Masochist
12.22.11 | I'm just curious as to which of these equally praised albums by each artist you guys like best. You obviously don't have to do every artist, but for the ones you do, choose only one of those albums.
Voting stops when I think people have stopped paying attention; I'll then post the results in a different list.
Here are the results of the past contests (and the date that those contests were first posted), just in case you're wondering why I didn't include some obvious artists like Metallica or Radiohead:
CONTEST 1 (5/20/08): http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=248968&listid=15125
CONTEST 2 (9/03/10): http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=248968&listid=54647
(There are three or four repeat artists from former contests, but I wanted to ask about different albums this time around) |
NeutralThunder12
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
4. Highway
5. For Emma
11. Arrows
12. Helplessness
17. Endless Numbered
20. A to B Life is their best but out of those two Brother Sister prolly
25. Kezia
30. Illinois, by a lot
27. Hemispheres isn't gay so Hemispheres
31. Out of those Vheissu |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | 1. the silent circus
2. homogenic
3. blink-182
5. for emma, forever ago
7. viva la vida
8. disentegration
9. diamond eyes
10. ocean machine
12. helplessness blues
13. the color and shape
14. 13 songs
16. plastic beach
18. my beautiful dark twisted fantasy
19. simple math
23. slanted and enchanted
24. doolittle
25. kezia
27. 2112
29. somewhere in the between
30. the age of adz
31. vheissu
34. define the great line
should remove 35 and change it to modest mouse - the lonesome crowded west vs moon and antarctica |
KILL
12.22.11 | thrice suck |
Masochist
12.22.11 | Thought about putting up Modest Mouse, actually, but I thought that 'The Moon and Antarctica' would win out (then again, I thought the same thing about Jimmy Eat World's 'Bleed American', but that didn't win).
Oh, well...maybe next time ;-) |
whywontyoudie
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
4. Blood on the Tracks
5. For Emma, Forever Ago
8. Pornography
9. Diamond Eyes
13. The Colour and the Shape
14. Repeater
16. Demon Days
18. MBDTF
19. Mean Everything to Nothing
20. Brother, Sister
25. Fortress
27. Hemispheres
29. Everything Goes Numb
31. Vheissu
34. Lost In The Sound of Separation
|
jayfatha
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
3. Enema
10. Terria
25. Kezia
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions
27. 2112
28. City
31. The Illusion of Saftey
|
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | its not too late no one's voted for 35 plus who cares about the white stripes if not de stijl |
Trebor.
12.22.11 | cool
|
Cipieron
12.22.11 | 11. Fables from a Mayfly
16. Demon Days
25. Kezia
27. Moving Pictures
35. Elephant |
Masochist
12.22.11 | Blink-182 was hard to choose, because all of them have them have around the same rating. The only reason I chose 'Take Off Your Pants and Jacket' instead of 'Dude Ranch' is because the former has hundreds more votes... |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | 35. the lonesome crowded west |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | also weezer blue album vs pinkerton would have been interesting |
Trebor.
