rasputin
10.18.09 | um no |
Prophet178
10.18.09 | Neither are sludge. Sleep is sludge.
Kylsea
High on Fire
Neurosis
Isis
|
rasputin
10.18.09 | rofl those arent even sludge either |
EverythingEvil2113
10.18.09 | maybe someone should define sludge? |
Zoo
10.18.09 | The Mire, Pelican, Intronaut, Mouth of the Architect, Minsk |
Mordecai.
10.18.09 | rasp, i don't think Prohphet was reccing him sludge, just bands that are similar to the ones in his list |
Prophet178
10.18.09 | I know those aren't sludge, they're recs for Mastodon and Baroness. |
Mordecai.
10.18.09 | anyway, get Irepress - Sol Eye Sea I. You won't regret it. |
rasputin
10.18.09 | sleep arent sludge either |
Zoo
10.18.09 | not really sludge but similar to baroness and mastodon. real sludge is like Grief, Unearthly Trance, Lair of the Minotaur, Ramesses, Omega Massif, Eyehategod, Abandon and what berk will probably say: Fistula, Moss, Noothgrush, and Corrupted. |
Prophet178
10.18.09 | I guess you have to enlighten me to what real sludge is. |
Burn2Burn
10.18.09 | wait wut neurosis are sludge. |
EyesWideShut
10.18.09 | Rasputin recs Sludge. go for it |
joshuatree
10.18.09 | get corrupted
that is all |
rasputin
10.18.09 | neurosis arent sludge
this is not me saying they are not good becuase i love neurosis, but they arent sludge |
iranscam
10.18.09 | ^knows what's goin on |
Burn2Burn
10.18.09 | ok so what are neurosis, post-rock? idk idk |
rasputin
10.18.09 | sludge:
grief
Noothgrush
Graves at Sea
buried at sea
Thou
EyehateGod
Zoroaster
Aldebaran
dot (.)
fistula
CORRUPTED
fleshpress
etc etc |
Mordecai.
10.18.09 | post-metal. Anyway they are just labels, Neurosis are Neurosis. |
rasputin
10.18.09 | that's exactly what i was going to say
neurosis are neurosis |
witchxrapist
10.18.09 | Intronaut, Swarm Of The Lotus, Knut (the three are like sludge metalcore, and I think you listen to them already).
Aside from them Eyehategod. |
Blindsided
10.18.09 | Thanks guys. I wasn't exactly clear on the sludge thing either. Prophet thanks. I'll check those out minus High On Fire, don't really like them. |
XulOnerom
10.18.09 | Every sludge thread should start and end with Acid Bath |
rasputin
10.18.09 | acid bath are terrible |
rasputin
10.18.09 | wait my bad, acid WITCH are terrible
havent listened to acid bath |
MaskAtTheMasquerade
10.18.09 | oh hello there Jordan Two Delta |
The Sludge
10.18.09 | I am sludge!
wtf are you all talking about! |
Countorous
10.18.09 | i would rec you some sludge but you wouldnt like it |
Mordecai.
10.18.09 | do it anyway, maybe i could take something from it |
qwe4
10.18.09 | high on fire destroys the two bands on your list dude... |
Countorous
10.18.09 | idk
goatsblood-drull
iron monkey-our problem
aldebaran-dwellars in twilight
paganus-self titled
thou-tyrant
arachnotaur-slow pertinacious threnody
anything by fleshpress |
AliW1993
10.18.09 | Melvins |
Phantom
10.18.09 | Dystopia |
rasputin
10.18.09 | good band but not really sludge |
FadeToBlack
10.18.09 | high on fire are pretty good |
MentalityOfA
10.18.09 | Describe Sludge please. |
rasputin
10.18.09 | listen to the bands and find out for yourself |
PaperTigers
10.18.09 | Can't believe it took that long for somebody to say Melvins.
Neurosis' first few CD's are definitely sludge - they didn't evolve into post-metal until a little later, and post-metal is basically an offshoot of sludge anyway. Mastodon and Baroness might not be completely sludge metal, but they have enough sludge influences that some people call them sludge.
Other sludge-ish bands you should check out based on your list are Burst, The Ocean, Giant Squid, and Torche. |
qwe4
10.18.09 | hahahaha burst sludge hahahaha |
Countorous
10.18.09 | yeah those 'sludge-ish' bands are post-metal and i wouldn't rec anyone giant squid ever. |
SpicsterGMex
10.18.09 | mastodon r sludge u dnt even kno |
Countorous
10.18.09 | sludgiest ov the sludge |
Wizard
10.18.09 | To clear the defining sludge thing up is somewhat complicated. I think alot of those bands that Prophet has mentioned incorporate some form of sludge in their music to a degree. However, those same bands mix it up with alot of other shit. Just listen to rasp on this for pure sludge rec's. Oh, and Neurosis are post-metal/ sludge. No denial there. |
PaperTigers
10.18.09 | He asked for "sludge proggy metal". Burst is proggy metal with some sludge elements (much more in their older stuff), and a lot of Mastodon fans like them. Neither of the bands he listed were straight up sludge, so I assumed that wasn't actually what he was looking for - I was just trying to rec him a few bands he might like.
And post-metal evolved from sludge, so there's no black and white line between them. |