tkxxx7
06.25.11 | Yep |
JasperrrD
06.25.11 | 1 is a great album and 2 isnt too bad. |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | 1 is an alright album and 2 is pretty bad |
Motiv3
06.25.11 | 3 sucks dick, like all of TDWP's work |
JasperrrD
06.25.11 | Ehhhh, I dont mind them two, but I think we all agree that 3 is absolutely terrible? |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | it's like ridiculously average. I think their previous work was terrible, and they have a generic sound that they just can't seem to shake, and screaming about fucking zombies and throwing car alarms into their breakdowns isn't gonna change that |
dnor
06.25.11 | 1 and 2 blow, but 3 is enjoyable only because exactly what you said, they are screaming about zombies. I like zombies. Not all generic music is bad, and not all bad music is generic. It's an enjoyable listen if you only care about the novelty of a zombie story. |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | it's a gimmick imo |
dimsim3478
06.25.11 | They may be scene, but these in particular are fairly good scene. |
FilupLees
06.25.11 | These suck. Thrice are scene too, and they are generic within the post hardcore world. People only suck their dicks here because they're one of the less unoriginal scenecore bands. |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | ^ what are you talking about |
theacademy
06.25.11 | lol @ that kid |
theacademy
06.25.11 | sputnik was so funny when 1 came out seriously |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | idk what 1 is. 2 is good, 3 has a couple of fun songs |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | thrice = total scenecore bro |
sonictheplumber2
06.25.11 | 1 and 2 are terribad
3 never heard |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | don't waste your time |
sonictheplumber2
06.25.11 | yeah dude even though I dont agree with your skin I suppose I can agree with you on these albums being shit |
PedalToTheMetal
06.25.11 | 1 - average
2 - nothing special
3 - great |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | what's great about it |
PedalToTheMetal
06.25.11 | zombies and metal.... whats not to like? |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | it's boring and gimmicky
what's not to hate |
sonictheplumber2
06.25.11 | but TDWP isnt metal, it's deathcore |
PedalToTheMetal
06.25.11 | its nothing special musically, but a very enjoyable listen imo |
sonictheplumber2
06.25.11 | nope
and 1 is like an emmure album |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | Zombie is generic but unlike their older stuff it actually has a few nice riffs and groove |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | Yeah they all suck |
Coloso
06.25.11 | Listen to Dance Gavin Dance, Emery, and A Lot Like Birds.
Talk about how scene music is ruining Sputnik.
Look like an idiot. |
PedalToTheMetal
06.25.11 | the last emery album was quite bad |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | @Coloso ALLB isn't scene they just have Travis |
Coloso
06.25.11 | Yes, that is one of the bands I mentioned... |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | get off my list |
Coloso
06.25.11 | Because you're being extremely hypocritical?... |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | how so ? |
Coloso
06.25.11 | Implying that scene music and fans caused Sputnik to "lose its way," but then listening to scene music and being a fan of scene music yourself... what am I misinterpreting here? |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | that's not what I was implying at all... if you weren't on sputnik at the times these albums were released, you wouldn't understand so stfu |
Coloso
06.25.11 | Oh, well all I saw was some scene albums listed along with a positive review for said scene album and you commenting on how Sputnikmusic sort of went down the drain once people started coming to the site that liked scene music, or when people already here began liking scene music?... that's not your complaint?
If not, then sorry I misinterpreted this list... what IS the point of it then, if not just to bash the style of music that you apparently like anyway? |
North0House2
06.25.11 | ... |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | the point of it is that when these albums were released, sputnik (or at least, large parts of sputnik) grossly overrated them. now most users look back at these times and laugh (although 3 is mostly my own opinion). thus me saying "maybe scenecore creeps up on users here, idk". I thought about adding Illuminaudio but decided against it because it seemed to be too polarizing and it would cause more users like yourself to misunderstand. as you can see, academy and sonic obviously understood |
Coloso
06.25.11 | academy just said Sputnik was funny when these came out.
sonic just said these albums were bad.
and the fact that you only put scene albums here was misleading, especially considering that you're currently deriding that AnarchisFish or whatever user for liking scene music.
So the only point of this list is about Sputnikmusic overrating albums and has nothing to do with any "scene" connotations? Ok. |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | i didn't deride him for liking scene music, i derided him for liking BTMH in general
"So the only point of this list is about Sputnikmusic overrating albums and has nothing to do with any "scene" connotations? Ok. "
exactly |
Psychopathologist
06.25.11 | needs more opeth |
botb
06.25.11 | u right |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | yeah emery and dance gavin dance suck too |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | yeah no |
botb
06.25.11 | i remember when everyone was hyping the shit out of 1 and i was just facepalming |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | "i didn't deride him for liking scene music, i derided him for liking BTMH in general"
it's funny cos when you ask people on here why they actually hate these genres loads of them end up saying "oh well actually it's more the fans that make it so bad" and then you go and make sweeping statements like this |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | "yeah no"
emery is ok from a musical standpoint, but looking from how praised they are on here...more of a case of me expecting something great I guess. and I've only heard dgd's first two albums, but they were absolutely awful, I can't defend them at all |
saucy
06.25.11 | 1 is great, 2 is bad, 3 is great.
