BrandNewBoognish: Shitty/Overrated Albums

BrandNewBoognish 12.30.09	Tried to make this list a bit more original than the usual overrated/shitty bands list on sputnik by including bands i actually am a fan of. These range from overrated (I Against I) to unlistenable cutesy bullshit (aim and ignite). Enjoy and sayonara as i will not be around sputnik again for a while, so this is an opportunity for some good old fashioned boog-hate.
Knott- 12.30.09	I agree about 2. 5 isn't the classic it's made out to be. 3, 6, 8, though... gots to hold different opinions.
pride 12.30.09	I agree with most of this list.
kitsch 12.30.09	1 is fucking amazing and not really overrated. i think its underrated. i agree on 3,4,5,6,7,8,9 (kind of a shitty b b album),10 2 is cool tho
supertouchox2 12.30.09	9 isnt that great your right, i agree with most of this. especially 8.
PaperTigers 12.30.09	I hate "overrated" lists, but I at least understand why somebody would hate on most of these bands....except Bad Brains. They were one of the only 80's hardcore bands that could competently play their instruments - why pick them?
shindip 12.30.09	4 7 8 9 10 are all great
ov420 12.30.09	wat a loser
Niceinvader 12.30.09	3 is soooooooooo disgustingly overrated
killrobotmusic 12.30.09	I can see how people would think 3 and 6 are overrated... very polarizing albums, though I happen to enjoy them. 8 is the only one I can't really see not liking unless you're not a fan of that type of music.
couldwinarabbit 12.30.09	Tool is terribly overrated on this site (Lateralus has the same rating as Kid A and Loveless). I can see someone thinking brand new and the SP are overrated though I personally enjoyed the albums. Neutral Milk Hotel- In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is very much hyped but only because it is without a doubt one of the best albums of all time.
PaperTigers 12.30.09	Tool and Radiohead are two sides of the same coin. They are both highly regarded almost everywhere - not just here.
SteelErectedb4you8er 12.30.09	I love I against I. The other albums, I see your point.
MindTrain 12.30.09	Tool songs sound like they don't know where they're going. You get an awesome intro, then a long quiet spot, then it picks up, then a quiet spot, and after 10 minutes when the song ends I feel like it never went anywhere. Seems more like repetition than progressive.
TheGreatD17 12.30.09	Are you saying all of these are shitty AND overrated? Because at least 6 through 9 are objectively not shitty.
Yotimi 12.30.09	6 is a work of pure artistic genius. I can understand the rest even though I like 7&8 a lot.
MindTrain 12.30.09	I don't know, 6 is good. I consider it a shit list because he explained nothing about any of the albums.
Jips 12.30.09	oooh ... edgy...
AnotherBrick 12.30.09	agreed on 6
BrandNewBoognish 12.30.09	I'm not trying to be 'edgy', you complete moron.
Bandido 12.30.09	Agreed on 3. I like 8 but it is a bit overrated
scissorlocked 02.13.10	10000 Days isnt shit.Maybe overrated but not shit
Emim 02.13.10	Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8
ThePalestMexican 02.13.10	I'm sorry, but that Bad Brains album pwned so good.
Slipping Away 02.13.10	I don't think 10,000 days is overated at all everytime it gets brought up people shit on it
Cavs 04.04.10	Get 1 and 9 out of there. Definitely agree with 6 though.
Dryden 04.04.10	agree with this list
OhAliceMonster 04.04.10	:/ tool is majorly overrated
theacademy 04.04.10	Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8Thou shalt be burnt at the stake for including 8
Ire 04.04.10	Fact: anybody who makes an "overrated" list is fucking stupid.
BSX 04.04.10	BE CALM!!!!!!!
eggsvonsatan 04.04.10	6 is fucking horrible and annoying. I'm glad you feel the same way.
theacademy 04.04.10	dude, nobody anywhere else thinks converge is good. try asking your mom what she thinks of jane doe. try playing it for some kids at school. they're all going to say its the sound a cow makes when you're uncle is raping it. if youre going to target overrated music, try looking outside of the sputnik niche. Animal Collective is (objectively speaking) ear torture. start there, and then move along the indie spectrum to everything else horrible about that subculture. its time to lave jane alone.
theacademy 04.04.10	my post was @shawnkemp/nonsynchro obviously...
eggsvonsatan 04.04.10	Agreed on animal collective. I feel like I can't walk into a coffee shop without hearing some scrawny white kid in a fuzzy sweater and tight pants talking about how they're the best band of our generation. I'll hang myself if that's how we're remembered in 20 years.