BillTheButcher
06.19.14 | not a bad album in the bunch. |
KILL
06.19.14 | remission beats hunter cmon
but yea none of em are that gd |
Avagantamos
06.19.14 | mastodon is the most average band to ever exist |
BMDrummer
06.19.14 | So many Mr. Dan rankings lately |
titanslayer
06.19.14 | I haven't heard 2 yet but I thought 1 was easily their worst |
Mythodea
06.19.14 | I generally disagree but 1 is 1. |
erizen826
06.19.14 | 4 is 1 what are you guys smoking |
Mythodea
06.19.14 | 4 is 2 but close to 1. Then BM, OMRTS, TH and in the end Remission because it's too sludgy for me... |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
06.19.14 | pussy |
smokersleeper5268
06.19.14 | Nice list. |
ScuroFantasma
06.19.14 | Crack the Skye is awesome agreed |
PitchforkArms
06.19.14 | 6 is great... |
Onirium
06.20.14 | I tried to get into this band a couple times, but I just never really dug it. I wanted to try again this summer, would you guys rec me to start with the new one? Or if not which one? |
BMDrummer
06.20.14 | Their new one is actually really good, I was genuinely surprised by how much I liked it. It would be a good one to start with, since it basically culminates everything they did, minus the harsh vocals for the most part. |
ScuroFantasma
06.20.14 | Even though it's not their best, I'd start with Blood Mountain because the songs are shorter than anything on Crack the Skye and are generally easier too get into. CTS takes time. |
Uranium
06.20.14 | remission is my jam |
Mythodea
06.20.14 | Short songs indeed but maybe they're too experimental for a start... I think the shiny production of OMRTS is fine. |
smokersleeper5268
06.20.14 | Id start with Blood Mountain and watch this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iik9bF9l7HY then give Crack the skye a spin. |
Onirium
06.20.14 | Well, from what I've heard from a lot of people, I think I'd prefer Crack the Sky because it's proggier, but I've jammed a bit of Leviathan before and it sounded cool too |
fsharptrit0ne
06.20.14 | once more is 3rd. cmon its not better than skye or levi |
Onirium
06.20.14 | Well I'm currently jamming Once More, and I think I really dig it. |
Onirium
06.20.14 | But next on my playlist is Crack the Sky, and you say it's great and proggy so I'm in |
Madbutcher3
06.20.14 | I'd go Blood Mountain myself.
Would be interesting to see where Call Of The Mastodon would be since I prefer that a lil to Hunter and Remission. |
Dodenakker
06.20.14 | For me it's probably: Leviathan > Crack the Skye > Once More 'Round the Sun > Blood Mountain > Remission > The Hunter > Call of the Mastodon.
At least, it is now, it was different. Gotta edit those rankings though. |
DrGonzo1937
06.21.14 | Interesting opinion. CTS is 1 though, yes! |
Twilightfern
07.25.15 | In my opinion remission is best! |
Muppelope
07.25.15 | CTS, Leviathan, Remission >>> BM, Hunter, OMRTS |
Sevengill
07.25.15 | The hell? |
DoofusWainwright
07.25.15 | 3, 4, 1, 6, 5, 2
Typical career arc of a lot of bands - here the metaphorical peak is appropriately represented by a Blood Mountain |
adr
07.25.15 | 6 is 1 |
Ocean of Noise
07.25.15 | reverse the list and it's correct |
Ocean of Noise
07.25.15 | yea switch Crack the Skye and Hunter and that's basically my ranking Arcade |
Muppelope
07.25.15 | @Arcade pretty spot on, last 3 are all interchangeable for me, but I prefer The Hunter atm. |
Sevengill
07.25.15 | Leviathan, Crack the Skye, Remission, Blood Mountain,
...
...
...
Once More 'Round the Sun
...
...
...
...
...
The Hunter |
Ocean of Noise
07.25.15 | damn The Hunter rules guys cmon |
deathschool
07.25.15 | 6 is 1 |