Proworks31
08.25.11 | I put a bit of thought into this one. |
ShadowRemains
08.25.11 | lol clearly not |
Uranium
08.25.11 | "Even though it is a coherent album'
...you obviously mean incoherent |
none
08.25.11 | who the fuck is this retard |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | I'm not saying these are the greatest albums just that they're underrated.
Quiet troll. |
none
08.25.11 | am i gonna have to take this up with ur mommy? |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | I believe so. |
none
08.25.11 | ok you'll be hearing from my attorney in 5 mins |
Deviant.
08.25.11 | "Although it might not be up to the same standard as OK Computer, or Kid A, it was and still is often over-looked by people, "
There isn't such a thing as an overlooked Radiohead album |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | ^ This is true, but in comparison.
@none. I look forward to it. |
none
08.25.11 | k get ready to ride the lightning |
Deviant.
08.25.11 | There is no "but in comparison". It came out, people listened and some just didn't like it as much |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | But that's what I mean, it's rather under-rated COMPARED to other Radiohead albums due to the fact that some people didn't like it as much, even though it's not that bad.
I see your point, and it's probably right, but meh. |
none
08.25.11 | nice try |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Thanks bub. |
none
08.25.11 | don't call me bub dipshit |
Deviant.
08.25.11 | "But that's what I mean, it's rather under-rated COMPARED to other Radiohead albums due to the fact that some people didn't like it as much, even though it's not that bad.
I see your point, and it's probably right, but meh."
Underrated and overshadowed are two different things. Underrated means that a lot of people didn't like it despite it (apparently) being just as good as any other album by said band. Overshadowed means that for whatever reason an album was overlooked (possibly by another album). If you think Amnesiac is underrated that's fine, but it definitely wasn't overshadowed. As if Radiohead fans wouldn't listen to a Radiohead album |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Well someone clearly has completed a unit subject in English.
I was kind of fusing the two here- as you can see be some of my 'supposed' ill-advised choices.
Maybe I should change the title.
Thanks. |
Deviant.
08.25.11 | And how could Ride The Lightning be overshadowed by Master Of Puppets. There's a good 2 (maybe 3?) years separating the releases; it's not like Puppets came out the next day or anything. People just remember Puppets more because it's a better album, or believe it to be |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Well it's just a more popular album, and people don't really think RTL when they think Metallica (unless they are a knowledgable fan) They would think Master of Puppets. Anyway changed the title and description so hopefully it clears a few things up. |
Uranium
08.25.11 | When I think of Metallica I only acknowledge them to Kill em All and then they no longer exist |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | I reckon in Kill em All his voice sounds retarded, but the guitar work was pretty awesome. |
FruityCatOfDoom
08.25.11 | 2 is sick. so is 3. but Ride The Lightnening isnt that underated. |
FruityCatOfDoom
08.25.11 | Kill Em All is sick as fuck. dont talk shit. |
Mordecai.
08.25.11 | proworks are you 9 or something? |
Alucard125
08.25.11 | Agree with 4, I love it. Sixpounder was one of my favourites from Hatecrew Deathroll, and this album was similar in sound. |
faux
08.25.11 | tnx for this list, i love obscure music like the metallicas |
AngelofDeath
08.25.11 | 1. Just because some people like MoP more, doesn't mean this is underrated.
2. See above.
3. Also see above.
4. Not nearly as good as their first three albums.
5. Maybe but not really among Satch fans. |
chaseguitar
08.25.11 | "tnx for this list, i love obscure music like the metallicas" hahaha |
MO
08.25.11 | Lightning destroys Puppets. |
MisterTornado
08.25.11 | at #2; an "over-shadowed" album isn't one that has 1929 ratings and a score of 3.9 |
FrankRedHot
08.25.11 | This guy might, just might, be worse than any of the metalcore/deathcore alts |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Good news everyone I have an excuse.
I'm only 13.
Hoho.
But in response to everything, have your own opinion, that's the point of lists, but atleast see I
tried to explain/backup my choices.
I'm talking about underrated AND over-shadowed, and not just about fans, but the general public.
|
FrankRedHot
08.25.11 | Not gonna say anything else other than age is not an excuse for stupidity. |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Not gonna say anything else but you don't back up your arguments. You just flame me without telling me why, because I like 'bad' music? That has nothing to do with this list. Because this list is crap? Talk about the list, not me. |
FrankRedHot
08.25.11 | It's not an argument. An argument is where I debate you. I made a statement.
Should've been pretty clear. |
Oathbreaker
08.25.11 | "who the fuck is this retard"
This made me laugh for hours for some reason. |
NigelH
08.25.11 | 2 is underrated. Ratings on this site can be a fickle way to judge an album's quality, but I think it deserves at least a 4. |
WashboardSuds
08.25.11 | I like 13 year olds |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | I like 13 year old girls that are tanned and live on beaches and feature in Zoo magazine.
Lol FrankRedHot. No matter how much you bag me I still find it funny. |
FrankRedHot
08.25.11 | "Lol FrankRedHot. No matter how much you bag me I still find it funny."
Eww bro.... what the fuck is wrong with you? |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Even that made me laugh and it was a direct insult. |
WashboardSuds
08.25.11 | who would put 13 year old girls in zoo magazine |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Just wondering, can a review that was written ages after the album was released become the featured review for that album? Or is once one chosen it is set in stone? |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | "who would put 13 year old girls in zoo magazine"
Some sick fuck. |
WashboardSuds
08.25.11 | "Just wondering, can a review that was written ages after the album was released become the featured review for that album? Or is once one chosen it is set in stone?"
I don't think so
"Some sick fuck."
oh |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Fairly shattered.
Haha. |
foreverendeared
08.25.11 | "can a review that was written ages after the album was released become the featured review for that album"
yes |
WashboardSuds
08.25.11 | I read that wrong, my mistake. thought you meant can it make the featured reviews on the front page |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | "yes"
How would you know? Does a staff member need to read it and decide it's better or more relevant? |
foreverendeared
08.25.11 | Usually staff will read it and if it's good enough yeah; otherwise, go to the Meds thread in the forums and ask them directly to flag it. |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | "dude try show no mercy or hell awaits"
those are probably more relevant, but I didn't really think of them. Should I change it? |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | "Usually staff will read it and if it's good enough yeah; otherwise, go to the Meds thread in the forums and ask them directly to flag it."
Well I don't think people would want to do that in case of embarassment/bragging.
I'm not suggesting anything anyway, just out of interest. What if the review has more pos's does that mean anything? |
Pharoh
08.25.11 | Ride the lightning > master of muppets |
foreverendeared
08.25.11 | "Well I don't think people would want to do that in case of embarassment/bragging."
At least once a day a user will ask for their review to be flagged, so no, no one really cares. |
Proworks31
08.25.11 | Oh really. I'd like personal opinon first before I asked to get one flagged though. Thanks. |
