Hawks
06.09.10 | A lot of people might disagree with some of the bands on this list, but I think it's fucking awesome. |
Obfuscation24
06.09.10 | Nice list man, 1 7 9 16 24 25 34 35 38 are all great
Not sure Cannibal Corpse should be on here though lol |
Gmork89
06.09.10 | Very good list indeed. |
qwe3
06.09.10 | no.
|
buckfutter
06.09.10 | If you include In Flames on a Best of Metal list, Qwe dies a lil inside |
Hyperion1001
06.09.10 | It's trve kvlt to say 10 and 37 are sell-outs, but their old material was quite good. Nice list. Only band on here i can't stand is 34. |
SCREAM!
06.09.10 | I died a little cause of Cradle of Filth
Lots of good but a andful of questionable choices too. Needs more kvlt |
qwe3
06.09.10 | "If you include In Flames on a Best of Metal list, Qwe dies a lil inside"
well not just them but yeah
made worse by the fact that this guy considers them death or black metal |
TheSpirit
06.09.10 | Ehh I would disagree with this list even though no band on it is horrible. |
Gmork89
06.09.10 | Man, all this hate for In Flames makes me sad. |
buckfutter
06.09.10 | It depends on how you look at it, Qwerty my good friend. He could look at them as melodic death metal and think that validates his reasoning for them being on here.
TheSpirit- My sentiments exactly |
qwe3
06.09.10 | dude im sorry but you cant include suffocation and in flames on a dm list its one or the other yknow. make a melodeath list if you wanna do in flames but cmon |
buckfutter
06.09.10 | If you want to get particular and anal about it, then yeah, I agree with you. |
qwe3
06.09.10 | in flames =/= dm if you also think suffocation is dm
oh and btw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXFmNC3q4Es |
SCREAM!
06.09.10 | Suffocation is dm
In flames would be melo dm
Whiich is a sub genre of dm
Thus warranting a spot
Its not that complicated qwe man |
buckfutter
06.09.10 | Dammit, I can't watch it. This computer doesn't support any type of video, on account of it being from the Stone Ages |
qwe3
06.09.10 | "Suffocation is dm
In flames would be melo dm
Whiich is a sub genre of dm
Thus warranting a spot
Its not that complicated qwe man"
thats like saying FAV PUNK BANDS
and putting up the clash, assuck, pig destroyer, pg99, ceremony and shit
kinda awk |
buckfutter
06.09.10 | I see what you're saying Qwe, but I think you're being a bit too anal about it. Melodeath sounds more like death metal than pants like assuck and pig destroyer sound like punk |
SCREAM!
06.09.10 | Not really. Melodic death metal is a sub genre of death metal. What you said would be like having metallica alongside Burzum along with some Alestorm. Which all fall under metal but many different sub genres. Here were only talking of the sub genre DM along with the sub-sub genre Melo DM. |
qwe3
06.09.10 | idk inflames has never sounded like dm to me except for gutturals.
i mean melodeath like intestine baalism and arghoslent does but
w.e |
SCREAM!
06.09.10 | I could definitely put the older stuff under melo death personally, some of the new stuff id just put there cause it still seems the most fitting place |
FadeToBlack
06.09.10 | assuck sounds more death metal than melodeath |
qwe3
06.09.10 | "Not really. Melodic death metal is a sub genre of death metal. What you said would be like having metallica alongside Burzum along with some Alestorm. Which all fall under metal but many different sub genres. Here were only talking of the sub genre DM along with the sub-sub genre Melo DM."
yeah fair enough still point stands melodeath and death metal are too far removed for them to be one thing.
insomnium for example is nothing like incantation yet theyre considered both death metal. nahhhhhhh
and i mean fucking arch enemy? on the same list as CC? doesnt make sense.
oh and sepultra. cmon. |
SCREAM!
06.09.10 | Im surprised you havent brought up thhe point that this is a death / black list. Those two are much farther apart than death and melo death. I dont understand why theyre always thrown together |
qwe3
06.09.10 | well yeah but whatever at least hes acknowledging them as different.
unless he thinks these are all blackened death in which case lol |
FadeToBlack
06.09.10 | its the unwritten rule of sputnik that if you include melodeath in a 'death metal' list, u will get raped
and rightfully so |
qwe3
06.09.10 | f2b ilu |
FadeToBlack
06.09.10 | as for the list; its good, but the black metal bands are all really entry level and stuff (no offesne) |
Dryden
06.09.10 | i expected this to be a great great list, how wrong i was |
WithHorsesInHerEyes
06.09.10 | Possessed should be alot higher up. |
Blotto
06.09.10 | What's the best Obituary album? |
FadeToBlack
06.09.10 | Cause Of Death and Slowly We Rot are the only Obituary albums you need. |
Blotto
06.09.10 | Cheers |
McCopper
06.09.10 | Props for many of these but 50 sucks sooo baaaad... |
bigguy69
06.17.10 | I can't argue with Death being number 1. |
Ire
06.17.10 | in flames isn't death/black metal?
omg noway |
Helvete
06.17.10 | list is gay |
bigguy69
06.17.10 | 1. Death
2. Opeth
3. Atheist
4. Cynic
5. Bathory
6. Suffocation
7. Sepultura
8. Entombed
9. Autopsy
10. Deicide
11. Darkthrone
12. At the Gates
13. Nile
14. Obituary
15. Amon Amarth
16. Enslaved
17. Behemoth
18. Immortal
19. Cryptopsy
20. Dark Tranquillity
21. Pestilence
22. Cannibal Corpse
23. Necrophagist
24. Vader
25. Mayhem
26. Dissection
27. Edge of Sanity
28. Grave
29. Marduk
30. Hypocrisy
31. Arch Enemy
32. Napalm Death
33. Emperor
34. Rotting Christ
35. Krisiun
36. Immolation
37. In Flames
38. Morbid Angel
39. Carcass
40. Satyricon
41. Carpathian Forest
42. Beherit
43. Possessed
44. Celtic Frost
45. Burzum
46. Dimmu Borgir
47. Hellhammer
48. Venom
49. Mutilation
50. Cradle of Filth
|
Helvete
06.17.10 | lol cradle of filth and nile
u trying to out-gay him bro? |
EpXeh
06.22.10 | inclusion of cradle of filth, darkthrone not being higher. my face: >.> |
TheAngryPelican
07.03.10 | i find it kind of strange that people are angry because i put melodic DEATH METAL bands on a best of death and black metal list.
since when was melo death not death metal?
|
Hyperbore
07.03.10 | Did you simply name the 50 most recognizable death & black metal bands? Be honest... |
TheAngryPelican
07.03.10 | hyperbore,
no, this is simply the product of years of death metal and black metal music collecting, and analysis of said music. |