Twelve51
04.23.12 | Two of the most iconic figures in the history of Rock n' Roll. I have to give a slight edge to Dylan. |
Cipieron
04.23.12 | Bowie for sure. |
Ovrot
04.23.12 | Bowie |
AngelofDeath
04.23.12 | Bowie has talent. Dylan does not.
/thread |
TheFonz123
04.23.12 | dylan |
jefflebowski
04.23.12 | Dylan is in a different league to Bowie. Sure, he's has some classic albums, but i don't think anything of Bowie's compares to Blonde on Blonde or Highway 61 in terms of seminal status |
YankeeDudel
04.23.12 | Um Ziggy Stardust |
livingisland
04.23.12 | Bowie |
phishing
04.23.12 | dylan obviously |
Ire
04.23.12 | "Bowie has talent. Dylan does not."
Uh, what?
Comparing the two is dumb. |
Maniac!
04.23.12 | dylan
' Bowie has talent. Dylan does not.'
WTF. its one thing to not like him, but saying he has no talent is just being stupid |
Funeralopolis
04.23.12 | Bowie |
Twelve51
04.23.12 | "Comparing the two is dumb."
They're just two of my all time favorites so I figured it would be interesting to see who the members of this site preferred. don't mean to offend. |
MO
04.23.12 | leave lists like this up to hans whenever he comes back |
Ire
04.23.12 | lol met
dw dude, i'm a fan of both, but i only meant that they're so different in like every way. |
thunder15
04.23.12 | career?
overall (acting, etc): bowie
purely music: dylan |
tommygun
04.23.12 | Bowie |
Blackbelt54
04.23.12 | Don't know why these two are being compared, but I prefer Dylan |
AngelofDeath
04.23.12 | Dylan can't sing or play the guitar, and as good as his lyrics can be, his songwriting is pretty derivative and uninteresting to me. |
jefflebowski
04.23.12 | does not compute |
Maniac!
04.23.12 | Angel what the hell are you smoking? |
LAD
04.24.12 | dylan. fuck talent even though he has it, if it aint his talent, it the talent inspired by a god |
TheGardener
04.24.12 | Dylan. Though I still love Bowie. |
gabethepiratesquid
04.24.12 | They're really different but I like Dylan a lot more. |
wabbit
04.24.12 | What the hell crawled up Angel's ass.
Dylan cause he's like a better version of jesus |
baldymort
04.24.12 | Bowie. Not a fan of Dylan. |
PuddlesPuddles
04.24.12 | Bowie |
jefflebowski
04.24.12 | whether you're fans or not, Dylan is just better |
SCREAMorphine
04.24.12 | I'm a bit more of a Bowie fan, but Dylan is great. |
clercqie
04.24.12 | "i'm a fan of both, but i only meant that they're so different in like every way."
Basically this |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.24.12 | Bowie. Don't listen to much of either, but I prefer what I know from Bowie |
JohnP
06.05.12 | For lyrics, legacy, longevity and literary significance - it's Dylan, Dylan, Dylan and Dylan.
For image, musical creativity, influence on other artists and innovation - it's Bowie, Bowie, Bowie, and Bowie.
A tie. |
NightProwler
06.05.12 | Although I really like Bob Dylan's music, I have to say David Bowie. |
