about that either lol
|
DDDeftoneDDD
01.30.22 | 5 and 3 are top shuggah. No doubts |
MO
01.30.22 | 1 is 1 yea |
evilford
01.30.22 | Nice ranking here, 1 is 1 yea [2] |
DDDeftoneDDD
01.30.22 | Oh yeah, nothing prolly my second to third shuggah. What donI win the re realease
|
Ryus
01.30.22 | i dont rly like 1, 3, or 5. 2, 6 and 8 are my favs |
evilford
01.30.22 | Also yea tvsor was a huge grower, probably was my least favorite when it came out and now it's almost a 5 for me |
JeetJeet
01.30.22 | 3 goes crazy. 8 is the best tho. 4 deserves way more love too its top tier. |
evilford
01.30.22 | Best band ever. Besides gorguts agreed |
evilford
01.30.22 | 4 is a 5 yea |
trilo
01.30.22 | 1 is 1 yuh |
YoYoMancuso
01.30.22 | great list except 5 is my fav |
DDDeftoneDDD
01.30.22 | 5 is the best
3 is my shit |
evilford
01.30.22 | 1 is 1 but calling 5 the best is not incorrect |
Emim
01.30.22 | 1 & 2 are correct for me. I do love 9 quite a bit too though |
DType
01.30.22 | Yeah, 5 is peak Shugg along with 8 |
evilford
01.30.22 | I've never been crazy about c33 as a whole but there are definitely parts I love
My Neverending quest is just to jam it hard til it becomes a 5 |
DDDeftoneDDD
01.30.22 | That s exactly the point w c33 |
DType
01.30.22 | I didn't get C33 at first it all lol, thought it was extremely repetitive and weird, but man, it's a grower among growers |
evilford
01.30.22 | I mean I enjoy it quite a bit as it is. I just dont think it's among their best, this ranking is about where I would put it |
evilford
01.30.22 | Tbqh im worried that if I actually start digging c33 on an unreasonable level like I already do with like 4 or 5 of their albums that ill start liking the shug even more than gorguts and I'd feel bad doing guts like that |
evilford
01.30.22 | Im aware that this is stupid lol |
Purpl3Spartan
01.30.22 | Literally do not understand this band. So boring to me |
evilford
01.30.22 | Rip |
CottonSalad
01.30.22 | Love how high 3 is |
el_newg
01.30.22 | never get tired of listening to this band |
evilford
01.30.22 | Same |
Eakflanderyof
01.30.22 | "Literally do not understand this band. So boring to me"
To be fair, you have to have a really high IQ to understand meshuggah |
Eakflanderyof
01.30.22 | 3 is very violently slept on by meshuggah fans... and it's very unreasonable |
evilford
01.30.22 | Gottem |
botb
01.30.22 | 9 is one of my favorites, bring back meshuggah with two steps and gang vocals |
FR33L0RD
01.30.22 | Nice list. 1 is 1. Many amazing LP, indeed. |
Pikazilla
01.30.22 | Yeah, they got no duds.
Never get tired of listening to this band [2] |
Purpl3Spartan
01.30.22 | I knew someone was gonna say that |
Sinternet
01.30.22 | 3 sucks ass but no real qualms aside from that |
DType
01.30.22 | "To be fair, you have to have a really high IQ to understand meshuggah"
Aight that's cheesy lol but i bet that's the point
|
bigweinerdon
01.30.22 | 4 is prob best |
Slex
01.30.22 | Djent was a mistake |
Senetrix666
01.30.22 | Botb coming in with the godly take. A truly enlightened individual |
Purpl3Spartan
01.30.22 | Djent is good but not by itself. It's like butter. Use it tastefully |
botb
01.30.22 | It ain’t easy being cheesy |
Slex
01.30.22 | I can respect that Spartan |
Pikazilla
01.30.22 | Djent was a mistake [2] |
Pikazilla
01.31.22 | Agreed |
Slex
01.31.22 | Yeah that's a solid take Pika |
Flugmorph
01.31.22 | C33 > I |
Koris
01.31.22 | C33 > I [2] |
Pikazilla
01.31.22 | hail the almighty shug |
Eakflanderyof
01.31.22 | I'd rather listen to just about any meshuggah album over C33. It's easily the least interesting of their albums |
DType
01.31.22 | It's the most demanding but easily one of their absolute best |
Pikazilla
04.01.22 | Ranking updated to include the new one, apologies to all the number comments :3 |
FR33L0RD
04.01.22 | New one in the middle of your list, that is fair enough. |
Space Jester
04.01.22 | I swear you people sleep the fuck on Contradictions Collapse |
Pikazilla
04.01.22 | It's a great album but it doesn't compare to their classics. CC and C33 are easily my least played shug albums. |
Flugmorph
04.01.22 | one would think its a bit early to rank the new album on day 1 |
DType
04.01.22 | I also feel it's too early to rank it, so far is my new least favorite but i'll give it proper time to grow |
Pikazilla
04.02.22 | Leak's been out for over a week. |
evilford
04.02.22 | New 1 kills
Great ranking, I like new 1 more than koloss and probably tvsor |
GhandhiLion
04.02.22 | 7 is top 3. Also original nothing > re-release production |
GhandhiLion
04.02.22 | and chaosphere best shuggah |
DType
04.02.22 | Also original nothing > re-release production [33] |
Trifolium
04.02.22 | 10 and 8 too low and 3 too high but this band is all good everything rules and so do you. |
Trifolium
04.02.22 | Also where is None????! |
Pikazilla
04.02.22 | I've never listened to it :p |
Pikazilla
04.02.22 | Trif, you should post your shug ranking as well, buddy |
Trifolium
04.02.22 | Omg listen to it especially since you enjoy DEI and Chaosphere so much!