12.22.11 | 2. Homogenic
3. Dude Ranch
5. For Emma
6. london calling
15. supreme clientelle
22. static age
24. doolittle
25. kezia
29. everything goes numb
32. rain dogs
34. we're only chasing safety |
anarchistfish
12.22.11 | 9: White Pony
34: Disambiguation |
Masochist
12.22.11 | Foxxxy - THAT one I already did, in the second contest. They tied at first, but The Blue Album won the tiebreaker. |
WashboardSuds
12.22.11 | 2) Post
3) Enema
16) Demon Days
31) Illusion
35) Elephant |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | i demand a recount
also i didn't realize this was something you'd done before, my bad |
Masochist
12.22.11 | No problem. Also...took out MF Doom for Modest Mouse, because no one had voted on DOOM yet (and it
coincidentally fit alphabetically). |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | lol i commented on the first list in 08 as faggor i remember now :edit: oh hey thanks man 22. the
lonesome crowded west |
omnipanzer
12.22.11 | 2. Homogenic
4. Blonde on Blonde
6. London Calling
7. Parachutes
8. Neither
9. Neither
10. Ocean Machine: Biomech
12. Fleet Foxes
13. The Colour and the Shape
16. Gorillaz
17. Our Endless Numbered Days
19. Simple Math
21. Operation: Doomsday
22. Walk Among Us
23. Slanted and Enchanted
24. Surfer Rosa
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions
27. Moving Pictures
29. Everything Goes Numb
30. The Age of Adz
31. Rain Dogs
35. White Blood Cells |
Masochist
12.22.11 | Hahaha...sorry, Omni, I switched out Doom for Modest Mouse, and then had Modest Mouse and Misfits switch places ;-) |
ZilbelPing
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
5. For Emma, Forever Ago
11. Fables From a Mayfly
13. The Colour and the Shape
16.Demon Days
20. Brother, Sister
25. Fortress
26. Fear of a Black Planet
29. Everything Goes Numb
31. The Artist in the Ambulance
34. Define the Great Line |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | sorry omni im so sorry omni |
anarchistfish
12.22.11 | you should do one for GY!BE |
Trebor.
12.22.11 | Moon & Antarctica
|
omnipanzer
12.22.11 | Correction:
The Lonesome Crowded West |
Emim
12.22.11 | 1. Alaska
2. Haven't heard either.
3. Don't like any of it.
4. Haven't listened to enough Dylan to make a judgement.
5. For Emma
6. Probably London Calling.
7. Don't care.
8. Haven't heard either.
9. White Pony ofcorz
10. Biomech.
11. Fables from a Mayfly
12. Haven't heard either.
13. The Color and the Shape
14. 13 Songs
15. Haven't heard either. I'll just leave the ones I haven't heard blank...
16.
17.
18. Don't care; hate him.
19.
20. Brother, Sister
21. Static Age
22.
23.
24. Doolittle
25. Kezia
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions...
27. 2112
28. City
29. Everything Goes Numb
30.
31. The Artist in the Ambulance
32.
33.
34. errrrgghhhh Lost in the Sound...
35. |
Masochist
12.22.11 | ...I haven't yet? Wow, didn't realize that I'd missed them in the three contests I've had so far. Well...hahaha, no more changes on this one, I'll remember it for next time (and DOOM will have his day). |
Masochist
12.22.11 | Also, NeutralThunder votes:
22. The Lonesome Crowded West |
anarchistfish
12.22.11 | I've never listened to Modest Mouse |
Masochist
12.22.11 | AnarchistFish - S'all good, just making sure you knew ;-)
Also, where are all the Metalheadz? Why does Ulver only have one single vote so far? |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | anarchist get the two albums that are competing for sure |
anarchistfish
12.22.11 | ehhh, it probably wouldn't be my kinda of music |
omnipanzer
12.22.11 | "I've never listened to Modest Mouse"
So sad. |
Trebor.
12.22.11 | yeah |
FromDaHood
12.22.11 | Take Off Your Pants and Jacket
For Emma (duh)
Rush of Blood to the Head
MBDTF
Simple Math
Whichever onee has Cowboy Dan, I think it's Lonesome Crowded
Crooked Rain
Doolittle
Somewhere in the Between
Illinoise
Illusion of Safety
Define the Great Line
Elephant I think |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | i didn't think so either
when i checked them out in 04 i was listening almost exclusively to death metal, now they're my favorite band |
LegendofPittman
12.22.11 | Colors
Homogenic
Highway 61
For Emma
Disintegration
White Pony
The Argument
Demon Days
Brother, Sister
Walk Among Us
The Lonesome Crowded West
Doolittle
Fear of a Black Planet
Hemispheres
Everything Goes Numb
Vheissu
Rain Dogs
Define the Great Line
White Blood Cells
|
kris.
