scotish
01.08.10 | and incase anyone somehow missed it -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDDHHrt6l4w |
PanasonicYouth
01.08.10 | why would you put the comedian so low? he's like the most badass character ever
mine would be like...
1
6
3
2
4
5 |
intothepit83
01.08.10 | just to hear the way jackie earle haley's voice doin the voice over for rorshach made this movie for me. |
darthbarf
01.08.10 | rorschach messed people up |
scotish
01.08.10 | haven't seen the film yet, only read the comic; for the short bit of time we see the comedian he's either in a mental breakdown or being a dick, so he wasn't exactly inspiring. |
scotish
01.08.10 | or being chucked out of a window, actually |
Electric City
01.08.10 | dr manhattan has to go above nite owl who was a huge fucking pussy |
scotish
01.08.10 | nah dude nite owl was awesome if only cos of his ship |
LegendofPittman
01.08.10 | Rorshach = WIN |
Electric City
01.08.10 | uh three words for dr manhattan: giant blue penis |
darthbarf
01.08.10 | yeah nite owl needs to drop a bit.
ozymandias could go up. He caught a bullet. He caught it. |
BallsToTheWall
01.08.10 | Well judging from the movie, havent read the novel, and probaly never will, The Comedian was badass. Didnt like Ozymandias but respected his stance and Rorschach/Dr M. well yeah. Awesome. |
MUNGOLOID
01.08.10 | my ranking would look like this:
1
6
3
2
5
4
although watchmen was an amazing graphic novel, the same can't be said for the movie adaptation. it seems that zack snyder forgot the mood of the source material and instead of making it this raw and gritty take on superheroes, it instead felt like a glamorized music video with colorful special effects and a story plot that actually felt too quick.
the movie only (roughly) shows like 1/3 of what happens in the graphic novel and for that, that's where it suffers the most. and i also hated the actor who did Ozymandias. he overdid the character and made a little too obvious that he was the villain. |
robin
01.08.10 | V is 1 |
Tits McGee
01.08.10 | Rorschach is one of the greatest characters ever |
Fugue
01.08.10 | Rorschach for the win.
1, 3, 6, 4, 5, 2 for me. |
Freditron
01.10.10 | 1,6,3,4,2,5. |
ninjuice
01.10.10 | "instead of making it this raw and gritty take on superheroes, it instead felt like a glamorized music video with colorful special effects and a story plot that actually felt too quick."
We were definitely watching different movies. |
dylantheairplane
01.10.10 | "the movie only (roughly) shows like 1/3 of what happens"
You obviously didn't pay much attention. The movie follows the novel VERY closely. |