NeutralThunder12
07.20.10 | this is how most would rank them, so this is probably the first time I've ever agreed with the popular ranking opinion. 2 and 3 rotate; 2 is the most inconsistent of the top 3, but I love the energetic rock vibe that isn't present on Boxer or Violet, but Violet is more consistent and definitely more mature. |
tinkrbel
07.20.10 | list is wrong
2 should b 1 |
couldwinarabbit
07.20.10 | list is wrong
2 should b 1 [2] |
Wildcatforever
07.20.10 | 1-3 are so close at this point for me, Alligator only has a slight edge |
Slipping Away
07.20.10 | for me its boxer>HV>alligator but they're all great |
Zizzer
07.20.10 | What's inconsistent about Alligator? Half the songs are favorites of mine, and the rest are still awesome. |
Enotron
07.20.10 | only heard the first three, but its about right |
Zizzer
07.20.10 | And you made the exact same list a month ago... |
couldwinarabbit
07.20.10 | Alligator gets top spot as Mr. November, Geese of Beverly Road and Abel are the band's 3 best songs.
High Violet is really growing on me though, it might get 2nd place soon. |
Zizzer
07.20.10 | I think Boxer is most people's favorite, but the Alligator supporters seem the most cult-ish lol |
