User
Reviews 166 Approval 97%
Soundoffs 15 News Articles 16 Band Edits + Tags 3,434 Album Edits 8,415
Album Ratings 3527 Objectivity 88%
Last Active 12-03-22 11:37 pm Joined 08-18-16
Review Comments 16,120
|
SandwichBubble
06.17.17 | 1
4 (sorry Carole) | butcherboy
06.17.17 | 2
4 | Davil667
06.17.17 | P.E. | Ryus
06.17.17 | nas | Drifter
06.17.17 | Nas | TheSpaceMan
06.17.17 | this tourney has taught me that 2pac is a NY based band
but i'll vote Nas | Papa Universe
06.18.17 | Public Enemy
The Magnetic Fields | AlexKzillion
06.18.17 | [From the last round] "To MrAlexK - why not?"
Because saying 2pac is a new york artist is like one of the most incorrect hip hop related thing you could ever say ever, in spite of him technically being born there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Coast%E2%80%93West_Coast_hip_hop_rivalry | AlexKzillion
06.18.17 | Public Enemy | Divaman
06.18.17 | 2Pac was born in East Harlem. That's the fact, in spite of the whole East-Coast/West-Coast thing. I'm not saying he's JUST a NY artist, but that NY being his birth place qualifies him as a NY artist no matter what else he may also be. | Divaman
06.18.17 | My vote is:
Nas
Magnetic Fields | Divaman
06.18.17 | Updated | AlexKzillion
06.18.17 | "2Pac was born in East Harlem. That's the fact, in spite of the whole East-Coast/West-Coast thing. I'm not saying he's JUST a NY artist, but that NY being his birth place qualifies him as a NY artist no matter what else he may also be."
No it does not. It's like making a "Best Bands from Chicago" tourney and being like "Hmm Eddie Vedder was born in Chicago, that's enough to warrant the inclusion of Pearl Jam",,, even though Pearl Jam is one of the most notable Seattle bands ever and really has nothing to do with Chicago other than the fact that Eddie Vedder was born there. You get where I'm coming from? | Titan
06.18.17 | what a sad representation of new york
millennials really do suck sweaty balls | Divaman
06.18.17 | Alex, I get it. I understand the logic of your position, and if you did a tournament like this and chose to exclude 2Pac on the grounds that you mentioned, I'd understand perfectly. I made a different choice. As a proud New Yorker myself, my tendency is to go for the wider definition. To ignore him would feel to me like I was denying 2Pac his birthright. But I can understand how someone else could make a different decision. (And btw, if were from Chicago, I'd be claiming Eddie Vedder for my own too). | Divaman
06.18.17 | lol, it could be worse, Titan. And don't forget, when I get my winner, they'll be pitted against Velvet Underground, who won butcherboy's tournament last week. (Assuming the site doesn't completely implode before we can do that). | AlexKzillion
06.18.17 | Okay, I agree to disagree here haha | Winesburgohio
06.18.17 | PE
Carole King tbh | TwigTW
06.18.17 | Public Enemy
Carole King | granitenotebook
06.18.17 | nas | ianblxdsoe
06.18.17 | 1 & 3 | TheCrocodile
06.18.17 | 1 |
Submit Comment
|