fr33convict
02.26.11 | idk why i've put off listening to these guys so much but damn they rule. |
Defeater
02.26.11 | sadly, I've really grown distant from this band. |
fr33convict
02.26.11 | why so? |
North0House
02.26.11 | I must agree that I like 1 the best. |
AnotherBrick
02.26.11 | 2, 6, and voyage 34 are the best. then deadwing, lightbulb sun, stupid dream, THEN in absentia |
Defeater
02.26.11 | I never feel like listening to their material, and when I try I usually turn it off a few songs in. It was one of my first "branching out" bands I tried when I started here in 2007, but the enjoyment has fled. |
Sowing
02.26.11 | everytime i listen to these guys im like WHOAH FUCK THEYRE GOOD then i never listen to them again |
UnnamedOcean
02.26.11 | I was just never able to get into Porcupine Tree. They feel too sterile and stereotypical prog to me. It's just not organic enough I guess. Idk maybe I should download Absentia and give them another try. |
fr33convict
02.26.11 | I torrented their whole discog because I was going to bed and wanted to have it the next day and it came with a bunch of radio versions and alternate takes and about 5 duplicates of every song. deleting them all was a pain. |
iSkane
02.26.11 | Great list, my favorite band. Although my list would be:
1. Fear of a Blank Planet
2. Stupid Dream
3. Lightbulb Sun
4. In Absentia
5. Deadwing
6. Signify
7. The Sky Moves Sideways
8. Up the Downstair
9. The Incident
10. On the Sunday of Life... |
kangaroopoo
02.26.11 | Got into them big in 07 with foabp and like you fr33 I got their whole discog. In Abs + Dwing in my top 3 with foabp. I rec getting Staircase Infinities EP which also appears on the bonus version of Up The Downstair. |
InFiction
02.26.11 | everytime i listen to these guys im like WHOAH FUCK THEYRE GOOD then i never listen to them again [2]
Yeah, same boat. |
Masochist
02.26.11 | #'s 1-4 are too close to call for me; I can't figure out which one I like more. I think 'Deadwing' might have the edge for the top spot, but even that's not set in stone.
All I know is that I adore this band. I've been listening to them for a good few years, and I hope they never wear off or get dull. |
Piglet
02.26.11 | They are the modern Pink Floyd to me. |
Dis_Con_Nec_Ted
02.26.11 | If 5 would switch with 6, the top 5 would be quite decent to say the least ;)
Just revisiting the band's discography again since forever so this makes me happy.
|
tiesthatbind
02.26.11 | Yeah, the first time listened to Deadwing it blew me away so I immediately downloaded their
discography. I actually agree with this ranking almost exactly, I would just switch 8 and 9. |
tiesthatbind
02.26.11 | *first time I listened |
