Brokenjewel
03.07.10 | They get rec'd quite a bit, dude. Not heard 1, 3 and 4 - love 2, though; especially the weird melodic bits. |
Powerban
03.07.10 | Pretty much agree with this list. The Beyond and Eternal Kingdom would probably switch around for me but it's still fine as it is. |
Wizard
03.07.10 | Huge CoL fan here, I did a review for 'Eternal Kingdom' and of course 'Salvation' is an easy 5/5. |
eternium
03.07.10 | I'd put 4 as 2. I just got Eternal Kingdom in the mail the other day. Salvation (which I just listened to) is my favorite, but it's almost twenty dollars for some reason, while Eternal Kingdom was eight.
1
4
2
3
5
All are amazing nonetheless. I wish they would tour America. |
Powerban
03.07.10 | And yeah, these guys are pretty much notorious in the post-metal scene. Maybe the 3rd most known behind Isis and Neurosis. |
Wizard
03.07.10 | MuzikManiac,
Rosetta are nothing like these guys. Post metal is vast territory. Plus, Salvation is a landmark in the genre and I have yet to hear Rosetta produce anything of that magnitude. |
eternium
03.07.10 | If I don't count Neurosis as true post-metal, then Cult of Luna is the second best band, closely behind Isis. |
Relinquished
03.07.10 | Huge fan of the band. Rating is correct, but even 3 is a 4.5
Rosetta sucks real bad compared Cult of Luna, but they're still good.
btw Neurosis > Cult of Luna > Isis > every other band |
Powerban
03.07.10 | Rosetta and CoL are at about the same level for me. Love them both. |
Wizard
03.07.10 | MuzikManiac,
I completely forgot about that album hahahahaha. I'm still a little shaken from the mediocrity that was Wake/ Lift. |
Athom
03.07.10 | i liked wake/lift...
Salvation fucking owns |
theilladelph
03.07.10 | Salvation is definitely in the top 3 post metal albums ever IMO... I 100% agree with ur list, 3 and 4 are close tho |
Powerban
03.07.10 | Monument off of Wake/Lift is completely amazing though. Also, that song Clavius they did on a split a while back has one of the best intros ever.
|
Burn2Burn
03.07.10 | 4, 1, 3, 2, 5 |
Photon
03.07.10 | thanks Guys
@wizard ..I have read you review awhile back ..I am guessing ur a big fan of Burst as well :) |
InFiction
05.19.10 | I haven't heard 5 or 3 yet. But everything else is spectacuar.
I would have to say 'Somewhere along the Highway' is my favourite. |
FadeToBlack
05.19.10 | from what I've heard
1
3
2
gonna get the other two albums now |
