ButcherNate
10.26.13 | dude the wall at 10? i like animals the best |
Pheromone
10.26.13 | I have a confession to make.
*clears throat*
I've never listened to a pink floyd abum. |
StallionMang
10.26.13 | DUDE WHAT |
tempest--
10.26.13 | lol wtf |
ButcherNate
10.26.13 | get on that, seriously |
StallionMang
10.26.13 | Get WYWH and fucking immerse yourself right now. |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | @NerdTalent right now pls
Okay here we go
Wish You Were Here
Animals
Dark Side
Obscured by Clouds
The Division Bell
The Final Cut
Saucerful of Secrets
Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Atom Heart Mother
The Wall
A Momentary Lapse
Ummagumma
More |
GetOutOfMyHouse
10.26.13 | Boring |
MAGNIFICENT
10.26.13 | NerdTalent, I whole-heartedly recommend you too, it is more than just a journey through some band's discography. It's Pink Floyd, one of the biggest, greatest, best bands of all time. |
tempest--
10.26.13 | listening to floyd is a requirement when joining sput how did you manage to create an account man? |
Pheromone
10.26.13 | It's almost 2am and I'm about to head to bed but yeah whatever I'll add these to my list of bands to check out as I collapse on the floor. |
Pheromone
10.26.13 | I'm really attractive and have an excellent opinion on music so they let me pass. |
MAGNIFICENT
10.26.13 | And Butcher, I hold Animals, Wish You Were Here and Dark Side as 5's in my books, three wonderful albums. But I can't help it, Wish You Were Here is so eargasmic and Dark Side is my favorite record of all time. Animals would be a little better without the Pigs On The Wing, it just feels out of place. Still a 5 though. |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | I dunno man it's pretty hard to have an excellent opinion on music without listening to Floyd
also listening to Floyd actually makes you more attractive so if you're good-looking now you'll be a stallion by the time you finish their discog |
Pheromone
10.26.13 | Getting on it now ;) nah but seriously I'll most probably check them out tomorrow as well as checking out Elliott smith, I only recently joined sputnik and all these bands are being force apon me, I'm going to bed now I'm tired as fuck. Peace |
avonbarksdale221
10.26.13 | The top 3 are pretty interchangeable but yeah, solid ranking. |
LambsBread
10.26.13 | I have no respect for Piper at all. Final Cut is 1,000 times better than Piper |
avonbarksdale221
10.26.13 | I'm not huge on Piper either to be honest. |
demigod!
10.26.13 | oh man first time i heard Bike |
TAB
10.26.13 | piper is better than meddle. all meddle got is one of these days and echoes. final cut deserves its
slightly better than momentary ranking. although i've kind of grown to hate the wall, i still think
its better than ummagumma |
avonbarksdale221
10.26.13 | Half of it just comes off as kinda obnoxious. There are some good tracks, but doesn't really do it for
overall. If I'm gonna jam 60's psych, gimme Jefferson Airplane or Love any day. |
avonbarksdale221
10.26.13 | Um, Fearless? A Pillow of Winds? Echoes alone >>>>>> Piper |
demigod!
10.26.13 | i agree but the first time i heard Bike man i haven't laughed that hard in ages |
avonbarksdale221
10.26.13 | Syd was a lyrical genius |
TAB
10.26.13 | i will agree echoes is probably one of the best floyd songs, but otherwise meddle is like pink floyds 2112 |
demigod!
10.26.13 | it just sounds so fuckin retarded in like every way |
tempest--
10.26.13 | by that you mean top 5 yea |
StallionMang
10.26.13 | Syd Barrett = whimsical |
TAB
10.26.13 | yeh |
JaySpiral
10.26.13 | I like the love for Obscured by Clouds! But Atom Heart Mother is always underrated. |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | Piper rules guys wtf
but Saucerful is better |
tempest--
10.26.13 | the sea was angry that day, my friends |
demigod!
10.26.13 | a hole in 1 |
Muisc4Life26
10.26.13 | 3 is 1 |
menawati
10.26.13 | [startMacro] insert new String('final cut too low') into {*theweeklysputnikpinkfloydrankedlist} |
sonictheplumber
10.26.13 | meddle's my fav animals and wywh tied for 2nd |
Parallels
10.26.13 | I think youre the first to like 5 so much |
tempest--
10.26.13 | 5 is 5 for me as well |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | 5 is 4 for me and no way is the first to like it that much |
Atrophy
10.26.13 | 2 is 1 dawwwwg |
evilford
10.26.13 | 12 is wayyyy too low and the wall is overrated agreed |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | TFC >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Wall |
evilford
10.26.13 | ^ |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | ^^ |
DominionMM1
10.26.13 | "piper is better than meddle. all meddle got is one of these days and echoes."
ugh
|
Friday13th
10.26.13 | WYWH
Dark Side
Meddle
Animals
Piper
The Wall
haven't heard the rest in full |
NordicMindset
10.26.13 | ANIMALS |
JamieTwort
10.26.13 | The Final Cut should be much higher and 3 is 1.
and fuck whoever said Meddle is nothing apart from Echoes and One of These Days. That album is easily one of their best. Prob top 3 for me. |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | "and fuck whoever said Meddle is nothing apart from Echoes and One of These Days"
yeah agreed, Meddle is nothing apart from Echoes, One of these Days and Fearless |
wacknizzle
10.26.13 | 10 is 5, 11 is 6 |
JamieTwort
10.26.13 | "yeah agreed, Meddle is nothing apart from Echoes, One of these Days and Fearless"
and A Pillow of Winds agreed. So bassically it's nothing without the majority of its material... |
wacknizzle
10.26.13 | I like all the songs on Meddle. I know it's all about Echoes to everyone but I really enjoy that whole album. Even Seamus has a place for me |
JamieTwort
10.26.13 | Yeah same here but I can understand why people might not like Seamus and San Tropez. |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | well iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii was iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiin tha kiiiiiitcheeeeeeeeeeeen
n seeeeaaaaaaaamuus mah old hoooound was ooutsiiiiiiiiide |
Pheromone
10.26.13 | The artwork on #9 Is soooo good |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | ^ yeah one of my favourite artworks, 1-3 are all up there as well |
dante1991
10.26.13 | Great band, I agree with your top 4. I would have The Wall at 5 though. It's a touch overrated, but still better than most albums out there.
Had Saucerful on yesterday for the first time in ages. Excellent, underrated psychedelic album.
Never heard Obscured by Clouds, is it worth a shot then? |
Rowan5215
10.26.13 | Fuck yes Obscured is worth a shot |
TheNotrap
10.26.13 | The Dark Side of the Moon, The Wall and Wish You Were Here are their best works. |
stabbler
10.26.13 | top 4 are the top 4, though not necessarily in that order
11 is too low |
TwigTW
10.26.13 | It's good to see The Wall out of the top 5. |
Artuma
10.26.13 | "It's good to see The Wall out of the top 5."
fuck this, here it's always out of the top 5 damn |
musicalmedicine
11.18.13 | Basically this. Piper bores the living hell out of me though. |
evilford
11.18.13 | piper is 5/5 |
JokineAugustus
11.18.13 | Glad to see obscured so high |
kkamphaus
09.19.18 | Where would you put their latest?
|