And I'll do it when I know where to slot in Immutable. It'll take some more thinking. |
Trifolium
04.02.22 | We certainly have the same 1 and 2 though 💛💚 |
FR33L0RD
04.02.22 | Very often DEI is place in Top3, i feel like, maybe, i have untap potential in this one. I definitively need to dig it more, DEI along side the new one in the playlist now, nice. Cheers. After a couple of spin, Immutable occupy middle of the pack position. Great+ album that probably need many more spin to stabilize. |
Pikazilla
04.02.22 | It's a grower for sure! Definitely a solid one from the boys. |
FR33L0RD
04.02.22 | Nice. |
Trifolium
04.02.22 | Very much looking forward to spending more time with the new one. Buying it in my cute record shop tomorrow. |
Pikazilla
04.03.22 | Nice! How does the artwork look on a physical copy? |
Trifolium
04.03.22 | They didn't have it 😵❄️📉📉📉📉📉📉📉
Will report back when I know more. |
Pikazilla
04.03.22 | What. You should've filed a complaint! |
Pikazilla
04.05.22 | Moved Immutable up two spots. Gets better with every listen. |
normaloctagon
04.05.22 | are you muteable
zing |
Pikazilla
04.05.22 | what is this aggression towards my persona |
normaloctagon
04.05.22 | aggression what aggression i have no idea what youre talking about you are my one and only pika i would never |
YoYoMancuso
04.05.22 | Attempting to learn Stengah on drums wish me luck brothers |
FR33L0RD
04.05.22 | ~~Moved Immutable up two spots. Gets better with every listen.~~ by Pika.
Agreed on that, it is aa grower for me too. |
Trifolium
04.05.22 | Stengah 💖💞 |
Pikazilla
04.05.22 | A colossus of a track |
Trifolium
04.05.22 | Absolutely. Either one of their best, or their number one track. Perfect opener too for Nothing. |
YoYoMancuso
04.05.22 | well at least the verse is easy lmao. Finally got the intro down though |
XyphDryne
04.05.22 | 1 to 9 are too high. |
MonumentsOfParalysis
04.05.22 | Nice list Pikachuggah |
Koris
08.02.22 | 1 is 1 forever and always \m/ |
Pikazilla
08.02.22 | Always remember to get the blue version |
Koris
08.02.22 | Yep, the superior version for sure. Nebulous slowed down is fucking filthy |
DaveTrane
08.02.22 | 9 is 1 irl |
DType
08.02.22 | Get the blue version if you hate good drums |
Pikazilla
08.02.22 | reported |
Slex
08.02.22 | 1-9 is 9 |
Pikazilla
08.02.22 | out of 10 |
Slex
08.02.22 | Probably my least favorite band next to Guns N Roses |
Pikazilla
08.02.22 | check etienne sin |
evilford
08.03.22 | Best band ever besides gorguts agreed |
zaruyache
08.03.22 | unhinged, incorrect, WRONG rankings |
Slex
08.03.22 | I will, ugh, try listening to this band again just because your taste is that legit Ford |
evilford
08.03.22 | Id have 5 and 6 higher but still solid af |
evilford
08.03.22 | Nice slexy, have u actually heard the nothing rerelease? |
Pikazilla
04.24.23 | no he taking his sweet time clearly |
Vinnymcscoop
04.24.23 | I'm glad to see Catch Thirtythree on 9
*sigh* so many 1 minute song |
artiswar
04.24.23 | this heresy against c33 is unacceptable. Shed, Life, Death, Dehumanization, so many bangers. You guys just don't get it |
Pikazilla
04.24.23 | it just doesn't stack against their other releases, that's all |
artiswar
04.24.23 | you have wrong opinions and you bait hard. That's 0/2
if you were in the right mindset I bet you would appreciate Catch more. It's seriously such a great album |
Pikazilla
04.24.23 | I prefer their other one-song release, which goes way harder than c33
I'm not baiting lol |
artiswar
04.24.23 | it blows my mind that you like I but not Catch. Is it just the length that bothers you? jam it again |
Pikazilla
04.24.23 | no, it's the lack of memorable in-your-face moments
they should've made c33 an ep |
evilford
04.25.23 | Honestly put 4 at last place and this is probably my ranking |
Pikazilla
04.25.23 | based |
Trifolium
04.25.23 | Where is the 4.0 cut-off point here, Pika? |
Pikazilla
04.25.23 | Koloss is a 4
The bottom two are a 3 |
Trifolium
04.25.23 | So many 4.0s and above agreeeeeed 😍 |
Tundra
04.25.23 | Violent Sleep that high?? Bahaha |
IsisScript80
04.25.23 | "it blows my mind that you like I but not Catch. Is it just the length that bothers you? jam it again"
I'm not really a fan of the band, but I'd agree that 'I' does everything 'Catch 33' did with a shorter and more direct run-time. I definitely preferred it before becoming irrevocably bored of them as a whole. |