Scoot: Elliott Smith Ranked

Scoot 02.13.11	1 and 2 are interchangeable depending on mood
acorncheese 02.13.11	There's really no complaining about any order. Here's mine: New Moon XO Either/Or Figure 8 S/T Roman Candle Basement
acorncheese 02.13.11	New Moon's pretty much my favorite because it has the most songs/variety. Also, New Disaster is probably my favorite song of his.
Aids 02.13.11	I clicked ready to bring the pain if Either/Or wasn't #1. pain bringing averted.
Scoot 02.13.11	nah man either/or is generally my favorite but xo has its days
Aids 02.13.11	so you wanna buy that extra gy!be ticket I have?
Scoot 02.13.11	i'm dead broke man haha otherwise i would
InFiction 02.13.11	I respectfully disagree, but it's a tough choice considering all of his material is incredible.
mallen- 02.13.11	really can't decide depending on the day. figure 8 has been my favorite (yeah), but either/or has been close.
Sowing 02.13.11	3 and 5 have always been my faves
mallen- 02.13.11	either way, he's the best late night artist of all-time
Scoot 02.13.11	oh totally 2:45 is a mainstay
Pizza 02.13.11	1-4 are interchangeable depending on the day. i like new moon more than figure 8 as well but they are really close
couldwinarabbit 02.13.11	3 and 5 have always been my faves [2] but ya s'all great.
Chrisjon89 02.13.11	I don't have 3 and 4 but I pretty much agree otherwise
Scoot 02.13.11	get them, they rule
Chrisjon89 02.13.11	They're on the 'to get' list, somewhere in between a billion other albums lol. But I always come back to Either/Or the most out of what I have.
Scoot 02.13.11	yeah, it's the soundtrack to an all nighter for me
couldwinarabbit 02.13.11	@chris get 3 it is by far his best work.
Chrisjon89 02.13.11	It's pre Either/Or, so mostly acoustic based songs done on 4 tracks?
DinoX 02.13.11	I've only heard Either/Or but it is pretty grand. Also hi neighbour
chaseguitar 02.13.11	imo xo is pretty overrated compared to the rest. sweet adeline, tomorrow tomorrow, waltz #2, independence day, and i didn't understand are all fucking incredible, but the rest isn't as good as his other material. i don't know. that being said, s/t either/or new moon roman candle xo figure 8 basement honestly everything is so good though.
MO 02.13.11	haven't listened to much Elliot Smith...definately been meaning to
Scoot 02.13.11	get on it, i made the same mistake waltz #2 is one of his best songs
CrisStyles 02.13.11	I prefer XO to Either/Or but I haven't heard a lot of his other stuff yet.
Scoot 02.13.11	I love the s/t a lot
myhigherpie 02.13.11	I've been listening to New Moon more than anything else lately. I used to prefer XO over either/or but that's pretty much changed.
Scoot 02.13.11	well Either/Or is regarded by most as his magnum opus, but XO has a lighter mood to it that can suit a happier day
whywontyoudie 02.13.11	such a great man.