AnotherBrick
07.17.10 | pink floyd |
Maniac!
07.17.10 | opeth |
Counterf3it
07.17.10 | lolbrick |
Enotron
07.17.10 | teeh beatlez |
Lambda
07.17.10 | Nice try people ;) |
Enotron
07.17.10 | animal collective
its kind of hilarious that elliot smith is grouped with them though |
eternium
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith.
If AC wins, I'm going to vomit and shit at the same time. |
Counterf3it
07.17.10 | FUCK ANIMAL COLLECTIVE.
My vote is for Elliot Smith |
AnotherBrick
07.17.10 | just ignore everyone saying you should replace animal collective with Bon Iver
i'm going with Elliott |
TrvthBeTold
07.17.10 | Hipster shit. |
ShadowAmI
07.17.10 | fuck fuck fuck hard round. probably elliott smith since nmh and ac have both kind of grown off me recently. |
Enotron
07.17.10 | FUCK ANIMAL COLLECTIVE, THEY ARE OBVIOUSLY A HIPSTER SCHEME AND PURPOSELY SCREWING US OVER WITH THEIR HIPSTER NOISE BULLSHIT OMG FUCK THEM SPUTNIK IS TURNING INTO PITCHFORK MORE AND MORE OMG |
eternium
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel has one amazing album while Elliott Smith has a shit ton. |
acorncheese
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith.
If he does not win I will shoot somebody. |
Maniac!
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith |
BaconStarship
07.17.10 | Animal collective.
Fuch all yall haters! |
Slipping Away
07.17.10 | elliott smith by a mile |
Mr. Lizard
07.17.10 | Smith, because NMH has one good album |
acorncheese
07.17.10 | Smith, because his catalogue absolutely trumps that of AC and NMH. Flawless discography. |
Fugue
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel |
BigHans
07.17.10 | Elliott by a mile, the other two are shit. |
Enotron
07.17.10 | oh and AC should've been replaced with The National, either that or NMH being replaced with The National. |
Yeahtoast
07.17.10 | Smith. |
March_Of_Sand
07.17.10 | As awesome as In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is, Elliott Smith is just better. Elliot Smith gets my vote. |
cvlts
07.17.10 | I'll go with Nuetral Milk |
OhAliceMonster
07.17.10 | fuckin where are the other indie bands in this :/ this isnt fair whatsoever
|
ConsiderPhlebas
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith |
Romulus
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith by a lot |
Jethro42
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel |
OpethFreak
07.17.10 | Animal Collective |
TRMshadow
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith, Duh!
NMH is amazing, and Aeroplane is a classic, but Elliott was way more consistently solid over a far longer period of time. |
klap
07.17.10 | elliott smith |
Thor
07.17.10 | Elliott Smith >>>>>>>> rest of list |
skippingboy123
07.17.10 | the shins! |
Jethro42
07.17.10 | I confess I hesitated with Elliott. I chose NMH just because I listen to their music more often. |
salival13
07.17.10 | Elliot Elliot Elliot ELLIOT!
would be an abomination if AC wins...just ugh |
East Hastings
07.17.10 | Elliott, I guess. |
Pizza
07.17.10 | elliott smith |
couldwinarabbit
07.17.10 | This is the hardest desicion of my life, might be cause I'm 12 deep but regardless.
Are we counting Avey Tare and Panda Bear's solo careers. cause if they so they win
Elliot Smith has so many excellent album though
then we have NMH who has one good album. Well good is an understatement. In the Aeroplane over the Sea is without a doubt one of the top ten albums of all time.
God Damn it. |
DiceMan
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel |
ShadowRemains
07.17.10 | "This is the hardest desicion of my life, might be cause I'm 12 deep but regardless."
um.......wow
in any case, elliott |
Emim
07.17.10 | FUCK ANIMAL COLLECTIVE.
My vote is for Elliot Smith[2] |
DarthBlubber
07.17.10 | Animal Collective |
chaseguitar
07.17.10 | Elliott smith. Best artist ever brah. |
Blindsided
07.17.10 | NMH. |
WeepingBanana
07.17.10 | ITAOTS is my fav album of all time but elliott smith has just been so consistently amazing.
gotta give it to elliott smith |
couldwinarabbit
07.17.10 | fuck it
Neutral Milk Hotel cause ITAOTS is just so so so so so so so so so so so so so so so |
couldwinarabbit
07.17.10 | GOOD!!!! |
Labeasy
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel
|
Yazz_Flute
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel |
Ire
07.17.10 | academy is my hero
really though, fuck animal collective hard in the ass |
luci
07.17.10 | NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL. |
Dryden
07.17.10 | worst list ever |
luci
07.17.10 | best list yet |
Motiv3
07.17.10 | The National |
McCopper
07.17.10 | Neutral milk hotel |
SlightlyEpic
07.17.10 | elliott smith
anybody that votes otherwise can suck my dick |
Ire
07.17.10 | elliott smith
because indie hipster bullshit can foad |
SlightlyEpic
07.17.10 | yeah there shouldn't even be any competition |
Fapper
07.17.10 | What's with the AC hate.. vote goes to Elliott |
TRMshadow
07.17.10 | I can kind of see why some people might NMH (some people like more of a folksey sound to their indie), but honestly, this isn't even a fight; Elliott Smith will win, and AC will come in last by far. |
DBlitz
07.17.10 | Neutral Milk Hotel |
therayder
07.17.10 | In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is one of the best albums ever, but Elliott Smith has the better discography, so
Elliott Smith |
Prolapse
07.17.10 | I want to pick NMH but they only have one album
So Elliott Smith |
Prolapse
07.17.10 | good* |
AliW1993
07.17.10 | NMH |
Lambda
07.18.10 | VOTING OVER
Elliot Smith - 28
Animal Collective - 5
Neutral Milk Hotel - 12
Elliot Smith wins |
eternium
07.18.10 | Damn right. Go Elliott. |
skippingboy123
07.23.10 | the shins!!! |