12.22.11 | 1. alaska
3. self-titled
4. blood on the tracks
5. for emma
9. white pony
12. helplessness blues
13. the colour and the shape
15. supreme clientele
16. gorillaz
17. the creek drank the cradle
18. my beautiful dark twisted fantasy
19. mean everything to nothing
20. brother, sister
22. the lonesome crowded west
25. fortress
27. moving pictures
29. (oh shit this ones hard) everything goes numb
30. illinois
31. vheissu
33. bergtatt
34. disambiguation
list needs coheed and btmi! you disappiont mas |
anarchistfish
12.22.11 | ok |
ZilbelPing
12.22.11 | "I've never listened to Modest Mouse"
Dude get on that. Even if you don't like it, it doesn't hurt to try.
For example, I don't like My Bloody Valentine. Tried it but it's not for me. But at least I tried it. |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | hahah was an example really necessary zibel hahaha |
ZilbelPing
12.22.11 | Not really lol |
Masochist
12.22.11 | UhhKris - Didn't think of BTMI!, will keep them in mind next time. Coheed, however, was decided in the second contest: 'The Second Stage Turbine Blade' won out ;-) |
AsoTamaki
12.22.11 | The only ones I really care one way or the other about:
2. Vespertine
8. Disintegration
9. White Pony
13. The Colour and the Shape
27. Moving Pictures
31. Vheissu |
FearThyEvil
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
6. London Calling
9. Diamond Eyes
11. Arrows and Anchors
13. Wasting Light
18. Fantasy
21. Walk Among Us
25. Kezia
27. Moving Pictures
28. City
31. Vheissu
32. Bergatt
34. Disambiguation |
ti0n
12.22.11 | 3. Blink-182
5. For Emma
9. White Pony
12. Fleet Foxes
13. Colour
14. 13 Songs
20. Catch for us the Foxes
22. Moon
31. Artist
34. Define the great Line
|
kris.
12.22.11 | "Coheed, however, was decided in the second contest: 'The Second Stage Turbine Blade' won out ;-)"
oh ok good as long as the masses chose the right one |
Blackbelt54
12.22.11 | I'm not gonna do all of them but:
4. Blood on the Tracks
6. London Calling
7. Viva La Vida
14. The Argument
18. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
22. The Lonesome Crowded West
29. Everything Goes Numb |
MrHotMoms
12.22.11 | i like btbam |
WeepingBanana
12.22.11 | 5. For Emma
6. London Calling
9. Diamond Eyes
14. FFFFFFFFFFFFF probably The Argument. toughest choice though
15. Ironman
20. Brother, Sister
24. Surfer Rosa
25. Kezia
26. It Takes A Nation Of Millions
29. Everything Goes Numb
32. Rain Dogs
cool list homie |
danielito19
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
7. Viva La Vida
13. The Colour And The Shape
20. Brother, Sister
31. The Illusion of Safety |
lukempls
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
3. Blink 182
5. For Emma
20. brother, sister
30. Age of Adz |
Coast
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
7. Parachutes
8. Disintegration
9. White Pony
10. Biomech
11. Arrows & Anchors
13. The Colour and the Shape
27. Hemispheres
31. Vheissu |
ohfoxxxycole
12.22.11 | I can't believe how short some of these votes are - most of these are pretty high profile around here |
CrownOfMagnets
12.22.11 | You should've done one for Tool's aenima vs Lateralus |
Pentagon
12.22.11 | 3. Enema of the State
4. Highway 61
5. For Emma, Forever ago
6. London Calling
8. Disintegration
9. White Pony
12. Fleet Foxes
14. 13 Songs
16. Gorrilaz
18. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
19. Mean Everything To Nothing
21. Walk Among Us
23. Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain
24. Doolittle
29. Everything Goes Numb
35. White Blood Cells |
Blackbelt54
12.22.11 | cole: some of these I've only heard 2 out of the 3 albums, others I can't decide/don't care, etc. |
Divine
12.22.11 | 1. Don't like any of them
2. Vespertine
3. Take Off Your Pants and Jacket
4. Highway 61 Revisited
5. For Emma, Forever Ago
6. London Calling
7. A Rush of Blood To The Head
8. Pornography
9. Diamond Eyes
10. Don't know
11. Don't know, either
12. Helplessness Blues
13. Wasting Light
14. The Argument
15. ?
