mechatanner
10.07.10 | This is my first list. there is not too much of an actual order here.. just some of the top's. I did leave off Sum 41, but i thought they stayed pretty under the radar after Chuck's fun faded. |
Mysteryskater2012
10.07.10 | fail |
cvlts
10.07.10 | only shit here that truly sucks is 2 and 5. |
BallsToTheWall
10.07.10 | Love 5 always will, I dont care. |
PanasonicYouth
10.07.10 | 3 is amazing sooo |
BigHans
10.07.10 | 5 has song underrated songs that never hit radio. Its their singles that were horrible. |
Jesuslaves
10.07.10 | The River's a decent song.
But Fall Out Boy and Blink 182 are so. fucking. bad. |
BigHans
10.07.10 | 1 and 2 are by far the worst on here |
geng
10.07.10 | 1 and 3 are ok. 5 is atrocious. |
pizzamachine
10.07.10 | I hate all pop punk so... [2] |
Phideaux
10.07.10 | I actually like dashboard. People hate on pop punk too much. |
Jesuslaves
10.07.10 | or maybe pop punk just blows ass. |
Emim
10.07.10 | GAIZ, PARAMORE ISN'T POP-PUNK |
Jesuslaves
10.07.10 | i also like motley crue. |
Emim
10.07.10 | Ha ha, fair enough, andcas.
And slaves is more of a thrash guy. I'm of the mind however that every genre has some good music in it. |
demigod!
10.07.10 | i used to play blink-182 religiously, but not so much anymore. i still like their first 2 albums though, admittedly |
Crymsonblaze
10.07.10 | 4 rules hard. |
mechatanner
10.07.10 | Ha see, lookin through the comments (which popped up rather quick..) everyone has their favorite, and then everyone has the one they hate.
I despise dashboard with all my heart. i don't know why precisely, but everything i've heard(yea i havent heard their first 2) makes me want to rage-punt a midget. |
AllTheWayKaye
10.07.10 | these are some of my faves. like 4 eva |
Emim
10.07.10 | "Ha see, lookin through the comments (which popped up rather quick..) everyone has their favorite, and then everyone has the one they hate.
I despise dashboard with all my heart. i don't know why precisely, but everything i've heard(yea i havent heard their first 2) makes me want to rage-punt a midget."
Actually I hate all of these. Only FoB has any semi-decent music. |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.07.10 | Dashboard are ok, if a little limp-wristed. Blink are great and FoB rule. |
AllTheWayKaye
10.07.10 | BLink are super great! |
ElectricAmber
10.07.10 | yes what's wrong with pop-punk? I love Fall Out Boy and especially the first two Dashboard cds! |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.07.10 | Super great indeed |
AllTheWayKaye
10.07.10 | Hi Amber! whasssssssssup cheetah?? |
ElectricAmber
10.07.10 | hey girl! miss me much? :) |
AllTheWayKaye
10.07.10 | yeah, didnt see you much in the halls today :(:( |
ElectricAmber
10.07.10 | hey now, hey now, you know where to find me :O |
Phideaux
10.07.10 | You can't just say pop punk sucks. Generalizing like that about an entire genre is just retarded. |
musicwithak
10.08.10 | dude this is way lame. |
Athom
10.08.10 | get some saves the day, get up kids, and northstar STAT! |
Ire
10.08.10 | 1 and 3 are great |
Asiatic667
10.08.10 | Fall Out Boy are great fun, nothing more, nothing less. Infinity On High was pop gold |
FrostbiteOblivion
10.08.10 | no MXPX or Reliant K?!?!?!?! |
heavenpraysed
10.08.10 | Lil'd |
Asiatic667
10.08.10 | hey Frostbite, don't bring christian into this, lol |
FrostbiteOblivion
10.08.10 | im talking about the music, their religion is irrelevant to their musical skill. They suck donkey balls |
Asiatic667
10.08.10 | Lol chill. |
FrostbiteOblivion
10.08.10 | how bout pop-mosh? lulz. |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | andcas made a good point, Pop punk has too many different areas to cover. I mean shit like Four Year Strong and Set Your Goals are a whole nother story. Then there's the ultra lame Boys Like Girls. Then the strange shit they threw in as pop punk because it didn't fit anywhere else (Say Anything!) |
literalsurrealist
10.08.10 | Are you talking about the terrible mainstream stuff, or the more obscure pop-punk like Superchunk or Lemuria? Because I will defend the latter to the death. |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | Well the mainstream(as in what i have up there^) i hate, but FOB and Blink will always be good for a listen.
