User
Reviews 219 Approval 95%
Soundoffs 102 News Articles 18 Band Edits + Tags 222 Album Edits 2,908
Album Ratings 5589 Objectivity 71%
Last Active 05-23-22 7:56 pm Joined 07-06-08
Review Comments 8,656
| Phil Collins: 40 Years, 10 Essentials
A career overview. | 1 | | Genesis Selling England by the Pound
Collins' fist appearances on record were with his original band, the short-lived Flaming Youth (who released one album in 1969 named Ark 2 before breaking apart), as well as playing on George Harrison's All Things Must Pass. In 1970, he auditioned for and became part of Genesis, joining for their third record Nursery Cryme. Collins became an integral part of the group?s sound, and, as such, became a major player in the progressive rock movement of the 70's. Genesis grew with each album, and Selling England was their best effort up to that point, some might even argue overall. Collins was beginning, very shyly, to sing, and both More Fool Me and the older For Absent Friends are interesting points of comparison to his later career, showing just how far he has come vocally. His skilful and precise drumming is a major appeal here, opener Dancing with the Moonlit Knight being a particularly excellent example of his skills. | 2 | | Genesis The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
The ambitious concept The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway was Genesis' final album with Peter Gabriel, whose expressive vocals gave the group its unique position in the world of prog. It was of course his very departure that fuelled the transition from Phil Collins the rock drummer to Phil Collins the hit-scoring pop singer; perhaps Phil would never have picked up the mic on his own if he hadn't been given the opportunity in Genesis, and even if he would have, the band's later sound changes were still largely defined by him. Unfortunately, he doesn't get to show his work behind the kit as impressively on The Lamb as on their previous works, Gabriel making his last Genesis record his most creatively dominant one. | 3 | | Genesis A Trick of the Tail
A lot of Genesis fans claim A Trick of the Tail to be their last great album, and it is easy to understand why. This is where Collins, after a failed series of auditions for a new lead singer, reluctantly took up the vocal spot and aimed to keep the band?s style intact, which included emulating Gabriel's vocal presence as well as storytelling ability. He gets a lot of credit for trying, because although his inferior performances on both accounts are evident, the material did turn out to be pretty great, particularly Dance on a Volcano, carrying both excellent vocals and drumming, especially considering Phil was just starting to do the former full-time. | 4 | | Brand X Unorthodox Behaviour
Brand X, an important group in the jazz fusion department, was Collins' go-to side project in which he performed some of his finest drumming. This first album arguably remains their finest, featuring a simply stunning rhythm section consisting of Collins and ex-Soft Machine bass genius Percy Jones. For proof, Nuclear Burn should suffice. | 5 | | Brand X Morrocan Roll
The second, and last Brand X album Collins played full-time drums on, only contributing sporadically to their recordings until 1982. It matches up nicely to Unorthodox Behaviour, although a lot softer and incorporating Eastern atmospheres. Phil performs a nearly indistinguishable vocal on Sun in the Night, more a mood addition than anything else, and once again focuses on what he does best. | 6 | | Genesis Seconds Out
If there was a moment during which Collins began to become really confident as a singer, this might have been it. Genesis' second live album is obviously lacking Gabriel's vocals, having been recorded after Wind and Wuthering, and also marks the final appearance of guitarist Steve Hackett (who grew frustrated with the denial of his creative input and made the band a trio consisting of Collins, keyboardist Tony Banks and bassist Mike Rutherford for the largest remainder of their career), but turned out to be an essential Genesis live release. Featuring tight performances and a new edge in the form of two drummers stepping in so Collins could focus on singing (ex-Yes/King Crimson virtuoso Bill Bruford and Frank Zappa's Chester Thompson, who would later become the band's long-time tour drummer), the sound turned out to be on at least equal grounds with their classic years. | 7 | | Phil Collins No Jacket Required
Collins finally started out his solo career in 1981 with Face Value, which, apart from the brilliant In the Air Tonight, was rather uneven. After spending some time finding his sound, really hitting it off with the unexpected hit cover You Can't Hurry Love, he suddenly started to show a significant talent in writing and performing his own pop songs, which was of course influenced by, and would in turn influence, the changing approach Genesis was taking. As his solo albums go, 1985's No Jacked Required was the one where he really hit his stride, and started his path towards becoming one of the best-selling artists of all time, spawning the 80's classics Sussudio, One More Night, Don?t Lose My Number and Take Me Home. | 8 | | Genesis Invisible Touch
The struggle within Genesis between prog and pop started as soon as they became a trio, and by 1986, pop had won the battle, an obvious result of Collins' solo success. Many have often condemned the direction the band took, and in particular this album. When you however listen to Invisible Touch as a pop album, not considering Genesis' history, it turns out to be quite excellent. The sheer catchiness and execution of it all is undeniable; the title track, Tonight, Tonight, Tonight, Land of Confusion and Throwing It All Away are all pop-era Genesis classics, and you'd be a fool for not letting yourself enjoy them. | 9 | | Phil Collins ...But Seriously
The eighties were easily Collins' finest years as far as his solo career is concerned, and he closed them with what is his second best solo record. Containing some of his best songs, particularly Something Happened on the Way to Heaven, I Wish It Would Rain Down, and of course Another Day in Paradise, ...But Seriously made this drummer-turned-singer hit master of the decade. | 10 | | Phil Collins Hits
Finally, Phil Collins' solo career, which is likely what most will ultimately remember him for, is nicely summarized in this pretty flawless collection. At the end of the day, his best songs always were the singles, and Hits doesn't skip any essentials. It even offers six songs unavailable on his albums, with the inclusion of Against All Odds and Easy Lover, the brilliant duet with Philip Bailey, being particularly pleasant. You can hate on this part of his musical profession as much as you like, but you've got to give the man credit for his abilities on both sides: there are few successful drummers-turned-songwriters, and none of them have ever matched Collins' success. Thanks for the music, Phil. | |
Nagrarok
04.12.11 | Fitting with his retirement and all that. | BigHans
04.12.11 | FUCK YES | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | I thought you would like this. | BigHans
04.12.11 | 80's era Collins/Genesis >>>> Prog/Classic era.
