scottpilgrim10
09.03.14 | Any quick 5s from this year too? |
zakalwe
09.03.14 | King Creosote - From Scotland With Love |
Lowder91bird
09.03.14 | Genesis-Selling England by the Pound and Nursery Cryme. |
Froot
09.03.14 | Buckethead - Pike 13 |
Relinquished
09.03.14 | thou-heathen
quick 5 from this year |
Ryus
09.03.14 | weakerthans-reconstruction site |
TheBarber
09.03.14 | Have A Nice Life-Deathconsciousness
Godflesh-Streetcleaner
Talk Talk-Laughing Stock |
ArsMoriendi
09.03.14 | Mr Bungle - California. First listen.
Kate Bush - The Kick Inside
Both of those albums were just instant classics. Furthest things from "growers" ever. |
insanedrexl1
09.03.14 | Shining - Halmstad |
InFlamesWeThrash666
09.03.14 | Queens Of The Stone Age - Songs For The Deaf |
Keyblade
09.03.14 | Tomorrow's Harvest I guess. I've been familiar with my 5's for years before I rated them, but I 5'd TH after around a year of hearing it. Eyedazzler's prolly second |
Onirium
09.03.14 | Very good question, I'd say it was Red by King Crimson
|
Gestapo
09.03.14 | saor |
jefflebowski
09.03.14 | none of my 5s were quick |
Angelboros
09.03.14 | Faith No More - Angel Dust
Cynic - Traced in Air and Focus
Agoraphobic Nosebleed - Altered States of America
Gulaggh - Vorkuta |
PitchforkArms
09.03.14 | Oceansize - Frames
The Ocean - Precambrian |
wwf
09.03.14 | None of my fives were quick. |
Gameofmetal
09.03.14 | None of my fives were quick. [2]
I always let things sit for a time before a 5. The only things I consider 5 worthy are a few classic Metallica records and Caladan Brood's Echoes of Battle
Saor is pretty close but still a 4.5 at the moment. |
Totengott
09.03.14 | Coroner - Mental Vortex and Isis - Oceanic, that's for this year. |
ConorIsNotHere
09.03.14 | We Lost The Sea - The Quietest Place On Earth |
zakalwe
09.03.14 | Throughout my time on this planet these all expanded me mind on first listen. I was young when I heard the majority of these but they've all kept their place.
Nirvana - Nevermind
Pearl Jam - Ten
Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream
Grant Lee Buffalo - Fuzzy
Pavement - Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain
Beatles - Abbey Road
Air - Moon Safari
Spiritualized - Ladies and gentleman....
Radiohead - OK Computer
Massive Attack - Mezzanine
Black Sabbath - Paranoid
|
Wadlez
09.03.14 | All of my 5s were quick hue hue
Probably BoC - Geogaddi |
StallionMang
09.03.14 | There's only been a few albums that I've instantly 5'd before:
Pink Moon
Lift Yr Skinny Fists
Madvillainy
Geogaddi
Endtroducing
|
laughingman22
09.03.14 | remain in light was the only instant 5 for me |
Gestapo
09.03.14 | for a sec i thought u meant this year so
lord snow - solitude
refused - shape
asap rocky - liveloveasap
main attrakionz - 808s 2
rick ross - rich forever
have a nice life - deathconsciousness
my bloody valentine - loveless |
NorthernSkylark
09.03.14 | well, i fived a lot when i first started, the good old classics so to speak, but since then:
dino jr. - you're living all over me
slowdive - souvlaki
carissa's wierd - songs about leaving
women - public strain
unwound - leaves turn inside you |
wwba
09.03.14 | Converge - Jane Doe
Attack Attack! - Someday Came Suddenly
Periphery - Periphery
Woe, Is Me - Numbers
The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute |
MO
09.03.14 | opeth - my arms your hearse
the beatles - abbey road
meshuggah - nothing
pink floyd - animals/WYWH |
Let
09.03.14 | I can't think of any that were immediate, but it didn't take long for me to 5 these:
Talking Heads - Remain in Light
Demilich - Nespithe
The Avalanches - Since I Left You
Massive Attack - Mezzanine (Actually this one was pretty immediate) |
LepreCon
09.03.14 | Instant 4.5's are highest possible with me. Needs to be good over a period of time to warrant a 5. But that's just how I rate things, everyone is different |
HBFS
09.03.14 | the wild hunt by tmoe and a bunny's caravan and slow riot for new zero kanada were all pretty much insta-5s for me |
beartato108
09.03.14 | Aeroplane and Hospice were pretty quick for me. Aeroplane took one listen, can't remember how long Hospice took. |
AnimalsAsSummit
09.03.14 | most recently would be dan swano - moontower
ever....hmmmm.... probably choirs of the eye |
scottpilgrim10
09.03.14 | I need to check out a lot of these. I've recently heard animals by Pink Floyd and it's definitely a good record but I don't see it becoming a 5 for me.
