Strider
10.25.10 | 12 is so fucked up, only half the song! |
Crymsonblaze
10.25.10 | I highly disagree with 3 and 11 but otherwise pretty solid. |
Strider
10.25.10 | do you see weaker than 3 in that album? except probably for Disposable Heroes, but that song is one awesome thrash fest with a bad ass solo. |
NeroCorleone80
10.25.10 | 4 is one of the best on AJFA. I agree with 2, 3 and 5 though |
Willie
10.25.10 | I agree with the first three, but also think that 4 is one of the best on AJFA ("Harvester of Sorrow" is the worst). For five I'd have to go with "Don't Tread on Me". After that the albums are just a blur. |
Strider
10.25.10 | I rock a lot on don't tread on me but yeah it was a close call for the weakest track. Eye of the Beholder is the one I listen to the least actually, I don't know, the singing is really bad on that one IMO |
Emim
10.25.10 | HARVESTER
OF
SORRRRRROOOOW |
LepreCon
10.25.10 | 1. Phantom Lord (pretty much a filler song, JITF is great)
2. Escape (yeah gotta agree there)
3. Leper Messiah (not bad but worse than TTTSNB)
4. Frayed Ends of Sanity (just plain boring after the intro, EOTB is cool)
5. Holier Than Thou (pure crap, face it, though only half the album is any good anyway)
6. 2x4 (wtf is up with the solo? Mama Said is cool just not Metallica)
7. Ronnie (just cheesy long and boring but so is most of the album)
8. Tuesday's Gone (an insult to Skynyrd)
9. Bleeding Me (not bad just really didn't belong on this album)
10. Invisible Kid (Metallica's worst song ever)
11. Suicide and Redemption (overlong and uninteresting, ALYL is awesome man wtf?)
As for the Live Shit version of MoP, yeah it's very disappointing all right |
Strider
10.25.10 | LepreCon, Ronnie is on Load not reload lol. |
kangaroopoo
10.25.10 | really disagree with 4,5,8,12; really don't dislike any 1st 4.
-motorbreath
-trapped under ice
-the thing that should not be
-frayed ends of sanity
-struggle within (resembles one of their covers too much)
-(loads of poo + St. Anger) – too much crap to count
-(dm) – unforgiven III
*(live shit seattle show anyway = all pos’d) – love the ‘to live is to die’ intro to MoP and the sick mosh pit at the intro to ‘for whom the bell tolls’ |
awhiteguy
10.25.10 | I thought this list was going to be much longer. |
Strider
10.25.10 | the seattle show is bad ass. I don't even hate any of these songs, except for better than you |
FadeToBlack
10.25.10 | no
yes
yes
no
yes
dont care |
TheBloodTypo
10.25.10 | Man, all of 10 is the weakest track. Album blows. |
Strider
10.25.10 | c'mon, Frantic, St Anger and The Unnamed feeling are awesome. |
kangaroopoo
10.25.10 | St. Anger is only track I like off that album
frantic tic tic toc ... doesn't go too well around here |
Strider
10.25.10 | ^Frantic tic tic tic tic tic toc, not Frantic tic tic toc. |
kangaroopoo
10.25.10 | yeah...it's been a while! |
awhiteguy
10.25.10 | Seriously, who gives a shit how the song goes? It's terrible no matter which way you put it. |
Edwin
10.25.10 | LepreCon pretty much said all that needs to be said. |
TheSpirit
10.25.10 | wtf "Mama Said" rules |
BigHans
10.25.10 | This calls for the Metallica Authoritys opinion:
Kill: Phantom Lord
Lightning: Escape
Puppets: Thing That Should Not Be
Justice: Eye of the Beholder
Black: Either Don't Tread On Me or Struggle Within
Load: Probably The Cure
ReLoad: alot. Carpe Diem, Devils Dance, and Memory Remains
Garage: Agree
S & M: Agree
St. Anger: cant pick, entire 2nd half sucks tremendously
Magnetic: Suicide and Redemption
Live Shit: None |
fr33convict
10.25.10 | 10's weakest tracks are Purify and All Within My Hands IMO. |
Strider
10.25.10 | I was waiting for you to comment Hans. for kill, jump in the fire has a cool riff, but fails everywhere else imo. Struggle within is bad ass. I was hesitating between the cure and mama said (Idk, I'm really not feeling that one). those are the good ones on Reload. and Suicide and redemption's middle section is really awesome. |
Strider
10.25.10 | as for st anger, a lot of the songs are bad, but I think this one is utterly forgettable. |
BigHans
10.25.10 | The only "good" songs on Reload are Unforgiven 2 (stretching it), Low Mans Lyric (stretching it), Fixxxer, and Prince Charming. The rest is God-Awful |
FadeToBlack
10.25.10 | do you know what the worst metallica song is overral?????????
all of them |
Strider
10.25.10 | coming from a user who's name is FadeToBlack, it sounds a bit stupid.
Oh, I only don't like Better Than You, Slither and Attitude, the rest is fine to great. |
FadeToBlack
10.25.10 | yah cos usernames are sooooooooooo important and u should be judged based on it
im guessing thats why u changed yours...? |
BigHans
10.25.10 | What was his old name? |
Strider
10.25.10 | nope, but I don't get why you would take you username from a song, from a band you "don't like". I agreed that my former username sucked a bit (I add a bit because Kirk Hammett rules), and took this one. |
FadeToBlack
10.25.10 | hmm the fact that u assume i named myself after a metallica song says more about you than it does me js |
BigHans
10.25.10 | Fade, dont lie |
Strider
10.25.10 | @Hans, my old name was KirkHammett714, I changed it to Strider because I was getting some crap, and I thought too it was a bit lame (not that I don't like Kirk) |
BigHans
10.25.10 | ah that makes sense |
Irving
10.25.10 | For 11 it really should be The Unforgiven III... |
Strider
10.25.10 | nope, that heavy riff and the solo takes it immediately out of the list |
Strider
10.25.10 | Also, for 11, I think The Judas Kiss deserves to be the weakest, I mean it's great, but it doesn't go anywhere actually, unlike that was just your life who does actually try to get back to that 80's style, but managing to stay fresh. |