But you already knew that about me Nag | BigHans
04.12.11 | And Take Me Home is one of the best songs ever | Scoot
04.12.11 | Guy gets no respect at all, he was actually a pretty solid drummer. | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | ^anyone who thinks he's heard his best drumming should check out 4. | Jethro42
04.12.11 | Good job, Nag! Phil Collins is one of my all time favorite artists hands down, not as much for his innumerable love songs than for his drumming prowess of course (I'm a proghead after all). The man is up there with the greatest drummers of all time. Thanks for all, Phil. | BigHans
04.12.11 | SO TAKE A LOOK AT MEEEEEEEEEEEE NOW
THERES JUST AN EMPTY SPACE | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | 'not as much for his innumerable love songs than for his drumming prowess of course'
Hehe, of course. I'm afraid that despite my efforts we've had it with the comments now that you and Hans passed by. | BigHans
04.12.11 | Yeah the three people that would comment on this heavily are already accounted for, lol. | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | ^Jethro loves his prog years, you love his pop years, I love them both. | Jethro42
04.12.11 | Nagrarok, stay away from BigHans, he has a bad influence on you LOL | LepreCon
04.12.11 | List is ace, Nag, and his work on Peter Gabriel's third solo album deserves an honourable mention too imo ;) | Jethro42
04.12.11 | Hans, have you ever listened to 'Trick of the Tail', or 'Seconds Out'? | LegendofPittman
04.12.11 | I had never heard of Brand X until now. I will check it out, especially the fact that I have always thought Collins was a phenomenal drummer. | Jethro42
04.12.11 | ''List is ace, Nag, and his work on Peter Gabriel's third solo album deserves an honourable mention too''
Ya right, LepreCon. While we're on it, I'd also mention his collaborations onto Hackett's solo albums. | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | 'Nagrarok, stay away from BigHans, he has a bad influence on you LOL'
I grew up with pop-era Genesis and Collins' solo hits so I loved it all long before, just be glad I actually grew to like their prog era, haha.
'List is ace, Nag, and his work on Peter Gabriel's third solo album deserves an honourable mention too imo ;)'
Thanks a bunch Conor, just now I was thinking that it might be you who could also still comment, lol. I'm actually terribly unfamiliar with Gabriel's solo career except for So, been meaning to do something about that for some time. | Emim
04.12.11 | Awwwwh, no mention of Tarzan :(
Great list though, Nag. The man is a legend. | Titan50
04.12.11 | Haven't listened to much Genesis or Collins, but Mama, Land Of Confusion and In The Air Tonight fucking slay | Nagrarok
04.12.11 | Thanks Em, of course Tarzan deserves an honourable mention. | Jethro42
04.12.11 | One of the very 1st album I bought was 'And then There were Three' as it came out (1978). Then I quickly
bought 'Foxtrot' and I felt in love with it (and soon the classic prog in general) couple days after. What makes it all special is the Gabriel's departure done like only 3 or 4 years before that. Jeez, time fliiiiies!!!
| LepreCon
04.12.11 | "Thanks a bunch Conor, just now I was thinking that it might be you who could also still comment, lol. I'm actually terribly unfamiliar with Gabriel's solo career except for So, been meaning to do something about that for some time."
Yeah, my activity on this site is at an all time low this past few months, EXTREMELY busy with college work, but I'll have a breather when this week is up. As for Gabriel's solo work, you've really been missing out, especially his first three albums. Quite a bit different from his work with Genesis but if I can like them, you probably would as well, only not as much as I do ;) | mandan
03.24.13 | Never even knew about Brand X, might want to try it. | bigguytoo9
06.24.19 | the BRAND X material is fucking awesome, heard it years ago |
|