16. Demon Days
17. ?
18. ?
19. ?
20. ?
21. Static Age
22. The Lonesome Crowded West
23. Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain
24. Surfer Rosa
25. ?
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions...
27. Hemispheres
28. ?
29. ?
30.?
31. Don't really care
32. Bone Machine
33. Shadows of the Sun
34. Lost In The Sound of Separation (I guess)
35. White Blood Cells |
CrownOfMagnets
12.22.11 | 3. Enema
9. Diamond Eyesbr />
11. Tie
13. Self titled
27. Hemispheres
31. Vheissu.... But the real best Thrice is Alchemy Index or Major/Minor |
iFghtffyrdmns
12.22.11 | no titus andronicus, list is null/void |
Blackbelt54
12.22.11 | who likes Airing of Grievances better? |
iFghtffyrdmns
12.22.11 | can't even say one's better than the other cause they're both like 99/5
AoG has better individual songs, Monitor has a better overall album quality to it. |
iFghtffyrdmns
12.22.11 | 19: I'm Like A Virgin > Mean Everything to Nothing > Simple Math
ez. |
CrownOfMagnets
12.22.11 | that's just in order |
CrownOfMagnets
12.22.11 | that's just in order of release date, bro |
Auschwitz
12.22.11 | Wasting Light is way better. The Colour and the Shape doesnt deserve all the praise it gets. for Ulver, its between Perdition City and Shadows of the Sun |
Blackbelt54
12.22.11 | they're both amazing in their own ways but I still like the Monitor a bit better
also, I can't wait for LP3 |
swallowtales
12.22.11 | 9. White Pony
11. Fables From A Mayfly
16.Gorillaz
29.Equal |
iswimfast
12.22.11 | 1. Colors
5. For Emma
9. White Pony
11. Arrows and Anchors
13. Wasting Light
18. MBDTF
19. Mean Everything To Nothing
31. Vheissu
34. Define the Great Line |
pedroia55
12.22.11 | 24 Pixies
Surfer Rosa vs. Doolittle
not a question
|
iFghtffyrdmns
12.22.11 | "that's just in order of release date, bro"
yes, and coincidentally, also in order of awesomeness.
@Blackbelt - yeah dude stoked as fuck for number 3. |
Blackbelt54
12.22.11 | I'm not going to have high expectations cuz their last two are like impossible to top, but even if it's not as good as the others it's still gonna rule |
Masochist
12.23.11 | CrownOfMagnets - Already did Tool in contest one. 'Lateralus' won 11-5.
Pedroia55 - How do you mean? |
TomArnoldsArmpit
12.23.11 | but your list would just be obscure black metal demos that nobody has heard :( |
qwe3
12.23.11 | 1. TSC
2. Homogenic
3. S/T
4. Blood on the Tracks
5. S/T,S/T
6. London Calling
7. Viva La Vida
8. Disintegration
9. White Pony
10. Ocean Machine
11. havent heard arrows and anchors
12. Helplessness Blues
13. colorshape
14. 13 Songs altho repeater rules
15. Supreme Clientele but theyre allsoooooooo gooood
16. gorillaz
17. ......
18. mbdtf
19. ....
20. brother sister
21. cant decide
22. cant decide
23. Slanted
24. Dolittle
25. Kezia
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions
27. Moving Pictures
28. City
29. Everything Goes Numb
30. Illinois
31. Illusion of Safety
32. Swordfishtrombones
33. Bergtatt
34. they all suck
35. White Blood Cells |
AngelofDeath
12.23.11 | 1. gay
2. Vespertine
3. gay
4.
5. s/t
6. London Calling
7. gay
8. Disintegration
9.
10. OM: Biomech
11.
12. Fleet Foxes
13. TCatS
14. 13 Songs
15. Supreme Clientele
16. Gorillaz
17.
18. MBDTF
19.