Now the obscure stuff i honestly haven't gotten into much (mostly because i never have known many who have) other than i guess Say Anything, i mean their obscure right? |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | mech: not at all. no.
listen to
Northstar - Pollyanna
The Get Up Kids - 4 Min Mile
Descendents - Milo Goes to College
Park - It Won't Snow Where You're Going
Saves the Day - Stay What You Are
The Starting Line - Say It Like You Mean It
Bad Astronaut - Houston: We Have A Drinking Problem
The Thermals, The Body, The Blood, The Machine
The Early November - The Room's Too Cold
The Menzingers - Chamberlain Waits
The Gaslight Anthem - Sink or Swim
Nofx - Punk in Drublic
Gatsby's American Dream - Volcano
people really need to stop talking shit on genres they haven't properly heard. I don't know all that much about pop-punk, but there's more to it than blink-182. |
tapitforever
10.08.10 | hellz yea fall out boy |
Fapper
10.08.10 | 3 isn't very hated |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | pop punk is and always will be my favorite. partially because it covers a huge area.
And yea i was wondering if thats the type you were talking about.
Other than i thought NoFX was more skate punk(as in almost no pop but a lot o punk) and The Starting Line isn't very obscure.. they aren't highly circulated, but pretty mainstream sound.
the rest of the list is pretty sick though.. im going to be listening to a lot o that shit when i get home. |
Motiv3
10.08.10 | where the hell are mcr on this list? they are more hated than all these bands |
UnnamedOcean
10.08.10 | Meh pop punk.. Not my cup of tea. |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | have you heard pop-punk? |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | andcas: i actually haven't listened to much Man Overboard. i got into this whole thing like 3 years back, before that it was all rap. Now im finally getting into shit like Say Anything, Gatsby's, Brand New, ect.. |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | NO MCR is not pop-punk at all! they are a mix of Alt Rock, Emo and a bit of Punk.
And yes, they started out extreme emo. do not deny it. |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | mech: please don't refer to MCR as emo. ever. please. it's 100% incorrect and off-base. I hate to be a dick about genres, but labeling music as 'emo' based on what 14 year-old girls perpetuate really grinds my gears. Ugh you even added 'extreme'... I can't take this. |
botb
10.08.10 | 3 rules |
Slum
10.08.10 | They're pop-punk or alternative at best. Emo has never been applicable to them. |
pmmets07
10.08.10 | these (besides blink 182) all have a reason to be hated |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | dude- "Emo (pronounced /ˈiːmoʊ/) is a style of rock music typically characterized by melodic musicianship and expressive, often confessional lyrics."
sound like MCR? the lyric part, of course. and their lyric style is VERY emo: emotional, often about the darker side to life and its hardships.
Ok Fallout Boy is extremely clever, but listen to their first album and then second, huge difference because they switched songwriters from Patrick to Pete. |
Slum
10.08.10 | Go to Sea's 'Emo Bible' list and listen to some albums on there and you'll see the difference |
Slum
10.08.10 | http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=313022&listid=50082 I even linked it, I'm such a gentleman. |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | no no no no no emo music is a specific genre that originated from punk and hardcore in the late 80's and early 90's. I
have no idea where you got that "definition" but I assure you, in the context of a serious musical discussion, it's really
very dumbwrong. EDIT: Oh man Slum's got my back, thanks babe |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | ok you do have me there, i have to admit. touché mr.anemone. you win again. |
BigTuna
10.08.10 | he will win always if you talk about emo/screamo with him mechatanner |
mechatanner
10.08.10 | See now i think i honestly only know about 8 bands off that list, have heard maybe five more, and the rest is a complete loss. time for tanner to learn some musics. |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | one day that emo-list will be referenced in every single list posted. I can then die peacefully. |
LepreCon
10.08.10 | Pop Punk is ghey in general |
SeaAnemone
10.08.10 | LepreCon you've never heard good pop-punk so stop talking about bad pop-punk and thinking you speak for all pop-punk. |
Motiv3
10.08.10 | mechatanner: well that just proves to me u know nothing about genres, they have no alternative influence whatsoever and they arent even close to emo, you need to learn what real emo is before trying to correct me. They are pop-punk, pure and simple. |
Emim
10.08.10 | MCR is super emo. |
Emim
10.08.10 | Na na na na na na (na na na na na) |
dimsim3478
10.10.10 | Dude, this list is pretty good. I personally love pop-punk (but I also love everything else, so don't hate me), and I totally agree with most of your comments. |
bab808
10.11.10 | blink 182 is the shit.... and FoB's first two albums are great |
Douglas
10.11.10 | 1 rules. |
bab808
10.12.10 | if you count coheed's first two albums that's some amazing pop-punk right there |
tapitforever
10.12.10 | 2 sucks dick |
tapitforever
10.12.10 | correction, 2 sucks 5's dick and vice-versa |
mechatanner
10.12.10 | I really did not think Coheed was pop-punk.. |
AnotherBrick
10.12.10 | I just hate it all |
theacademy
10.12.10 | i like my chemical romance |
mechatanner
10.15.10 | theacademy- yea i liked them when they first came out (and the live version of their first album isn't bad) but now i hate em. HATE EM. i personally think they should have kept the drugs.. at least it made them interesting little emo kids. |
seifer
10.15.10 | all of them suck |
qwe3
10.15.10 | nah blink rules |
newjunkaesthetic93
10.20.10 | I love blink, the rest of them I lean more towards the hate side. |
