NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | I find one to be underrated. |
TheSpirit
09.01.10 | agree |
Idnuf
09.01.10 | You kiddin' me? III is the underrated one. The first one is pretty boring with a few exceptions. |
JamieTwort
09.01.10 | Mine would be: 3, 2, 1, 4... I think. |
climactic
09.01.10 | Surprised to not see IV as #1. Good list |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | HoH, IV, and Physical Graffiti are probably my favorite Zep albums
II is really close though |
LepreCon
09.01.10 | IV
II
I
III |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | I just love 1 and IV though, sooooo good. Dont know what my fave Zep album is overall though |
shindip
09.01.10 | all fuckin great |
Athom
09.01.10 | III is my favorite. I is just a covers album. |
shindip
09.01.10 | First 4>last 4 pretty obvious |
patroneyes
09.01.10 | two is the best |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | yeah for real, early zep forever |
SpottedTrout
09.01.10 | II, III, VI, Houses of the Holy, Physical Graffiti, I, Presence, In Through The Out Door. |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | 1 is definitely better than 3 |
shindip
09.01.10 | Presence is the worst IMO |
IAJP
09.01.10 | IMO:
3, 4, 1, 2. used to love 1, still do. 2 has never grabbed me all that much |
SpottedTrout
09.01.10 | They're all so close, its hard to compare. |
Athom
09.01.10 | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0lm199xkZEI |
SpottedTrout
09.01.10 | haha, thats fucking great. |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | link is epic win |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | 3 is a great rock album but its not on the level of 4 and 1 imo. 1 just grabs with it's bluesy rawness....its got a great instrumental, its consistent, its got my fave zeppelin song |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | dazed and confused? |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | that's mine, at least |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | yeah dazed and confused. Im gonna rank All the Zeppelin self titled later too. Dazed, How Many, Communication, Babe Im gonna Leave, all classics. The songs on Zeppelin 1 are just so....fitting. They work better than those on 2 and 3 |
BigHans
09.01.10 | Proggy, you're wrong BRAH. 1 isn't within a mile of IV and II, and even III beats it. |
Athom
09.01.10 | "...Jimmy Page, the greatest thief of American black music who ever walked the Earth" - Homer Jay Simpson |
ShadowRemains
09.01.10 | ^...i was waiting for that quote |
Nagrarok
09.01.10 | II and IV are easily the best here, though I never really dug III either, except for Immigrant Song and Since I've Been Loving You. I has got some average moments (Your Time is Gonna Come), but Communication Breakdown is one of the best songs they ever did. |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | redsky beat me to it |
ConsiderPhlebas
09.01.10 | Who did they take stuff from? |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | Jake Holmes, for one.
but pretty much the entire first Zeppelin record (and a good portion of II) were just re-writes of old Delta River Blues songs |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | IV could be better than I I dont know.....im still listening a lot. Hadn't listened to Zeppelin in a while, oh and @Hans, even though my opinion of which is the best of the s/t's, 3 is definitely the worst. Listen to 1 again. |
ConsiderPhlebas
09.01.10 | Have to agree with Neutral on this one |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | really though, Houses of the Holy is where it's at |
Athom
09.01.10 | if you don't like Gallows Pole you should stop listening to music. simple as that |
NeutralThunder12
09.01.10 | actually I remember Physical Grafitti being my favorite overall, but I definitely prefer early zep over late zep overall. ill have top listen to Grafitti and Houses again though |
MUNGOLOID
09.01.10 | 1 is in no way underrated but even then, it still has its flaws. |
WeepingBanana
09.01.10 | 1
4
2
3 |
LegendofPittman
09.01.10 | IV
HoH
II = III = PG
I
P
ITtOD |
LegendofPittman
09.01.10 | ^ oh btw, IV and HoH switch for me depending on my mood. |
patroneyes
09.01.10 | mungo has a point. i know many people who have raging boners for 1, so i think it gets the credit that should be coming to it. |
Ire
09.01.10 | 2
3
4 = 1
RAMBLE ONNNN |