Inveigh
09.01.10 | there have been a lot of thrash bands releasing "comeback albums" in the last few years |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | and grunge |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | Alice in Chains and Pearl Jam... who else? |
climactic
09.01.10 | Death Magnetic? I mean it wasn't great but was a good comeback |
Gmork89
09.01.10 | Inveigh just made things awkward... |
shindip
09.01.10 | High Hopes is fucking amazing |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | Alice in Chains and Pearl Jam... who else?
AiC, Pearl Jam, Stone Temple Pilots, and Soundgarden is working on an album now.
stick that in your pipe and smoke it |
Gmork89
09.01.10 | Owned |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | I thought comeback albums were supposed to be good. STP's newest doesn't qualify, and PJ's barely does.
Soundgarden's not being out yet kinda prevents it from being in the discussion, seeing as how I doubt it ever actually comes out. So you've got AiC, and Pearl Jam sorta. compared with:
Death Magnetic
Endgame/United Abominations
Christ Illusion
The Formation of Damnation
Ironbound |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | Christ Illusion sucked and so did DM
so you got endgame and the other 2 |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | Christ Illusion ruled, it's probably a top 5 Slayer album
Death Magnetic ruled too
and even if you don't count those two, last time I checked my original comment was "AiC, PJ and who else?" which has yet to be proven false... |
AngelofDeath
09.01.10 | I'll take Maniac's side on this one. Christ Illusion and Death Magnetic blew chunks.
3 is way awesome though. |
Inveigh
09.01.10 | lol the question isn't whether they blew chunks or not, I just said a lot of thrash bands released comeback albums in the last few years and he said grunge too. I said AiC, PJ and who else? he gave me a shitty STP album and one that hasn't even been announced, but apparently that means I got "owned" according to Gmork
lol |
Maniac!
09.01.10 | I was more in the mindset of that the genre was coming back.. less as much about the quality. Quality aside, grunge, numetal, and thrash are coming back |
Dryden
09.01.10 | ya
|
Inveigh
09.01.10 | oh, well then yeah agreed edit: actually, I'd say thrash already came back, but the 90s (grunge and nu-metal) are on their way. 80s retro thing's been going on for awhile |
JamieTwort
09.01.10 | This list was originally supposed to be called "Reunion Albums" hence the absence of most of the said Thrash albums as the bands never actually split up. 2 and 4 are both reunion albums as both bands split up and reformed to record the featured albums. 1 and 3 are reunion albums due to a classic line-up reuniting and 5 is just a dig that could be classed as a comeback album. The reason i changed the title is because Sputnik would not let me write the word "reunion" as a list title for some retarded reason. |
JamieTwort
09.01.10 | I've edited in an explanation, which hopefully makes this list make more sense. |
AnotherBrick
09.01.10 | good to see 5 on here but i wouldnt call momentary mediocre |
taroo
09.01.10 | i liked momentary... surely not there best work, but like Brick, I wouldn't call it mediocre. |
JamieTwort
09.01.10 | Maybe I was a little harsh. |
elephantREVOLUTION
09.01.10 | brave new world |
JamieTwort
09.01.10 | Ah yes the return of Bruce! |
elephantREVOLUTION
09.01.10 | and one of maiden's best albums |
Curse.
09.01.10 | Formation of Damnation is the best thrash comeback album. Hands down. |
Nagrarok
09.01.10 | I agree with the descriptions of 1,3 and 5. |
EVedder27
09.01.10 | with you on 5 |
Gmork89
09.01.10 | I say, Black Gives Way to Blue is the best comeback ever. |
Zizzer
09.01.10 | I clicked this looking for Brave New World lol |
Mordecai.
09.02.10 | gross list |
eternium
09.02.10 | Alice in Chains - Black Gives Way to Blue
Iron Maiden - Brave New World
Machine Head - The Blackening
Harvey Milk - Life... the Best Game in Town
Cynic - Traced in Air
Fear Factory - Mechanize
Will laugh if anyone mentions Recovery or Death Magnetic. |
Gmork89
09.02.10 | Death Magnetic= great |
DrGunther
09.02.10 | What makes DM a comeback other than the fact it took 5 years since the last one until it was released? St. Anger was more of a comeback album (Hetfield's rehab, band on hiatus etc.), bad as it is. |
DinoX
09.02.10 | Bush is also coming out with a comeback album |
FruityCatOfDoom
09.05.10 | BUSH. |
Sheeple9000
09.05.10 | CREED may also be coming out with a comeback album . |
Maniac!
09.05.10 | I say, Black Gives Way to Blue is the best comeback ever. [2]
Endgame was really really awesome too |