miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | My first non-metal list. |
adr
08.08.16 | 6 is 2
|
JamieTwort
08.08.16 | Switch 1 and 3 and this would be a decent ranking.
6 should only be one place higher at the most. |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @Jamie You're good at determining what's a good ranking and what is not a good ranking. I respect that (sarcasm). |
Jethro42
08.08.16 | Nice ranking
8, 9 and 10 > 7
Abacab > Invisible Touch |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @Jethro42 Thanks bud. I rank 7 as high as I did since it's my first Genesis record, and I got hooked right away. I still memorize all the song lyrics on that album too. |
adr
08.08.16 | 1>6>2>3>4 haven't heard the rest |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @adr Step out of the Gabriel zone bud. |
wham49
08.08.16 | 6-8 are embarrassingly low |
wham49
08.08.16 | 1 is 1 though, don't listen to the haters, 3 should be 5-6 |
Sunnyvale
08.08.16 | Sweet list. 1 is definitely in the right place for me, with 3 close behind. |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @wham I think a lot of people with like 10,000+ comments on this site think of themselves as seniority and believe they're allowed to dismiss people's different opinions just because I don't bandwagon on their views.
tbh, I would rank 7 a bit higher, and I might even do so since it's my most replayed Genesis record. I think 6 is fine where it's at although I may bump it up one slot, and 8 is alright for now for me.
@sunny thanks bud. |
anat
08.08.16 | Good list, so much terrible artwork |
JamieTwort
08.08.16 | "@Jamie You're good at determining what's a good ranking and what is not a good ranking. I respect that (sarcasm)."
You mean just like everyone else commenting in this thread? I'm not even sure you yourself know what point your trying to make with that "sarcasm". |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @anatelier They seemed to love cheesy artwork to fit their theatrical antics. I think ...And Then There Were Three is the least terrible aesthetically. |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @Jamie I can respect different opinions but using words like "should" indicate that you are dictating my rankings to your liking and expect me to do the same. If everyone thought like that, then every goddam Genesis fan might as well say "fuck our own rankings" and rank based on your own. If I'm overthinking it, then fine, but goddamn it if I should be penalized for having a different ranking than the majority of people like the wankery you and Nero pulled on my Black Sabbath ranking. |
JamieTwort
08.08.16 | Obviously it's my opinion that I'm stating, just like you're stating your opinion with this ranking and everyone else commenting on this list is stating theirs. I don't feel it necessary to say in my opinion after everything I say. And my use of the word 'should' in this instance was actually me sort of agreeing with your placement of Nursery Cryme. |
miketunneyiscool123
08.08.16 | @Jamie Thanks for the clarity I guess. Now I'll know what to expect as far as your opinions are concerned. Maybe I just misread things sometimes, but I'm only human right? |
wham49
08.10.16 | the only time I get like that is when for the hundredth time have to listen to people putting Master of Reality in the top 2 of Sabbath albums, people and their F'ing agenda's. LOL |