Some Other ones I have thought of:
Nirvana- Nevermind
Arctic Monkeys- Debut
The Beatles- Abbey Road
Pantera- Cowboys From Hell
Wilco- Yankee Foxtrot Hotel
|
Torontonian
09.03.14 | Camel-Mirage and Porcupine Tree-Deadwing |
Artuma
09.03.14 | the monitor by titus andronicus |
menawati
09.03.14 | most of my instant 5s were back when i had an open mind, i'm now jaded and cynical, it's pitiable really |
Rhyme
09.03.14 | i never rate anything above a 4 on first listen. it usually takes a long time before i realize something is a 5 for me. that said, the quickest 5 i gave was probably kayo dot's choirs of the eye |
BMDrummer
09.03.14 | latest was Unwound's Leaves Turn Inside You, holy fuck |
Insurrection
09.03.14 | rachmaninoff - piano concerto no 2 |
Linx
09.03.14 | Meteora- Likin Park
Discovery- Daft Punk
Challenger- Memphis May Fire |
emester
09.03.14 | Agalloch The Mantle
Opeth- Morningrise
Rush- A Farewell To Kings
Manilla Road- Crystal Logic
|
Friday13th
09.03.14 | Thick as a Brick. I heard the whole thing and instantly 5'd it. |
lyzakthellama
09.03.14 | Bjork- Post |
scottpilgrim10
09.03.14 | Vespertine and Homogenic were almost immediate 5s for me. I love post but I find it a little overrated.
|
facupm
09.03.14 | wish you were here probably |
Phobonnika
09.03.14 | Filosofem. |
RogueNine
09.03.14 | My one 5 took a little while. |
Mercy
09.03.14 | Dismember - Like an Everflowing Stream instantly hit me. |
DikkoZinner
09.03.14 | Bruce Springsteen - Nebraska |
Thuglifethor
09.04.14 | Helios - Eingya and Andrew Jackson Jihad - Knife Man |
Funeralopolis
09.04.14 | joy division- unknown pleasures
john coltrane- a love supreme |
Avagantamos
09.04.14 | when I first heard mezzanine I 5'd it right away. I have it at 4.5 now, but I might bump it back up at some point |
ZombicidalMan
09.04.14 | asobi seksu - citrus
boris - boris at last feedbacker
insta-5s |
erizen826
09.04.14 | I 5'd OK Computer after my first listen. I think that's it on my insta-fives other than when I first joined the site and was getting my favorites out of the way. |
Supercoolguy64
09.04.14 | "Whatever Happened to PJ Soles?" - Local H, might review that someday |
Veldin
09.04.14 | Frank Zappa - Hot Rats
Led Zeppelin - How the West Was Won
Swans - To Be Kind
Theophany - Time's End
Yes - Yessongs |
TheSupernatural
09.04.14 | Not any quick 5's besides Brand New, Radiohead, Manchester Orchestra, Tori Amos... Thrice obviously |
DrMaximus
09.04.14 | Fuckin Gospel |
Trebor.
09.04.14 | all of my 5s were massive growers |
zakalwe
09.04.14 | There must be one that completely bowled you over on first listen Treb? The one where you listen and you've never heard anything like it and it simultaneously sends ya stellar. |
Thibs
09.04.14 | Extol - Undeceived |
Avagantamos
09.05.14 | gospel [2] |
kris.
09.05.14 | tbh it was probably direct hit - brainless god |
Dodenakker
09.06.14 |
Karnivool - Sound Awake
|
DotEight
09.06.14 | "Meteora- Likin Park "
Lmao.
Death ofc. |
FeedingNetherlands
09.06.14 | Dead Kennedys - Fresh Fruit For Rotting Vegetables |
Xar
09.06.14 | None of my 5s were quick. |
Wadlez
09.06.14 | that's a new 1 |
Xar
09.06.14 | Wait I lied. Spirit of Eden was an obvious 4-4.5 on first listen. Obvious 5.0 by the 5th one. |
Gameofmetal
09.06.14 | XSPONGEXCOREX |
Tunaboy45
09.06.14 | Wish You Were Here
Animals
Dark Side Of The Moon
The Satanist
(off the top of my head) |
MyNameIsPencil
09.08.14 | Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
Weezer - Blue Album (all time favourite album)
Letlive. - Fake History |
bach
09.08.14 | my smiths 5s |
omgbecky
09.08.14 | Elliott Smith - s/t |
JokineAugustus
09.08.14 | Devin Townsend - Terria or Gorguts - From Wisdom To Hate |
EnyaFangirl
09.08.14 | Electra Heart |
Asdfp277
09.08.14 | i know boring and obvious but i'll say björk - homogenic |
Mythodea
09.08.14 | Mine were probably Vangelis - 1492:Conquest of Paradise, Steven Wilson - The Raven that Refused to Sing (And
Other Stories), Pink Floyd - The Wall.Now Im listening to 'The Snow Goose' by Camel, and I think it's a 5. |
Flugmorph
09.08.14 | Death - sound of p. comes to mind |
gryndstone
09.08.14 | The first time I listen to something it's never a five. The only two times this has been an exception are with Fleetwood Mac's Rumours and Swans' The Seer |
qwe3
09.08.14 | a lot of my fav albums i heard without thinking hey i would rate this 5/5 but probably disintegration or something. |
theacademy
09.08.14 | atreyu's last few albums and also i was only a few seconds into that new kimbra album and it was definitely a 5 for me |
theacademy
09.08.14 | hullo qwe |
Rowan5215
09.08.14 | Grace by J-Bucks for me |
qwe3
09.08.14 | hello friend, how are you |
InbredJed
09.08.14 | Angel Dust
Houdini
Through Silver In Blood |
Bromero
09.13.14 | Dark Side of the Moon |
Shuyin
09.13.14 | Isis - Oceanic
after the first 3 songs i just knew i had to 5 it |
Anthracks
09.21.14 | Only one I can think of is Kishi Bashi - Lighght, but I'm sure there are others. |