20. brother, sister
21. Walk Among Us
22. gay
23.
24. Surfer Rosa
25. gay
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions
27. A Farewell to Kings (Not putting this as an option is retarded.)
28. CIty
29.
30. Age of Adz
31. gay
32. Swordfishtrombones
33. Shadows of the Sun
34. gay
35. meh |
patroneyes
12.23.11 | 5. for emma
6. london calling
7. rush
12. helplessness
14. 13 songs
22. TLCW by a smidge
23. slanted
24. surfer rosa (also by a small margin)
26. FEAR OF A BLACK FUCKIN PLANET
30. can't decide... fuck it, illinois
35. white blood cells |
TomArnoldsArmpit
12.23.11 | nah just fuckin with ya |
Masochist
12.23.11 | AngelofDeath - I chose the three highest-rated Rush albums with the most votes. I only put up to three albums because any more would probably discourage people from voting period (really, how would you be able to choose between ALL of Rush's good albums, or ALL of Metallica's good albums?)
And yes, this WAS a stealth bump. After today, voting will be closed, so be sure to get your opinions in, because when I tally the votes and you're not happy with them, I don't wanna hear any complaining about it if you didn't even vote. Fucking democracy... |
Masochist
12.23.11 | Also, I'll go ahead and throw down my votes:
1.
2. Homogenic
3. Take Off Your Pants and Jacket
4. Highway 61 Revisited
5.
6. The Clash
7. Viva La Vida
8. Pornography
9. White Pony
10. Terria
11. Fables From A Mayfly
12. Helplessness Blues
13. The Colour and the Shape
14.
15. Fishscale
16. Gorillaz
17.
18. The College Dropout
19. Mean Everything to Nothing
20. Catch For Us The Foxes
21.
22. The Moon & Antarctica
23. Slanted and Enchanted
24.
25. Scurillous
26. Apocalypse 91: The Empire Strikes Black
27.
28.
29.
30.
31. The Artist In The Ambulance
32. Rain Dogs
33. Perdition City
34. Define The Great Line
35. White Blood Cells |
Masochist
12.24.11 | Last self-bump.
VOTE NOW OR FOREVER HOLD YOUR PEACE. |
Acanthus
12.24.11 | 25 = Kezia, don't care about most of the other bands on list |
AngelofDeath
12.24.11 | "AngelofDeath - I chose the three highest-rated Rush albums with the most votes. I only put up to three albums because any more would probably discourage people from voting period (really, how would you be able to choose between ALL of Rush's good albums, or ALL of Metallica's good albums?)"
Fair enough, but all the real Rush fans know AFtK is the best album. |
qwe3
12.24.11 | lol real rush fans |
KILL
12.24.11 | problem QWE? |
qwe3
12.24.11 | idk do we have a problem pardner |
DoubtGin
12.24.11 | Colors
Post
Blink-182
Highway 61 Revisited
Bon Iver, Bon Iver
London Calling
Parachutes
Disintegration
White Pony
Ocean Machine: Biomech
Fables From a Mayfly
Helplessness Blues
Wasting Light
The Argument
Supreme Clientele
Demon Days
Our Endless Numbered Days
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Simple Math
Brother, Sister
Static Age
The Moon and Antarctica
Slanted & Enchanted
Doolittle
Kezia
It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back
Moving Pictures (lol)
City
Everything Goes Numb
Illinois
Vheissu
Rain Dogs
Perdition City
Disambiguation
Elephant |
porch
12.24.11 | 14. repeater
|
BroFro
12.25.11 | 5. Emma
9. Diamond Eyes
12. Fleet Foxes
13. tCatS
16. DD
20. Foxes
29. Numb
31. Vheissu |
discovolante
02.10.12 | 2. Post
3. Enema of the State
8. Pornography
9. White Pony
13. Colour and the Shape
15. Supreme Clientele
16. Self Titled
18. Late Registration
26. It Takes a Nation of Millions
27. Moving Pictures
28. Alien
35. Elephant |
