SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | Wow that took more work than i thought. |
Trebor.
04.07.13 | lol |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | ^ What's so lol :p |
DamnVanne
04.07.13 | welcome to Sputnik, a place where people like us get no love. |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | What do you mean people like us? |
climactic
04.07.13 | 10 that low is incredible |
climactic
04.07.13 | also black clouds at #1 is bizarre |
Drummerboy123
04.07.13 | No need to apologize man hahaha. Its only an opinion. |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @Drummerboy123
Well i've noticed that people on here have gotten ridiculed for their opinion, and have been called names and such. I don't really care for that, but i figure i'm gonna get it for my opinion :/ |
DamnVanne
04.07.13 | Die-hard DT fans.
|
DamnVanne
04.07.13 | I agree, The Count of Tuscany might be DT's best song. |
Trebor.
04.07.13 | The first like 3 minutes sure |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @DamnVanne
That I am! They are one of the two only bands (Alice In Chains in a lesser case) That actually bring out my emotions and make me feel with music. But are you insinuating that Die-hard DT fans get slack on here? |
MeatSalad
04.07.13 | 3=1 |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @DamnVanne
@Trebor17
Actually the first 3 minutes are probably my favourite part of the song. Jordan Ruddess really makes the song even better with his playing |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @MeatSalad
That's your opinion and i respect it :) |
MeatSalad
04.07.13 | thanks BRAH |
MeatSalad
04.07.13 | 10 is also good stuff, haven't heard most of the rest |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | Definately check out 1 and 2. |
MeatSalad
04.07.13 | heard some great things about 1, might get on it sometime |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | You won't regret it |
bloc
04.07.13 | 1's probably my favourite too |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | 1 is the first album i ever sat down and listened through, and good thing, because it's so amazing. |
tempest--
04.07.13 | lol |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.07.13 | Erm...this is beyond a joke
4 is 1
I loved 1 when I first heard it (my fanboy days), but it grew off me pretty fast |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | That's your opinion |
OmairSh
04.07.13 | Wow, I mean wow this is unexpected.
"The first like 3 minutes sure"
Yup, after that the song takes a turn. Instrumental versions of the album was better imo. |
MMX
04.07.13 | you messed up man |
OmairSh
04.07.13 | Whoa are your ratings for real? |
DamnVanne
04.07.13 | Of course his rating are legit. All Green Day albums are perfect, except for DOS!
|
DamnVanne
04.07.13 | That's just my opinion, though. |
Keyblade
04.07.13 | dam Awake is too low man |
NeroCorleone80
04.07.13 | Strangest ranking Ive seen |
thumbcrusher
04.07.13 | you need more 5s |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @DamnVanne you are probably the only person in the world who has agreed with my music taste thank you! |
Artuma
04.07.13 | what the hell hahaha, at least this is something original |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | I stray from the norm :P |
thumbcrusher
04.07.13 | oh shit Systematic Chaos is higher than Scenes you crazy |
porch
04.07.13 | dream theater is the enemy |
Artuma
04.07.13 | i can see that, won't see metropolis 2 that low every day |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | Maybe if i actually got into it it could pass Systematic Chaos but i really havent listened to it exscessivley like the rest :p |
Artuma
04.07.13 | how is falling into infinity so high? |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | Because of Anna Lee, Hollow Years, Take Away My Pain, and the Falling Into Infinity demo's. Those songs all mean alot to me |
ViperAces
04.07.13 | have only heard 3 and it is amazing |
Artuma
04.07.13 | i don't like hollow years and take away my pain, new millennium and peruvian skies are about the only ones i like there. my list would probably be 10, 5, 3, 4, 2, 7, 1, 8, 9, 6, 11 |
JamieTwort
04.07.13 | Falling into Infinity is kinda underrated imo. I'd prob have it about 6th too.
Apart from that this ranking is pretty weird. |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @Artuma
Hey at least we agree on 9 and 11 :P
@JamieTwort
Well it's my opinion haha |
OmairSh
04.07.13 | FII is underrated [2]
@SweetSerenity, it's cool that you shared your opinion, don't think I'll come across a ranking like this in the near future
|
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @OmairSh
Thanks :) do you disagree? |
ILJ
04.07.13 | this is so wrong |
SitarHero
04.07.13 | Why isn't A Change of Seasons ever on these lists? |
JaySpiral
04.07.13 | Dramatic Turn of Events and Scenes from a Memory are way too low. |
OmairSh
04.07.13 | @SweetSerenity, to quite an extent yeah :-). I also find it interesting that your top tracks are usually the ballads
Why isn't A Change of Seasons ever on these lists?[2]
Thats a top 5 DT track
"Dramatic Turn of Events and Scenes from a Memory are way too low."
ADTOE isn't really, it wasn't anything special |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | @OmairSh
I see A Change Of Seasons as more of a song, not an album.
I do like most DT ballads more than their metal songs, but some metal songs i like alot more too.
ADTOE Is good but a few songs, like Outcry and Breaking All Illusions, bring it down |
Artuma
04.07.13 | the solo section in outcry may be their worst ever |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | I also dislike Bridges In The Sky, other than that the album is good |
Artuma
04.07.13 | bridges in the sky rules |
SweetSerenity
04.07.13 | nah the ones i like on the album are (in order of tracklisting not preference)
On The Backs Of Angels
Build Me Up, Break Me Down
Lost Not Forgotten
This Is The Life
Far From Heaven
Beneath The Surface |
OmairSh
04.08.13 | Build Me Up, Break Me Down, seriously? I 've heard so little of it I keep forgetting its on the album
|
Artuma
04.08.13 | yeah and OTBOA is only a decent track too, this is the life and far from heaven are seriously forgettable |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | "I see A Change Of Seasons as more of a song, not an album."
