Ryus
02.01.23 | this list is authoritative, definitive, didactic, and absolute [2]
"oh that isn't rock" "oh they're mid" dont care |
SomeCallMeTim
02.01.23 | objectively wrong for not including CAN |
Ryus
02.01.23 | can gets an honorable mention. im not familiar enough with all their work but they could potentially be here |
GhandhiLion
02.01.23 | Some based picks here. |
GhandhiLion
02.01.23 | Including Royal Trux is a surprising choice, despite Twin infinities being one of my favourite albums. |
Ryus
02.01.23 | twin infinitives was one of those formative albums for me. went from hating it to loving it so quickly that i surprised myself. and they have some great stuff beyond that album as well |
GhandhiLion
02.01.23 | Black Tambourine are a meme band though. |
GhandhiLion
02.01.23 | Yeah they have some other great stuff, but Twin Infinitives towers over the rest of their discography. I probably value bands that release great albums consistently more than you, still a based pick though. |
Colton
02.01.23 | where is Lil Yachty |
Ryus
02.01.23 | https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=1037980&listid=173982
prescient |
Ryus
02.01.23 | @ghandhi yeah a lot of these artists just have 1 or 2 releases that are really important to me. i am a notorious failure at finishing/semi-finishing discogs so thats part of the reason lol |
ffs
02.01.23 | list got me on the edge of the ape oven |
JohnnyoftheWell
02.02.23 | Modest Mouse at 2 is enough of a meme that you might as well have gone for Muse or Kyary Pamyu Pamyu
+ AnCo placement is major self-delusion points
Otherwise this can fuck. Mmm. Surprised to see Medicine so high!! |
combustion07
02.02.23 | I expected a list with 50 classic rock bands. I am pleasantly surprised by a nice, diverse list. Lots of awesome picks here along with some I've been meaning to get around to checking out |
GhandhiLion
02.02.23 | anco is fair if we are going by peaks and ignore the 10s |
Mort.
02.02.23 | polvo and unwound are 2 and 1 |
ArsMoriendi
02.02.23 | Ew The Smiths, but that’s to be expected since I know you’re a big fan
I feel like we sync up better with non-rock hmmm
|
Ryus
02.02.23 | this is very lightly ranked beyond the top ~10 ish
not a bad take mort |
evilford
02.02.23 | Immolation m////// |
DominionMM1
02.02.23 | well you got ehg here so that’s good |
granitenotebook
02.02.23 | where the fuck are the all american rejects |
neekafat
02.02.23 | “(Objcetive)” wheres paramore then huh |
Ryus
02.02.23 | i will take them into consideration next time |
JohnnyoftheWell
02.02.23 | every single one of the new paramore singles is a separate strike out against consideration
"where the fuck are the all american rejects"
address this one though, or no feature |
Ryus
02.02.23 | i would never trade my dignity for a feature |
Emim
02.02.23 | buckcherry doesn't even get a mention huh |
Snake.
02.02.23 | 17 pog |
evilford
02.02.23 | Voivod m/ |
StormChaser
02.02.23 | wow ryus your definition of rock is like so cool |
IsisScript80
02.02.23 | Here's some good (objective) rockin' an' a rollin'! |
evilford
02.02.23 | It has gorguts, list checks out |
StormChaser
02.02.23 | i wanna be inclusive like this to have a MBV and Darkthrone album on the same list, so enligthened |
evilford
02.02.23 | Based pilled yeah |
Avagantamos
02.02.23 | 1. linkin park
2. isis |
dedex
02.02.23 | cool list, love to see Beat Happening and Drive Like Jehu |
Demon of the Fall
02.02.23 | If this was a list of actual rock, rock would in fact be a good genre
cool |
rhinocerosmilk
02.02.23 | Im imagining that people who don't like rock N roll hear all the classics like it's Two Sides of the Moon. |
Ryus
02.02.23 | remember this list is objective so any quibbles you have with it are wrong |
fogza
02.02.23 | from the little i've seen of ryus, i'm surprised to see no whitesnake on here |
Ryus
02.02.23 | idk what that is but i have a feeling it isnt good |
fogza
02.02.23 | there's something beautiful about the idea of a life lived without hearing whitesnake |
IsisScript80
02.02.23 | ^ Not more than a life lived hearing Whitesnake... OBJECTIVELY the greatest hair metal band EVARRR! |
IsisScript80
02.02.23 | "idk what that is but i have a feeling it isnt good"
Oh, and I'm pretty sure it's just named after singer David Coverdale's dick, BTW. So whether it's "good" or not, is purely up for debate. |
DoofDoof
02.02.23 | some good some bad some happy some sad |
mkmusic1995
02.02.23 | Damn dude, where's that sweet FFDP |
fogza
02.02.23 | stay together |
fogza
02.02.23 | i feel like if you're punching people with five fingers that implies your fist is open in which case it should be five finger death thrust, point is it's a bad name on many levels |
IsisScript80
02.02.23 | Five Finger Bitchslap |
Demon of the Fall
02.02.23 | Four Fingers & A Thump |
Demon of the Fall
02.02.23 | I did actually debate this for five seconds on my lonesome once (before deciding it wasn't even important enough for the internet), but thanks fogza...
I was amused. |
mkmusic1995
02.02.23 | Four Finger Dick Pull |
MillionDead
02.02.23 | Some great taste on display here. Love a lot of these records, though I'd hesitate to call some of this "rock". lol |
onionbubs
02.02.23 | r.e.m. probably tops my list now. adore that band |
fogza
02.02.23 | my primary goals are to make good omelettes and amuse demon, so my life is pretty much sorted now |
Ryus
02.02.23 | good choice onion |
sonictheplumber
02.02.23 | i like 28 of these |
Ryus
02.02.23 | ill take it |
GhandhiLion
02.02.23 | Why no medicine rating |
Ryus
02.02.23 | i mostly just rate stuff on rym these days |
Hyperion1001
02.02.23 | rock on brother |
Ryus
02.03.23 | em slash |
z00sh
02.03.23 | unwound numero uno m/// |
StormChaser
02.03.23 | whitesnake are so washed they played in my town TWICE in the last 20 years and nobody ever comes here |