MrSirLordGentleman
04.03.18 | Some cool picks
3, 4 and 12 are my favorites in here |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | I don't think Tales would even make my top 5 Yes albums. Solid list but could use Rush hard |
MrSirLordGentleman
04.03.18 | Rush ain't really that prog |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | What |
MrSirLordGentleman
04.03.18 | They've always been a great hard rock band for me, but even if prog-influenced, I don't really think they can be labeled as a prog band
Besides the fact that their songs are certainly longer than you classic hard rock piece, the general structure still remains, though with the awesome techinque that lies within them |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | They've changed their sound a lot from album to album and the prog influence has varied a lot but you'd be hard pressed to argue that (at the very least) 2112-Hemis weren't prog albums. I'd say a few more than that personally but those 3 at the very least seem undeniable to me idk |
Friday13th
04.03.18 | At very least Rush from 2112 to Moving Pictures is prog.
If Rush isn't prog, than neither is Pink Floyd or Supertramp. |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | I'd say Caress to MP personally |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | Hell I might even throw Signals in there |
Friday13th
04.03.18 | yeah Caress is kinda iffy. Fly by Night has like 2 prog songs on it. Same with Signals. |
SCREAM!
04.03.18 | Between Necromancer & Fountain I think it's pretty easy to count Caress in their prog years
Signals is a little iffy |
bgillesp
04.03.18 | Triana and Quarteto 1111 |
McP3000
04.03.18 | Red is my favorite 70's prog album. |
Jethro42
04.03.18 | Good list. Nice to see 12 and 14
7 is better than I remembered, but would not figure in my top 30
5 is a band I have hard times to like
6 is great, but would not figure in my top 30
The only one I dislike is the cold and hostile 15.
My list would contain some Camel, Maneige, Renaissance, Pink Floyd, Triumvirat, UK, Supertramp and maybe ELP or Focus.
As for Rush, they prog hard from 2112 to Moving Pictures, and they pretty much flirt with prog throughout the rest of their discog.
|
wham49
04.03.18 | would have picked a different GG, Yes, Genesis, JT and Can |
Sinternet
04.03.18 | trash genre but not even one camel album? smh |
Jethro42
04.03.18 | Oh, and Rush would figure in my top 15 as well. And I see you 5'd some PFM. They deserve a place into that list. Rock Progressivo Italiano needs more love on Sput. |
bloaf38
12.12.20 | 5 is the best. Also does Floyd count as prog? I think I only like Can and Pink Floyd for '70's prog. and some King Crimson. |