MO
02.22.12 | 8 and 2 |
Yuma310
02.22.12 | I see. |
NeutralThunder12
02.22.12 | yeah 3 and 4 suck really bad. 6 is really boring. 7-9 rule hard but you could pick better miles than 8 and 2 is the best ever |
mvood
02.22.12 | no one ever comments about modest mouse on this site... |
Yuma310
02.22.12 | Honestly just can't like/get into modest mouse. |
NeutralThunder12
02.22.12 | yeah i dont dig em either |
DarkSideOfLucca
02.22.12 | Neutralthunder, you can't possibly hate 3. Stop lying to yourself and just accept that Lateralus is the best. |
Cipieron
02.22.12 | 4 is the best thing here |
nex77
02.22.12 | Lateralus and In Absentia are quality. I can't get Modest Mouse either... |
blackparade
02.22.12 | this list sucks , now you know...lol |
UnnamedOcean
02.22.12 | It's really the vocals of Modest Mouse that put me off. |
balcaen
02.22.12 | idk what's up with the rest of this website. 1 is perfect though, nothing TO be talked about really |
Dimor
02.22.12 | lol, In Absentia and Lateralus aren't even close to sucking, stop trolling. They might not be the best albums of all time(allthough it all comes down to personal opinion), but i can definitely see how someone could vote them as 5:s |
Dimor
02.22.12 | Also, big props for 7,8 and 9 |
blackparade
02.22.12 | dont take it so seriously ;D |
Aids
02.22.12 | the third planet is sure that they're being watched by and eye in the sky that can't be stopped and when you get to the promise land, you're gonna shake that eye's hand... |
Aids
02.22.12 | good call on 7 by the way, fucking love me some King Crimson. and 9, well, 9. |
Dimor
02.22.12 | Well, i just feel that youre a bit hyperbolic when you say that albums that have like 4.3 general rating combined suck dick |
Uranium
02.22.12 | needs more meshuggah |
blackparade
02.22.12 | rock n roll....jee... |
Aids
02.22.12 | a high average rating for an album means nothing. 50% of the ratings in this website's database are from metal-head mxtabs vets who rated every dream theater album a 5 and haven't been active on the site for 5+ years.
sputnik needs to develop a system where like, if you haven't been active for 2 years or so your ratings slowly get phased out. |
blackparade
02.22.12 | a high average rating for an album means nothing. 50% of the ratings in this website's database are from metal-head mxtabs vets who rated every dream theater album a 5 and haven't been active on the site for 5+ years.
(y) |
Dimor
02.22.12 | Well yeah, you are quite right about that, i agree it would be good if the ratings phased out after some time. when i first joined i tried most of the 5:s on here and no more than like 10% lived up to the rating.
Allthough i still disagree about Tool and PT sucking big dicks. |
Aids
02.22.12 | yeah but Riff hates pretty much everything so whatever don't let it bother you |
fsharptrit0ne
02.22.12 | neut is so gay |
Uranium
02.22.12 | well tool rules, but haters gon hate |
TheFonz123
02.22.12 | tool is garbage (2) |
Spec
02.22.12 | true fives can't be ranked |
Days of Future Passed
02.23.12 | "yeah but Riff hates pretty much everything so whatever don't let it bother you"
^This. |
FearThyEvil
02.23.12 | Lol at the Tool is garbage comments. |
Betacra
02.23.12 | Tool isn't a bad band, in fact they're a very good band.
Same goes for Porcupine Tree, so many solid albums that I can't hate on them. |
Mike08
02.23.12 | I neither hate nor love tool. I love them on certain songs, hate them on others, hate their egos, hate their album timings, and find most of the work to be good, not great. Though I LOVE Third Eye, The Grudge, Prison Sex, Somber, and 10,000 Days.... so there |
iambandersnatch
02.23.12 | wtf @ people hating on 4, are you trolling? It's probably not a five but it's pretty awesome. |
Aphrodisiac
02.23.12 | how you only 5 nine albums out of almost 600 ratings is beyond me |
Dimor
02.23.12 | 5:s are sometimes way overrated |
Hankpym
02.27.12 | I love modest mouse. . . .Tool . . ehhhh. |