Well in that case Scenes From A Memory should also probably not be on the list. Just sayin... |
Artuma
04.08.13 | scenes is so much too low in this list that it wouldn't make any difference if he didn't include it at all |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | Lol, good point. Maybe the better comparison would've been Six Degrees. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | yeah, probably |
tempest--
04.08.13 | But A Change of Seasons is one song on an EP that features other songs unrelated to that track.
Scenes and Six Degrees are full length albums of separated songs. Yeah, they all join up, but it doesn't change fact. |
tempest--
04.08.13 | Plus there is the first disc of Six Degrees. |
beefshoes
04.08.13 | I was a huge Dream Theater fan when I was 14-15 and if I hadn't gotten into them, I probably wouldn't have ever discovered real prog rock.
Kevin Moore DT is the best, FII gets way too much hate, and there's not been one decent album since Rudess joined. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | that's why six degrees would be a good comparison. in both there is half of the record consisting of one song |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | The line between multi-part epic and concept album is a blurry one IMO, ESPECIALLY in the case of DT when there are so many changes of mood in each song/part. Saying that a single epic can't also constitute an album would mean saying that X-Japan's 'Art of Life' isn't really an album either, and I'm not sure you want to do that here... |
beefshoes
04.08.13 | Seriously. Their lyrics have been absolute rubbish since Moore left and Myung stopped, their softer songs sound so dated except those on the older albums, and they've always been flamboyant as far as noodling is concerned but ever since Rudess joined there hasn't been much else besides that. |
tempest--
04.08.13 | A Change of Seasons is not an album though. It's an EP. Hence exclusion from the list. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | yup, this was just an unnecessary conversation since he said that didn't include a change of seasons cos it's "only a song" |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | A Change of Seasons IS an album. It's just not regarded as a "Full-Length" studio album. But what differentiates an LP from an EP is entirely arbitrary, because the title-track itself is longer than most Ramones LP's. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | EP is EP anyway |
tempest--
04.08.13 | Nowhere is A Change of Seasons ever called an album or LP or full length or whatever you choose. It is an EP. It has always been an EP.
Mike Portnoy himself said, and I quote "It was important for us and the label for it not to be perceived as the latest studio record. That's why we tagged it an EP." |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | Even EP's are albums, and sometimes very important ones, like Alice in Chains' EP's. The fact that it's not a full-length album doesn't mean it's not an album. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | i think it's a valid reason to exclude it |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | Well as I said before, the line between an LP and an EP is pretty arbitrary, and I respect the fact that the band itself didn't consider the EP to be a canonical "studio record".
But that being said, the title track IS one of their best works, is far more listenable than Systematic Chaos. |
Artuma
04.08.13 | well sure, i would even say that it's their best song ever but it's an EP and that's it |
OmairSh
04.08.13 | Bands going to the crapper |
tempest--
04.08.13 | sorry dude but you're just ridiculous holy crap i am never commenting in this thread again |
OmairSh
04.08.13 | Alrighty then |
tempest--
04.08.13 | dam going back on my word just to clarify I was talking to SitarHero not you dam now I look like a fool |
OmairSh
04.08.13 | Alrighty then |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | Why am I being ridiculous? |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | It's an E.P. i would consider Alic In Chains Jar Of Flies as an album though. |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | just wondering because i love 10, what are your least fav tracks from there? |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | I dislike:
Strange Deja Vu
Beyond This Life
The Dance Of Eternity
One Last Time
I like:
Regression
Overture 1928
Through Her Eyes
The Spirit Carries On
Home
And the rest i neither like or dislike :)
|
ViperAces
04.08.13 | strange deja vu is actually one of my favourites, first dt song i ever liked. i agree with the likes, though, these songs rock |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | Black Clouds And Silver Linings is still their best though :) |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | i have actually only heard images and scenes, got a load of dt to check |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | Images is a fantastic album! Seriously check out Black Clouds, and Six Degrees! :D |
SitarHero
04.08.13 | "It's an E.P. i would consider Alic In Chains Jar Of Flies as an album though."
Then that's just a double-standard.
"i have actually only heard images and scenes, got a load of dt to check"
I would actually suggest giving A Change of Seasons a spin. Not to be contrary, but because it's awesome.
|
JamieTwort
04.08.13 | A Change of Seasons is easily one of their best songs. You need to check Awake too, Viper. |
OmairSh
04.08.13 | "Black Clouds And Silver Linings is still their best though "
Dude.....
"I would actually suggest giving A Change of Seasons a spin"
Definitely, back when DT was writing quality music |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | where is a change of seasons from? i will check these albums out.
|
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | @SitarHero
Well it's because Jar Of Flies had 7 original songs, and A Change Of Seasons only had 1 original and a few covers. I wouldn't put it in the same list as full length albums. |
JamieTwort
04.08.13 | @Viper: A Change of Seasons is the name of the EP. |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | ok thanks bro=) |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | really hope this dude is a genuine user, he seems cool |
Artuma
04.08.13 | well he 5'd all green day albums except one |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | I give all 5's in the ratings to support the artist. Dumb i know. But in my reviews, i give what i feel is my actual score. Note that i have no reviews as of yet, but i was on a different site until i found sputnik |
ViperAces
04.08.13 | ok nvm its def an alt/troll |
SweetSerenity
04.08.13 | Nope |
tmagistrelli
04.11.13 | this is camgrovesfan and his story is different.
"he's a phony, a great big phony!" |