Why? 1 can write coherent music, and not just string together a bunch of riffs and call it a song. Every breakdown fit, every riff fit. Its a decent stand out album in the genre. 3 suffers from the string of riffs plague, but its a heavier, faster improvement. |
wabbit
06.25.11 | god the site sucks when you kids aren't in school |
theacademy
06.25.11 | hahahahahahahah^ |
Winsomniac
06.25.11 | Needs moar junz |
Trebor.
06.25.11 | I never understood the appeal of 1 |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | "sweeping statements like this"
What are you talking about
"I've only heard dgd's first two albums"
listen to happiness |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | you deride me for liking BMTH and only for that therefore you'd deride everyone for liking BMTH regardless of anything else |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | that makes no sense. you're forgetting you're an idiot |
Emim
06.25.11 | "Not all generic music is bad, and not all bad music is generic."
yay, someone's using their brain. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | it makes perfect sense.
and you're forgetting that you have never met me or ever held a proper conversation with me so what could you know? |
pmmets07
06.25.11 | 1 is ok
2 is boring as fuck
3 is boring as fuck |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | "held a proper conversation with me so what could you know?"
that IS how I know |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | "listen to happiness"
yeah I've been meaning to since the primary reason I don't like dgd is because of Jonathan Mess. He sucks |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | no you're just being a typical internet warrior who assigns labels to people based on stereotypical preconceptions because you there's no way you can truly lose because you'll always have some bullshit answer to everything |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | @Crymsonblaze it's easily their best, and I know jonny isn't for everyone
"there's no way you can truly lose"
great, we agree, if not for the same reasons |
LiveByFaith
06.25.11 | 1. bored me to death after a couple listens
2. is half way good
3. is fun as hell, their best work. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | haha you just know that you will always be able to defend yourself whilst you're on the internet
if anything you're the idiot because the only reason you dislike me is because of music taste |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | I like Craig's voice though, and I have the album, I'll give it a spin sometime |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | "if anything you're the idiot because the only reason you dislike me is because of music taste"
I don't dislike you
"I like Craig's voice though, and I have the album, I'll give it a spin sometime"
he isn't on it |
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | Ahhh they changed both vocalists? Didn't know that |
Trebor.
06.25.11 | Jon Mess had lime's disease when they recorded Happiness.
|
Crymsonblaze
06.25.11 | Gotcha. I knew Mess wasn't on it but I thought Happiness is when Craig came back. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | ""if anything you're the idiot because the only reason you dislike me is because of music taste"
I don't dislike you"
you hide that really well
how about I stop commenting here and we don't bother each other anymore? |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | "we don't bother each other anymore?"
no one worthy of the ability to bother me would like BTMH
js |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | whoops, BMTH |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | so what's your motive to take every jab possible towards me?
of course, I forget that we're all subhuman idiots
also yeah fallout 3 is incredible. 101 playtime hours ftw |
MickeyPHager
06.25.11 | Have you heard BMTH's first ablum? That sucked ass. This latest one is pretty good. I hate The Word Alive so much. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | I don't like their first album |
Acanthus
06.25.11 | I love you for this list. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | >everyone
>you and txxx7
notice how I'm never the one to start the arguments |
TomArnoldsArmpit
06.25.11 | People were shitting themselves over 1 when it came out. It's not BAD, just very forgettable. |
Acanthus
06.25.11 | It was really disappointing compared to their E.P. imo, and being forgettable didn't help it any further. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | got bored of mainstream music, decided to expand my tastes
of course I still listen to that stuff but I don't really enjoy it as much as I did a couple of years ago |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | you answered pit's question
you lose |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | what is anyone doing here? |
Acanthus
06.25.11 | Being a comment whore, trying to improve my writing, getting music rec's, etc. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | "Ruining people's online experiences."
fair enough
"a lot of albums that would be completely hated by the whole site a while ago are now being embraced."
genres more so than albums |
Acanthus
06.25.11 | I suppose the core group must have changed, going from die hard Radiohead and Opeth fans to this seems like a new user issue. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | lol |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | rabbit junk
high five |
Acanthus
06.25.11 | Fuck yeah man, they've been rocking my MP3 player for quite some time now. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | what I find funny about this site is that users keep complaining about other people's musical tastes but when those people join this site, instead of trying to introduce them to your kind of music you repel them |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | complaining =/= teasing |
dixoncocks
06.25.11 | groundbreaking. |
anarchistfish
06.25.11 | this is the internet so the two blur |
YouthCat
06.25.11 | I never understood all the hype about 1, but 2 was pretty good. I still like that album.
Also, the new Color Morale album should have been on this. There were a good many people hyping the shit out of that one too. |
tkxxx7
06.25.11 | not enough people to be on the list
large amounts of people hype everything |